Video Game Pirate Walks the Plank on 'Talk Like a Pirate Day'

Video Game Pirate Walks the Plank on 'Talk Like a Pirate Day'

September 20, 2007

Is it possible that the suits at the ESA have a sense of humor?

We have to ask because yesterday was International Talk Like a Pirate Day (Yarrr!) and, lo and behold, an e-mail arrived from the ESA trumpeting the jail sentence imposed on a game software pirate in California.

From the press release:


 

In June 2007, acting on a tip from ESA investigators, members of the Computer and Technology Crime High-Tech Response Team (CATCH) arrested [Frederick] Brown for trafficking in pirated game software. A search of his premises resulted in the confiscation of hundreds of illegal game discs. On August 1, 2007, Mr. Brown pleaded guilty to two felony counts of trafficking in counterfeit products.


Said Ric Hirsch, the ESA's IP enforcer:
 

We commend the work of the San Diego CATCH team and the San Diego County District Attorney’s Office. Sentences that include jail time send a clear message that violating intellectual property rights is a serious crime with significant consequences and violators will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.


Brown definitely took a lashing. On top of the jail time, the judge imposed a $100,000 fine and the convicted pirate must reimburse the ESA $10,000. And when he gets out, it's unlikely that Brown will be playing much Pirates of the Burning Sea, since his computer time will also be restricted.

So - if someone at the ESA planned the subtle humor behind all of this, well played!

If not, we'll just chalk it up as an incredibly serendipitous week for the video game biz, given that a federal judge in Oklahoma threw out that state's video game law on constitutional grounds on Monday, which just happened to be Constitution Day here in the United States.

Comments

I really don't understand how it is legal to restrict someones computer time, if someone if arrested for running from a cop, do you limit their exercise time? I dunno, seems not right for to me, it's not like he was hacking computer mainframes and releasing viruses and stuff to the world.
While Im not a big proponent of piracy, and I'm glad this guy got put away, the ESA, and much of the Media corperations on earth today, are directly responsible, in part, for piracy of there products.

While music and movies are not to big an issue, in the game world, there is a major part of it that has Led to piracy becoming rampant. Import gaming.

Many people, myself included, have often bought games legally from other countries, but due to the retarded region lockout that exsists on my my consoles, to play those games I have to use some means to circumvent this . As a result, it wasn't long before the same people who were legally circumventing region lockouts discovered they could use the same methods to play bootlegs, and thus, piracy took off.

Had there been no region lockout, piracy would have never gotten as popular as it has become, and in fact, some would argue that rather then using region lockouts, companies could have used better, more effective measures to thwart pirates while still allowing legal gamers to play there imports.

While Im a big supporter of the esa and the industry in general, i find little reason to celebrate when I see stories like this.

If the industry hadn't made it so hard to play legal games, there would have been no market for illegal games to begin with.

Least, thats my take on the issue.
@ Yuki,

I am sorry, I have to disagree. While region lockout is an annoying issue and a waste of time, it is not the source of game pirating. Pirating anything has been around since the advent of the printing press. It will always be around. Every time a new medium comes along, pirating expands in that direction. The only single source of pirating is the fact that there are people out there that want to make a buck off of other people's work.

But the industry is not doing all they can to prevent it though. I am not saying that I agree with DRM, just that it is possible to stop a lot of it. By making the game easier for the consumer to acquire and use, it will stop some forms of pirates. Pirates will always be around and the more DRM you put in, the more they work to get the games for free. But the easier the developer makes for real consumers to get the game, the less likely these consumers will go through less legal means to get it.
I hope the can justify the $110,000 fine in terms of the profit this guy made over time, else my sympathies for the ECA will soon go the way of my sympathies for the record companies that make up the RIAA.

Punishment should fit the crime, he must have pirated a lot of discs to have cost the ECA that much cash. The ridiculous amount will not be a deterrant for any other pirates, except not to be so blatent.
@ Knight

It's up to you what you belive, and thats cool. I've been in the emulaton scene for the past 15 years, and the most common reason why emulaton becomes popular, and the reason most of the people I know chose to pursue mod chips and other such devices, is not for piracy ,but for importing. Least that was my experiance.

my point being, that regional lockouts don't deter piracy, they only help to encourage it. If you used some other method that didn't prevent people from playing legally aquired imports, I would bet that you'd see a sharp decline in the use of modchips and other devices.

Personally, I think the DMCA is Garbage and should be revoked and banned, but thats me. DRM is a joke, the DMCA is a farce, and the media companies are using it as a club to attack the american citizen.

To me, thats the problem, no piracy.
@ odc04r

I think you mean the ESA

@ Yuki

I agree with you on region lockout. It is stupid. I just don't think it is as big of a player in the piracy thing as you seem to think. (although it is part of it.)
Ah yes, good point. ESA not ECA.
This wasn't piracy; this was the ESA and the ICE going after an innocent man who was getting around region lockout so they don't look like they're completely worthless.

To the ICE and the NSA that is probably watching this: ICE, go fuck yourself. You have proven time and again to be absolutely worthless, and just a draw on the taxpayers' dollars.
If i could link to that 'failure' sound from 'The Price is Right,' i totally would right now.
It's nice to see they quit bothering with those gang bangers and are taking out the real criminals, those evil media pirates (which make up a large amount of the population of the U.S. at this point, I believe...)
Wisk I Knew You...

The life of a child is very complicated in today's society. It helps to have someone you can turn to, trust, and look up to. Usually this is a parent or relative, but increasingly, it is a day-care center, an organized group for after- school care,...
Pirates suck!
Ninjas>Pirates!

Except GrĂ¡inne Mhaol, our national Heroine. She's alright.
@Austin Lewis:

Innocent man? It says in the article that he plead guilty to trafficking counterfeit products. It also says authorities found HUNDREDS of illegal discs. He wasn't just circumventing region lockout to play a few games; he may have even been selling illegal copies as well.

Don't let your hatred for the ICE blind you; this guy was no angel.
@ Hayabusa:

He wasn't an angel, but ICE has better things to do than be hit man for the copyright mafias.
There's a Fair Use Act of 2007 that's trying to get passed. Reps. Rick Boucher and John Doolittle are the one's sponsoring it. The EFF has a letter you can send to your representative. I was looking for a way to submit it to GamePolitics, but I couldn't see one.

Anyway, you can read more about it at:

https://secure.eff.org/site/Advocacy?cmd=display&page=UserAction&id=271
@JQuilty:

Agreed, but I was simply making the point that he's not innocent.
One thing thats making pirating so big with video games, is the absured cost of games these days, and the fact so many of them suck.

Movie -19.00
CD - 14.00
Videogame - 50-60.00

Then alot of people of course dont have that money but they want to play the game.

The biggest thing i wonder is.. I play steam games. Why the hell does a game thats compleatly digital cost the same if i bought it at the store?

Then there is the region lockout like yuki said, but things beyond the region lock out though.

You know, were the japense make a game for the PC (no lockout) but due to our anal retentive goverment, and just the fact its not very profitable sometimes, we never get it in the states.

So we import it, and then boom! they port it over, and we get attacked for piracy. (similar to anime)


But still i think the biggest contender is, Overhyped games, with greedy players/producers.

Like Lair. They go OMG lair tis the awsome, everyone play lair! play it play it play! look at the pretties! then compleatly blow the gameplay.

So now the players are out 50 dollars, and have a crappy game.

The BX here still is charging 40 dollars for IGN 2, and so that creates more problems.

They also went and bought like 200 copies of 50 cent bullet proof and didnt sell those well enough. So now they are out about $ 1,000.

And all sorts of other crud. lost train of though.. hunger... Dave and Busters soon.

ARG, Ye maties!
Okay, maybe I don't exactly agree with pirating games.

But the people who crack down on it aren't exactly good guys either.

Let's think about it.
If somehow pirating was stopped tomorrow, do you even think for a second that game developers would put more money into their games or pass down even a slight fraction of the extra money onto the consumer?

No chance in hell.
These people only make things we like because it makes them money. They know people are used to todays game prices, so why would they have a reason to lower them?
This is a business, not a charity.
i want to play this game

GamePolitics ShoutBox

Posted 07/04/09 at 06:33pm
Alyric: Of course, Mark falls into the common trap about Columbine, which had nothing to do with bullying, etc. See: http://slate.msn.com/id/2099203/?GT1=3256 for a more thorough explanation.
Posted 07/04/09 at 06:32pm
PHX Corp: Read this http://www.destructoid.com/sgc-09-liveblogging-the-jack-thompson-debate-138502.phtml#ext
Posted 07/04/09 at 05:54pm
PHX Corp: JT is afraid of such ban then advocates it That's what i call a total Hypocrite
Posted 07/04/09 at 05:50pm
PHX Corp: AE: JT is a -Bleeping- Jackass
Posted 07/04/09 at 05:07pm
Andrew Eisen: JT "knew it would be a good audience." Not what he said on Tuesday.
Posted 07/04/09 at 05:01pm
Andrew Eisen: VG cause violent behavior. VG companies influence behavior to get sales. Yeah, that makes sense. (To be fair, the Twitter feed makes deciphering JT's point pretty tough.)
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:52pm
Andrew Eisen: Yes, it's been proposed but as far as I know it has not been passed. Big difference.
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:50pm
Cheater87: http://www.gamezine.co.uk/news/formats/xbox360/all-violent-video-games-be-banned-in-germany-$1301757.htm
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:49pm
Andrew Eisen: Far as I know, Germany has not banned all violent video games.
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:44pm
Cheater87: Jack wants the US to follow Germany's total video game ban.
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:42pm
Andrew Eisen: Note to JT, it is not illegal to sell kids a ticket to R-rated movies.
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:39pm
Cheater87: Jack said we would be better with no rating sytem.
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:35pm
Alareth: So what was the introduction used for Jack?
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:31pm
JDKJ: Heard one, you've heard 'em all. He repeats the same act, with the same half-truths, over and over.
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:31pm
Andrew Eisen: Using a credit card as age verification is not illegal. Hope Mark called him on that and his made up statistics.
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:30pm
Alareth: Jack is special, his mommy always told him so.
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:29pm
Andrew Eisen: JT lied about that APA causation thing again. Wonder if Mark called him on it.
Posted 07/04/09 at 04:04pm
Andrew Eisen: Follow the JT/Methenitis debate on Twitter: http://twitter.com/jtdebate
Posted 07/04/09 at 01:18pm
Andrew Eisen: Rodrigo - A fun idea but you might want to fix the typos.
Posted 07/04/09 at 12:57pm
GRIZZAM PRIME: Happy 4th of July!
Login or register to post shouts