On V-Tech Anniversary, Morality in Media Prez Sees 1st Amendment "Suicide Pact"

April 16, 2008
Watchdog group Morality in Media marks the one-year anniversary of the Virginia Tech massacre with a press release in which MiM president Robert Peters (left) blames violent media for Hseung Hui Cho's murderous rampage.

Peters also refers to court rulings upholding the First Amendment as turning the Constitution into a "suicide pact."

From the press release:
Undoubtedly, there are loopholes in our nation's gun control laws that need plugging, but in remembering that the Virginia Tech killer used guns to slaughter fellow students, we should also remember that the killer grew up in a culture that glamorizes and even celebrates gun mayhem.

...the media [V-Tech anniversary coverage] should also be reporting on the irresponsible TV shows, films, rap lyrics and video games released in the past year that wallow in deadly gun violence and that are popular among children and young adults.

The media should also reconsider its blind adherence to modernistic Supreme Court decisions that have made it almost impossible to hold entertainment media companies responsible for harm caused by their reckless disregard for human life. Surely, this was not the intent of our nation's founding fathers, which never meant for the Constitution to become a 'suicide pact.'
Buzz It

Comments

Robert Peters, despite my complete disagreement with every word out of your mouth, I will defend your right to say them.

I'm sure the founding fathers would agree with my thinking on Free Speech, and not yours.
~~All Knowledge is Worth Having~~

Victimization comes to mind,like in the N'gai article(he had his panties in a wad over the trailer appearing to be racist only hes seeing it through the eyes of non white kids/people from other countries knowing full of the context of what he is seeing...) .

What I am getting at is that lets victimize the perpetrator as a sad crazy man who got him some guns and went on a killing spree only to blame the guns for him being crazy or the media he consumed as some sad and shallow attempt to explain why humans can be vile.

Crazy is crazy is crazy a tool or weapon a book or video wil not remove that fact, intact I would wager it aids release of stress(in legal ways) more than it makes crazy people criminals.

I'm sorry... entertainment companies didn't pull the trigger, Cho did...

I find this socially reprehensible, the eroding of (excuse the French) fucking personal accountability, he, although suffering from an illness, and perhaps being inspired by literature and shouldn't have a gun in his possession, made a choice to fire that gun, a premeditated choice.

Only that wanker is truly accountable, using a broken system to procure the means to do so.

Preventing another V-tech requires 2 things, an improved mental health system, & tighter gun laws, not the scapegoating of pop culture, which hasn't turned the masses into psychotic killlers...

Ah what Stephen King doesn't get a mention for equally destroying our society? Come on the Dead Zones Rape scene was far superior in disturbing content then that of Rambo nya.

Why does he conveniently disregard the role that psychotropic drugs have played in so many of these tragedies?

Cho Seung Hui
Eric Harris
Dylan Klebold
Kip Kinkel
Jeff Weise
Ted Kaczinski
Michael McDermott
John Hinckley
Byran Uyesugi
Mark David Chapman
Charles Carl Roberts IV

All on potent psychotropics AFAIK.

@E.Z.K.: Perhaps he's referring to Supreme Courts on the state level? Then again, perhaps he's just another "watchdog" barking at the moon.

----
Papa Midnight

That's exactly it Sean. Though history is forgotten upon fools like this...

Way to use the very tragic murders of 30+ people to further your own fucking agenda. Shitfuck, burn in hell, you cockmuncher. There, I'm practicing MY right to MY (and here's the key word) /FREE/ speech.

Ooh... I almost forgot to post this. It's required reading for any bill of rights argument.

"Any society that would give up a little liberty to gain a little security will deserve neither and lose both." - Ben Franklin, one of the greatest minds of our nations history.

Perhaps before stating the obvious that "Cho had mental illness problems", people here should read the press release more carefully. Namely:

"the media [V-Tech anniversary coverage] should also be reporting on the irresponsible [...]"

The keyword here is "also". He's not singling out violent culture as the sole cause of the shooting, he's trying to add it to the many causes that contributed, each in a different way, to the tragic events.

There is not a single issue, nor is there a single solution, and lambasting someone because he is focusing on one particular facet of the problem is being narrow-minded.

@DarknessDeku

Of course it won't, but we need to make our voices heard too.

I heavily disagree with that man's perspective. The constition was set up in the way it did because without being able to truly speak your mind, how can man truly critize how dark mans heart can be. I don't want to depth about european history at the time of the founding fathers, but you got to remember what europian countries did in the name of religion at the time.

The first admendment is the foundation of every matter in our government. When people start talking about restricting the 1st admendment, it really worries me. These groups that try to resrict the 1st ad. in the name of morality don't know that if they are sucessful in placing heavy restrictions on the first admend., they would be placing this country's morality in serious danger. Without the ability to critize corruption, libel, and defamation; this country would fall about in a matter of a few weeks.

It upsets me seeing other christians attack the first admendment just hurts me emotionly. I don't mean to bring religion into this but, we (in our faith) believe that man is corrupt. Without being able to openly discuss how dark mans heart can get, chaos ensues. And the first admendment helps ensure the ability to talk openly about these things. This is where I have a strong disagreement with that man about the first admendment being a 'suicide pact'. These christian groups trying to restrict the first admendment would end up hurting christianity itself.

This man doesn't want the 1st amendment, fine. It doesn't have to apply.

To him.

Man, this guy has reached a new level of low, bashing the 1st Amendment saying that freedom of speech should be restricted? ARE YOU FREAKING SERIOUS!!! What he just said really pissed me off. It's these guys who preach openmindedness yet at the same time consider the Constitution stupid that really give society a black eye. If you don't like the idea that USA has given others a right to have a choice, then get out of our country!!! Calling the founding fathers and their ilk who have given their blood sweat and tears to allow freedom idiots just goes to show that you sir, have no business being here. Don't blame TV, don't blame movies, don't blame guns, don't blame video games, and don't blame the 1st Amendment. If anything, blame bad parenting, blame overzealous bullying, and above all BLAME THE PERSON WHO DID THE SHOOTING!!!!!

The guy is saying we should have been following the media released in the last year? I think that's a terrible idea. Anything that effected Cho happened during his entire lifetime not just in the last years of his life.

Even the purpose to look at things that 'glamorize' violence is stupid. There have been movies that pushed the limits of the cultural bounderies since the first motion picture.

Why won't these idiots realize the racism and bullying Cho Seung went through? If humans learn how to treat each other not like shit, V-Tech would of never happened.

Of course Christian wackos like these guys always blame "violent media" because of their refusal to believe that humans are capable of treating other humans like if they're a inferior race.

@MasterAssassin

HA! Yeah, it's the video games, certainly not the butt-rape that's causing the decline of the church!

@GrimCW

Did you read my earlier post on a *very* interesting sect of Buhddaism? That's a pretty cool religion.Hehhehheh....

I love how he calls these things irresponsible.
TV? V-Chip and show ratings
Film? MPAA ratings and DVD parental controls
Music? Parental Advisory stickers
Video Games? Parental controls and game ratings.

It's not irresponsible to make these. It's irresponsible to criticize these as being irresponsible instead of looking at the REAL issues.

I remember reading an Uncle John's Bathroom Reader... one of the articles was about driving back when cars were first available to the public. There were doctors who claimed that women (just women) would lose brain equilibrium if they drove over 25 mph. And actually, when the car was starting to become widespread, the church dubbed it as evil. Of course, the automobile (whose name is a bastardization of two languages) has become an integral part of modern life.

These media haters don't have the basic grasp of cause and effect. Many elements in controversial media aren't a cause for bad things happening. They're often (not always) an effect of bad things happening. So instead of looking to the ROOT causes, they just find this scapegoat which is nothing more than effect.

And it, again, goes back to PARENTS. The problem is not that media exists, but rather that media is taking the place of parents for valuable life lessons. If I was growing up seeing nothing but violence, yeah, I might be violent too. But since I had parents to put things into CONTEXT, I grew up relatively well adjusted.

Parents: listen to what your kids listen to. Watch what your kids watch. Talk with your kids. The more levels of communcation that are up, the more likely your kids will come to you for help in difficult moral decisions. Don't blame media for your mistakes.

[...] Via GamePolitics. “The media should also reconsider its blind adherence to modernistic Supreme Court decisions that have made it almost impossible to hold entertainment media companies responsible for harm caused by their reckless disregard for human life. Surely, this was not the intent of our nation’s founding fathers, which never meant for the Constitution to become a ’suicide pact.’ [...]

"despite the fact there is no solid evidence connecting most any of these shootings to any games at all."

should be tagged in there somewhere.

oye, whats next for these people to attack when the games thing has died off?
any chance they'll take on the real threat? bad parenting and corrupt government?

hmm nah, on second thought, that'd be to easy to prove. We gotta stick with stuf that can be controversial and hard to prove.

"the goal of the conferences, according to one former government official, is to build a better system for sharing classified cyber-threat data with private companies."

Wow... in 1 sentence they were able to spew enough ignorance for the past century. Perhaps they should have included Jazz music, Interracial marriage, and gay pride.

Truce on the 2nd-amendment-gun-stuff for now?

This guy is an idiot with no regard for free speech.
How can he claim that entertainment media are recklessly harming human life? Hell, Cho wasn't into violent video games and stuff, so why would reporting on "the irresponsible TV shows, films, rap lyrics and video games released in the past year that wallow in deadly gun violence and that are popular among children and young adults."

crap... wrong paste

"…the media [V-Tech anniversary coverage] should also be reporting on the irresponsible TV shows, films, rap lyrics and video games released in the past year that wallow in deadly gun violence and that are popular among children and young adults."

THAT's the quote I wanted.

I believe next are games which are controlled by your thoughts... (they are being developed right now)
I am sure they will claim that this makes you program your brain to always want to kill our something along that sort...

Huh, I thought it was because he was "mentally ill and in need of hospitalization". Well, I guess I can be wrong from time to time.

Oh, by the way. Robert is a complete dick for seizing upon the anniversary of a horrific event to further his agenda.

There are my unasked two-cents.

I'm pretty sure the whole point of the 1st amendment is to protect speech some may find objectional, and the idea that this is somehow a "suicide pact" is ridiculous fear-mongering.

Acknowledging that there are "loopholes" in gun control laws and then going into a rant about the dangers of video games makes this peice seem almost ironic. Even if you want to believe that Cho was inspired to murder by Sonic the Hedghog (that was the game referenced in the final report, wasn't it?), he still couldn't have pulled it off without convenient access to guns.

If the media wants to report on irresponsibility, then maybe they should focus onn the irresponsible parents who let their kids watch/listen to/play forms of entertainment made for adults. The world is not made of Nerf, and not all of it is (or should be) appropriate for kids.

...And yet another know-nothing, opportunistic douchebag uses this tragedy to attempt to push his own agenda.

"The media should also reconsider its blind adherence to modernistic Supreme Court decisions that have made it almost impossible to hold entertainment media companies responsible for harm caused by their reckless disregard for human life."

Wow, bold statement. I seriously doubt ANY employee within the videogames sector has "a reckless disregard for human life". We're geeks, for crissakes - not sociopaths!

[...] wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptWatchdog group Morality in Media marks the one-year anniversary of the Virginia Tech massacre with a press release in which MiM president Robert Peters (left) blames violent media for Hseung Hui Cho’s murderous rampage. Peters also refers to court rulings upholding the First Amendment as turning the Constitution into a “suicide pact.” From the press release: Undoubtedly, there are loopholes in our nation’s gun control laws that need plugging, but in remembering that the Virginia Tech killer used guns to slaughter fellow students, we should also remember that the killer grew up in a culture that glamorizes and even celebrates gun mayhem. [...]

Im going to say what everybody right now is thinking about Moby Dick here,

You sir are a fat fat fat fat lard bucket who deserves to crawl back to the depths of heck from whence you came. 31 people killed and you want to use this as a launchpad for your political issues?

Well then you ambulance chasing tub of fat, you are a sick human being on the level of Hitler for doing so.

This time of year we should ask for the souls of those taken away so prematurely rest in peace, we should never forget nor should we use this as a weapon against others. The man who performed the shooting was sick in the head, do not blame guns or games or the media in fact dont blame anyone at all.

What happened to the time where the killers were blamed for the crimes they committed? Now parents groups, media enforcement groups all want a piece of the so called violent media. These people are inconsiderate and disrespectful to those who perished.

So Mr.Media Prez. please for the benefit of this planet go dig a hole and stay there for the rest of eternity.

modernistic Supreme Court decisions


What in the world does he mean by that? Of course he is an idiot. AS far as I know, the Supreme Court has yet to rule on anything regarding violent media.

So much for that argument.

According to their own website, they've been doing that since 1962. But as I previously said for Phyllis Schlafly : relax, it's just Morality in Media.

I'm sure that the fact that the man had a history of mental illness had nothing to do with what happened. And while we're talking about the intent of the founding fathers tell me do you think when the second amendment, when the only guns the existed could be fired at rate of about one shot per minute (if you were pretty fast), that they had any concept that people would be able to by things such as assault rifles or even semiautomatic handguns for that matter.

So... he doesn't believe in the bill of rights, or supreme court decisions..... WHAT!!>?!>>!>!>!>??!?!?!?!ONEONE Seriously, what's wrong with this man. Perhaps he should move to china. (Man, I've been saying that a lot lately)

Another watchdog idiot shooting his mouth of, great. As if this rhetoric wasn't tired enough, but now he's going right past gun control and into the realm of "TV DIRECTLY HARMS THE CHILDRENS!!!" If you ignore the fact that Chow as an anti-social, mentally unstable, gun-loving individual in the first place, you MIGHT have an argument. However, the guy watched wrestling and that was about it.

Additionally... Where the hell is this guy getting his statistics on gun violence? It's been going down for a while, last I checked. What a sensationalist jackass.

Ah another moron blaming things instead of people. Isn't the common thread in school mass murders someone who is insane? The #1 and #3 bloodiest mass murders in the US occurred long before video games (1927 in Bath Township Michigan and 1966 at the University of Texas respectively). Also, the one in Bath, did not involve guns the man responsible blew the elementary school up. Also, let's not forget that Charles Whitman (Texas Bell Tower sniper) had a large brain tumor, Cho was also extremely unstable (VTech), Andrew Kehoe believed that the school, rather the tax to build the school, was responsible for the foreclosure proceedings on his farm, this same man watched his stepmother burn to death, finally we've got Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold who might have been a clinical psychopath and depressant respectively.

It's not guns, it's not video games. It's a system which fails people. ALL of these people should have been seen as troubled and all of them should have gotten helped long before they snapped. They are tragedies in the truest sense of the word because they could have and should have been prevented had those that known the killers just been more observant.

That's a great idea. Let's restrict art and media to topics that government censors consider "safe" so that no one is exposed to anything that may be shocking or dangerous.

All this video game talk is only distracting from the real culprits: jazz music and short pants.

@Monkeythumbs
We’re geeks, for crissakes - not sociopaths!

I resent the inference that those two things are mutually exclusive, I sir/madam/MrGarrison (Circle where appropriate) happen to be BOTH!

As much as a reactionary massacre-profiting tool as this guy is, he may have a point. Think about the american constitution:

The first amendment guarantees free speech thereby allowing the creation of this suicide cult
The second permits the legal ownership of the guns used in such suicides that somehow manage (presumably through bad aim) to take out 30 other people first.
Isn't there also an amendment to guarantee you a trial by peers (AKA: Other sociopathic murdering gamers)?

Damn man, they create the cult, arm them & then give them a way to get off scott free by stacking the jury?? My god its a conspiracy of Thompsonistic proportions!

Good lord that set of my Bullshit meter about 100 times.

Do these people actually listen to themselves, even if all the evidance wasn't against them, there redicouls statments would make it seem like there crazy to begin.

it's scary to thing these people are wanting to be the moral compass for society at large isn't it?

Sorry bout my spelling. It's 5 am and i've not slept yet

Maybe they should focus less on entertainment media and more on the overwhelming amount of news coverage that every one of these shooters gets. Cho sent out his own press package, for fuck's sake. There's no real evidence that he was a big purveyor of violent entertainment (in fact it seems like he was less into that stuff than the average American young adult), but what was obvious was that he wanted his face and story plastered all over the news because that would make him instantly famous.

"Undoubtedly, there are loopholes in our nation’s gun control laws that need plugging, but in remembering that the Virginia Tech killer used guns to slaughter fellow students, we should also remember that the killer grew up in a culture that glamorizes and even celebrates gun mayhem."

Ummm, wasn't Cho mentally unbalanced? I'd say arming a fucking sociopath with violent tendacies in his past and a general disconnect with reality would be priority number 1. After all, this kid wasn't a gamer, he was a fucking playwrite. Quick, someone tell it on the mountains, West Side Story is a terrible influence on our children!

Hmm.. an anti-first amendment watchdog group uses the anniversary of a very unfortunate situation to opportunistically preach their anti-free speech stance.

Shocking!

[...] Game Politics is reporting that Morality in Media is using the first anniversary of the Virginia Tech tragedy to blame the massacre on the perpetrator’s use of violent media — btw, didn’t the violent game link get disproved mere days after the event? [...]

You know, idiots like this prove the point I make all the time.

Why does the industry sit and do nothing. Admittedly, in this case, this guy is just venting an opinion, moronic though it may be. but I can't fault the man for that, after all, he's not threatening lawsuits or specificly blaming anyone.

But, why is there no counter release from the industry, why no one saying "Hey, you got no evidance to back up your wild claims, we do have evidence that shows your wrong however."

Just a question, but, i'd like the industry to do something other then sit on it's rear like it always does.

what.
a.
cock.

Name a time when civilization DIDN"T grow up on a culture of violence.

The guy wasn't even listening to what he was saying... i say he just hates video games.

@Yuki

Because it's easier and acomplishes the same thing. They also don't want to risk making a martyr of one of those advocates.

I'm canadian, so I can't really comment on the first amendment intelligently.

What a douche. How could he assume that this nations youth is weak minded enough to be manipulated by those things? Do you have to be declared mentally retarded to have his job?
I am happy he is not manipulating his organization to attack video games in a real sense, but lots of people trust what he says. That statement may carry some weight with a lot of people. Yuki is right, the video game industry should shoot this one out of the sky.
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Andrew EisenThat article is over five years old, Uncharted. A fun blast from the past though.02/12/2012 - 10:47pm
Uncharted NESCritics: 'Left Behind' game glorifies violence- http://tinyurl.com/wu64s02/12/2012 - 4:34pm
ZenI felt Brutal Legends was a funny & beautiful look at the world of rock from Double Fines point of view. The only parts I wasn't hot for were the RTS bits as it felt forced. Otherwise fantastic.02/12/2012 - 1:34pm
DorthLousPassed 1.5M$. And I'd also say that Brutal Legend is far from being a bad game. I just think it was a few levels under what people expected from the people working on the project.02/11/2012 - 8:25am
TechnogeekBrutal Legend wasn't bad so much as "marketing had no idea how the game actually played", causing it to suffer accordingly.02/10/2012 - 10:38pm
RedMageIt looks the CIA's website has been DDOS'ed. Anon?02/10/2012 - 7:52pm
RedMageBrutal Legend.02/10/2012 - 7:52pm
ddrfr33kHas anything Tim Schafer ever made been of crap caliber? I'm struggling to think of one...02/10/2012 - 7:37pm
GuamishI think it is in good hands. Tim did a game for the GDC award show and that was fun for how short it was.02/10/2012 - 12:22pm
Andrew EisenIt'll be tragic if the game ultimately sucks.02/10/2012 - 12:17pm
james_fudge$1.3 million02/10/2012 - 11:32am
Uncharted NESGermany Says It Won't Sign ACTA [Update: ... Yet]- http://tinyurl.com/7r2twrg02/10/2012 - 11:21am
Andrew EisenDamn. Double Fine's Kickstarter fund has already passed a million dollars.02/09/2012 - 8:16pm
Andrew EisenAudrey didn't quote the sassy parts. Here's IGN's article: http://wii.ign.com/articles/121/1218359p1.html And here's my original post: http://tinyurl.com/7y68a3902/09/2012 - 7:50pm
james_fudgeI hope you some said something sassy! Where's the link?02/09/2012 - 7:46pm
Andrew EisenHey, neat. IGN quoted a blog I had writen only two hours earlier. I certainly timed that one pretty well.02/09/2012 - 7:38pm
Andrew EisenToki Tori has been added to the Humble Bundle for Android.02/09/2012 - 5:11pm
james_fudgeThanks for the heads-up DorthLous02/09/2012 - 4:33pm
DorthLousWill do, my apologies.02/09/2012 - 4:14pm
Andrew EisenI appreciate the heads up but please keep typo alerts to the specific article's comments or PMs.02/09/2012 - 3:33pm

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician