March 13, 2008 -
A footnote in the video game violence debate has been sentenced to die by an Oklahoma jury.As reported by the Associated Press, jurors deliberated for eight hours before passing a death sentence on Kevin Underwood, 28. The same jury had earlier found Underwood guilty of first-degree murder in the horrific 2006 killing of 10-year-old Jamie Rose Bolin.
So what is Underwood's connection to the game violence debate?
In a 2006 hearing before the Louisiana Legislature, Rep. Roy Burrell cited Underwood's heinous crime as an example of the supposed negative effects of violent video games. Burrell was, at the time, attempting to persuade his colleagues to pass Louisiana's Jack Thompson-authored video game bill. He succeeded, although the law was later ruled unconstitutional. As I wrote for Joystiq at the time:
Burrell related [to his colleagues] the story of an Oklahoma man accused of the horrendous murder of a child. Why he chose this example... remains unclear, since the 26-year-old suspect was no kid, and the "violent" game he played, Kingdom of Loathing, is a non-retail, non-industry, online product in which stick figures – stick figures! – battle one another... His bill would have no impact on the very example he raised to support it.
A defense psychiatrist who argued that Underwood's life should be spared testified that the killer had cannibalism fantasies, "gave up on being normal," and suffered from deviant sexual disorders, deep depression, a socially isolating personality disorder, and bipolar disorder.
But, probably it was the video games...



Comments
Re: Kingdom of Loathing Gamer Sentenced to Death
But if tennis or bowling were hobbies of his, they wouldn't have thought to mention them. Of course bowling wouldn't make him do anything crazy. Neither would reading book after book about serial killers. Nope. No way.
Re: Kingdom of Loathing Gamer Sentenced to Death
Good God they were not joking on the forums.
Ye God they can't be serious.
No. Just NO. Not KoL. Not associated with a killer. No. This is a dream. No.
...methinks it's Rep. Burell that needs psychiatric attention, if he thinks KoL can contribute in ANY way to crime.
Re: Kingdom of Loathing Gamer Sentenced to Death
Oh well, there's no such thing as bad advertising in the world of multi-player on-line games. Even if this story is two years old I say we take this canibalistic baby and run with it...metaphorically, of course.
:)
Re: Kingdom of Loathing Gamer Sentenced to Death
Give all oxigen breathers the electric chair!!! From this post it is platently obvious the the killer breathes oxygen... Is it not obviouse that the killer instinct lives in oxygen? He must be an Oxygenarian
Re: Kingdom of Loathing Gamer Sentenced to Death
Re: Kingdom of Loathing Gamer Sentenced to Death
You're KIDDING ME.
*facepalm*
So…we should just let it go, even though he murdered a 10-year-old? Or…we should let him rot in a prison for the rest of his life…? Which would be such a good option, he would fit in soo well with Bubba and all the other inmates for what he did…I guess I’m slightly confused about what the defense psychiatrist was saying… "
Trying to get a plea of insanity...I'm guessin the psych is a pacifist or doesn't believe in the death penalty....
I'm sure that many of the people that commit these crimes have played video games, so matching this crime with KoL should not happen.
"Responsibility for the responsible."
please, stick figures in a click-without-violence web-based game don't make you murder.
Unfortunetly that would be every singleone of us according to Bruce.
He's getting what he deserves.
Why would this case be used as evidence of a need for video game legislation? There are so many other examples that would have been relevant. If he was 26 at the time of the murder and roughly that age at the time he started playing the game in question, how would legislation have "helped". Even if it was a game published by a major company for a platform or PC, it would not have prevented him from buying it. And if it would, that's presents a whole new set of problems.
Note: I really don't want a crime to be commited just so this is tried.
Ooo! Bejeweled!
"Fifa 09 was so crap I just HAD to shoot up that football stadium!!!"
Lol. You just reminded me of this.
http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2001/01/08
You can't have it both ways. Either video games (and by extension, the rest of the media) are harmless, or the jails should be emptied since everyone there was brainwashed and not responsible for their actions.
I'm not shedding a tear for him though.
No local news outlets have chosen to play it that way. (pun not intended)
E. Zachary Knight
Divine Knight Gaming
OK Game Devs
Random Tower
Lol!
Reporter: So why did you kill your friend?
Accused: *beeeeep* beat me in Sonic and Mario Olympic Games!
I can see it now, a 29 year old charged with some horrible crime, medication, drugs, emo-poetry found at his house. All his aquantinences will say how crazy he was, his psychiatrist will say how the police were warned. He will have painted the crime on his wall with his own feces.
Then someone will find Peggle in his browsers history and he will be the Video Game Criminal on Faux News.
So...we should just let it go, even though he murdered a 10-year-old? Or...we should let him rot in a prison for the rest of his life...? Which would be such a good option, he would fit in soo well with Bubba and all the other inmates for what he did...I guess I'm slightly confused about what the defense psychiatrist was saying...
However, bringing games into this benefits no one, and if he is let off with it, common sense is done for.
Neither does the defence psychiatrist said anything related to video games. Only Burrell made the inexistent link. No one except him condemned video games, not even the psychiatrist (who would be the person I usually expect to say that). A point that most people who commented seems to miss.
Or he just believes that the guy's actions were caused by a medical condition he couldn't help having.
I don't know about Oklahoma law in particular, but it's likely that someone found not guilty due to insanity would be sent to a mental hospital until they were cured (which may well be never).
However, while I support the death penalty, I have no faith in the fair application of the death penalty in the state of Oklahoma. The state is notorious for denying defendants in capital cases the most basic protections and resources to ensure that a death sentence is arrived at fairly.
I recommend "The Innocent Man" by John Grisham. It is the true story of how a man in Oklahoma was railroaded by police and prosecutors and came within days of being executed for a murder he did not commit. After reading it, I cannot support any death sentence in Oklahoma until the state fundamentally reforms how it handles capital cases.
Virtually all officials city, state, and federal government are elected not be votes but by money and who shells out most of it.
But there are a few minority cases when a person like this one with a Cannibalism fettish kills someone because of their unstable state of mind.
But it is not the games or the fetish that is responsible, because he chose to do the crime. And he did not take any responsibility for his actions,
To blame his actions on Videogames or bizarre sexual fetishes is an overtly simplistic and a wrong thing to do because I know from my own life experience that my own fetishes are just fantasy, and only will ever be a fantasy. Just like the Videogames that I love to play.
Sadly not all people have a degree of what is fantasy and what is reality.
"DAMN THOSE STICK FIGURES"
yeah those stick figures are really evil( yeah right)
later on if somebody made a game of stick figures using real popsicle sticks will we hear something dumb now???
Doesn't Viacom own a part of Midway?
------
Anyway, as I stated/speculated when Dennis first editorialized Burrell's asinine testimony: "If it were to be found out that Kevin Underwood is related by blood/marriage to American Idol champ and country music star Carrie Underwood(and it's very possible as they're both from Oklahoma), would the same rhetoric that's heaped on the video game industry be heaped on Nashville(as it should, as they've cashed in on 9/11 more times than Jack has tried to cash in on youth violence)?"
No, Viacom isn't a major shareholder in Midway Games. Sumner Redstone, who owns a big share of Viacom also owns about 87% of Midway.
No. Viacom doesn't own Midway.
Hmm well I don't have cannibalism fantasies, I guess he and I are different. Besides, I suspect that human would not be very nutritious and I'm not sure what type of side dish I'd serve. Is salad appropriate or would rice be better?
Giving up on being normal should NOT be counted as a negative thing, normal is just a synonym for boring!
*shakes her head in disgust*