
Libraries are increasingly turning to video games to reach students.
To that end, as reported by the
Los Angeles Times, Friday has been designated
Gaming @ Your Library Day by the
American Library Association.
According to a survey by Syracuse University's School of Information Studies, almost one-quarter of U.S. libraries staged some kind of video game event in 2007. In Los Angeles County, teen use of public libraries has surged by 50% since a video game pilot program was introduced in 2006.
Said San Fernando librarian Lydia Harlan:
It lets teens be more comfortable with the library and become familiar with librarians. And it's what kids are into these days.
Penny Markey, coordinator of youth services for L.A.'s libraries, added:
Libraries have wonderful children's programs and programs for adults. But when it comes to programs serving teens, the numbers drop off. Games help us bridge that gap. It's a changing world. Teens are the next adults, the next taxpayers. And the library needs to be seen as an important and relevant resource for them.
Not every librarian agrees, however. The LAT reports on a blog entry by Steven M. Cohen, who operates
LibraryStuff.net:
Why do we have to lure kids into the library with candy? Shouldn't good literature be good enough?
Comments
hhmmm...
Books are some of the healthiest media for children. It helps encourage brain development. But what about those that have trouble reading? Tapes, TV, and movies are great too, but don't help the brain exersise as much, because of a more passive approach. But video games help kids learn better than any other, because of the interactivity. Brain activity goes through the roof. And people are starting to learn that.
Our university library recently started renting out games and interestingly enough in addition to games for the modern consoles someone seems to have dug up (pun intented) an old copy of Dig Dug for the C64. Funny to see that sitting on the shelves next to the 360, PS2,3 and Wii games.
They're already renting a few xbox games.
Why should they have games???
Besides why should anyone go to a library when most kids have access to more knowledge then they could possibly want inside their computer(with internet access)...
no wait, I was playing playstation
I do wonder if the libraries have the chance to offer other services/programs to the teens while the event is going on (and I wonder how the teens would react to something "interrupting" game time).
I think I still owe them five bucks for an overdue Gabriel Garcia Marquez that I never finished, though.
"Why spend so much time reading when you can just sit in front of a game or hey, if its a good enough book, they will just make a movie about it. That and reading just takes way too much time, I would rather lvl my warlock and pwn face. If I need to read a book for school, ill just sparknotes it."
Its these reasonings that lure youth away from reading and its sad tbh. Reading reallly is a great exercise for your mind, and what alot of people dont understand or know is that not only will it make you more intellegent, but many of the stories they play are loosly based on some sort of literature, especially anime and Japanese games. How many stories have they based soley on Son Goku?
Its good that that they are trying to lure in teenagers into libraries, it never hurts to try to push education. And what I think would be awesome is if if they do research on a particular game and say "Like the game? well they based such and such from this book and this from that story, check it out today!" That alone will increase the drive from gamers to read literature.
Im sorry but Im a huge adict of games and I love to read. Strange? Not really I hope, but it is true that few and few people have the drive to pick a good book.
The benefit of keeping teens off the streets and out of trouble (to some slight, but mention worthy degree) clearly isn't worth the imaginary threat of video games. But here I am, preaching to the choir.
I had moved from the children's department of my local library to the adult(no not p0rn) section by the age of 10-11 (now almost 17 years ago) because i had finished every book i found interesting in there.
The Fantasy and Sci-Fi sections of the library were my haven, i had up to 5 or 6 books at home at a time, usually finishing all within a week or 2.
Its a shame that todays kids no longer see their own imaginations as a fun place to be. (since books rely on that imagination a lot to work their magic)
I still love to read a good book, and do so regularly. I love video games aswell, so they're not mutually exclusive and i applaud the initiative of those libraries.
In fact, it's a controversy that started months ago on Dave Gibson's NewsByUs blog. Steven Cohen replied. Another blog, Library Attack, deconstructed his post and a comment by someone who disagreed. Then, Cohen replied again, and the result is the link I gave you.
Now, although I totally disagree with Cohen's views on video games, he has the right to have this point of view. And as he stated, the problem is not Cohen's views on video games, but the fact that games are put in libraries in order to attract children and make them read. And I'm forced to agree with him on that point. I'm not sure that children will want to read because of that poor excuse.
But maybe you should stop talking about "libraries" and call them "mediaries" (a rough translation of French word "médiathèque"), as you can find also DVDs and music.
It's not just gaming, either. My library had tons of videos and magazines, too.
I feel that there are many links between the two, and that games and libraries can interact each other very nicely.
Personally I love books and mythos, not once did I have to google an Ookami refernce because I already knew everything, and its just a bit annoying when I hear "reading's so dumb" from someone my own age(17) so I hope this turns out to be situation 1 because the more people read the more intelligent they'll be, satistically, the smarter people are the harder it is to win a presidental election campaign with war nanny states or horribly overt lies (though somehow Harper still got into our government) and if the president of America is based on actual merit rather than thier religion/creed well all the better for the world I say!
Because candy--generally speaking--does not have a tremendous potential for narrative. Video games do, and they're a wonderful gateway into the world of literature and reading:
"Like Halo? Check out these Halo BOOKS. And while you're at it, here's some great old school science fiction by Bradbury and Asimov."
DUH.
WHAT AN IGNORANT COMMENT!!!!!
Listen, before I get angry with this prick, it is better for me to calm down and just say a few words of my own peaceful stance.
Many years ago, when books were first invented, many people in society thought that books were turning people into zombies.
But until they acutely read a book for the first time, they could start to understand the reason for all this text in this page.
But at the time, not many people of the older generation could read, so therefore the gap between the older and the younger was divided between those who could read and those who could not.
Anyway, I would have more likely said, before you criticise Videogames as nothing but a waste of time, try to play a Videogame with a great story or one that engages you into a situration that you have never felt in your life that you can play a part of.
Just like in books, Videogames can be a gateway to another world in your mind.
Also if you don't think Videogames don't encourage reading, try playing some RPG games like Final Fantasy, Dragon Quest or even Legend of Zelda.
These are the games that a major book lover would like to read, especilly if they are into the books about Dragons, King Arthur and MediEvil times
Sadly, like in the example of the older generation not being able to read when books first were invented, the same goes with Videogames when some people like this guy from the older generation somehow can't be bothered in learning how to play "these darm" videogames.
So there is no use in my arguing because these people will never change.
GP: T-bone, your comment got noticed...
I have been in libraries around the country when I traveled with my parents and even now, I usually end up in a library (They did a lot of family history and still do) So I just read whenever. I only ever see books geared at teens in small sections, sometimes put on those spin wracks only meant to advertise the newest books. Books geared specifically for teenagers have almost no space.
Sure a lot of teenagers Read Stephen King, but they also read Tamora Pierce, Patrica C Wrede, R.L.Stine, and those were just some of my favs. Not to mention collections of 3 or 4 books are often incomplete meaning you might drop the series rather then go and try to find the sometimes way old 2nd volume.
On top of that this is one of the few times you might wanna differentiate the terms Kids and Teenagers.
HOWEVER.
There's tons of games out there that focus on reading, puzzle solving and story. For example, rpg's, or even Hotel Dusk for the DS.
So, mmm, I'm not sure.