
Last year
GamePolitics brought you
news of a game content site aimed at parents.
Founded by former EGM editor John Davison and former Ziff-Davis colleague Ira Becker,
What They Play aims to provide parents with "neutral, objective information" on games.
Yahoo! tech blogger Dory "The Mom" Devlin
checked out What They Play at the recent Consumer Electronics Show (CES), and came away impressed. Combining game information and user-submitted review, Amazon.com sales charts, ESRB ratings, game categories, and age groups, the site works at being a complete resource for parents looking for information about any game, on any platform.
What wowed Devlin most was the community participation factor:
The real value of the site will be in the comments, where parents (and, obviously, anyone else) can ask questions of each other and post their opinions about the games.
CM: What They Play's information on games was surprisingly neutral and detailed. As an example, the info for
Manhunt 2, described on Common Sense Media as "an appalling choice" and "a mediocre yet disgusting experience", was very descriptive, but made no judgment either way about the content. ESRB descriptors were expanded on, describing scenes, language, and actions that may have contributed to the ratings, and it even touched briefly on the controversy surrounding the rating. But I found it tried hard to stay neutral, aiming to provide as much information as possible to allow the parents to make the decision for themselves.
The only flaw I noticed in the community involvement theory was the idea that parents "vote" on age appropriateness for each game. Each game spouts a "Parents agree. [Game] is OK for kids over the age of : [age]". Somehow I doubt parents are voting for
Manhunt 2 to be 14+...
- Reporting from Canada, GP Correspondent Colin "Jabrwock" McInnes
Comments
Not trying to criticize, but critique.
I like the site. I have not gone in depth into it, but I have looked around.
He's banned at the moment, I believe, what with the trial still going on.
Sarcastic Gamer did a little story about it a little bit ago
http://sarcasticgamer.com/wp/index.php/2008/01/too-simple-for-parents.ht...
This is a pretty good clearing house for finding out "these things" if they choose to. After all, the ESRB descriptors on the box, though more detailed than film descriptors, can still be elaborated upon so that parents can truly understand what's going on in a game in as much detail as possible.
I have no idea what your beef with this website is, not at all.
"Bullets tear through body armor and into flesh, explosions throw combatants around like rag dolls, and corpses litter the battlefield in the aftermath of each skirmish."
while anyone who's played CoD4 knows that the blood only shows if the person getting shot is standing directly adjacent to a wall, and even then its nothing more than a simple blood decal on the wall that fades after a few minutes, and a grenade exploding at your feet only throws you back.
For the most part though they stick to a very literal interpretation of what is actually in the game.
we've all heard the many people claiming that the popular game
Mass Effect has a explicitly graphic sex scene, and you can even have
a homosexual sex scene (heh that sounded funny). While lawyers, politicians, and online "journalist"
(I quote journalist because while a journalist is supposed to do research on his or her subject. All to often online "journalist" in place of actually doing research they simply jump to conclusions, make up "facts" and start the article with the preconceived notion of 'all games are bad, and game developers want nothing more than to ""corrupt todays youth"")
Anyway, while most of the recent articles that have been posted here on GP about Mass Effect have been some lawyers, politicians, and online "journalist" personal crusade against sex in games and how this game has been marketed to little 15 year old boys and now their little minds are ruined because they saw about 10-15 seconds of bare HIP.
Needless to say I was surprised when the review from "What They Play" had this to say of the scene
"While described as “the sex scene” by anyone that’s heard of it, what the player actually sees is little more than the naked hips of one of the female characters as she moves up the body of her lover. The scene then fades to black."
in the same paragraph the author goes on to say that in order for you to even get the option of sex in the game you have to create a relationship between characters in the game and continue it through out the entire course of the game. The Author also notes that it is entirely up to the player to chose to or not to pursue a relationship.
all and all i was glad to see a site that was honest and even the reviews of the parents were very fact-based and truthful