Report: Indonesian Authorities Enforce Video Game Ban During Homework Hours

Report: Indonesian Authorities Enforce Video Game Ban During Homework Hours

May 5, 2008
According to a report on The Impudent Obersver, police in one Indonesian municipality will be enforcing a ban on videos games and TV during a two-hour evening period designated for children to do their homework:
The municipality of Bekasi... [is] ordering all students within its jurisdiction to study and do their homework or face legal consequences...  The new regulations require students, from elementary school to high school, to study between 7:00 p.m. and 9:00 p.m. either at home alone or with classmates from the same neighborhood. During study time, no TV or video game will be alowed and students will be banned from going to the mall or entertainment centers.

[Eductaion chief] Kodrato said his adminsitration would empower neighborhood heads and police personnel to enforce the regulations. Bekasi was inspired to institute the new policy after hearing it has been in operation in the municipality of Yogyakanta since 2003.

Comments

Well we all know that the government raising other people's kids never turned out bad, look at how Nazi Germany turned out. /sarcasm
Argh, this is typical of a bad idea. If you want someone to do something, encourage them to do that thing instead of telling them not to do some other thing. If they didn't want to study before this new law isn't going to change their minds.
"[Eductaion chief]"

lolz...

Sorry Dennis, there's something funny about that particular word having the typo... :-p
WATCH OUT BIG BROTHER IS WATCHING!!!!!
0_o This story is pretty creepy....
So from 7 to 9 they will have kids pretending to study? I'm sorry if you told me I had to study between 7 to 9 I would go to my room, turn out the lights and go right to sleep.
@InsidiousMrMoo

I used to go up, close the door and read comics.
Do they issue their 'officers' with swastikas and jackboots, you know, for authenticity?

This story gave me shivers....
Shit! Don't let Tommy boy hear about this one, that might be his next campaign against the industry! Then he will move to make any time study time! :-S
try this where I live and there will be riots on the streets. Riots in which I will participate. The governement is rotten and should mind his own business.
And I thought I was living in a nanny state.
2 hours isn't unreasonable. I was a horrible student who never got my homework done and got through HS by the skin of my teeth due to my lousy attention span. But government enforcement is still excessive.
They should know you cannot force a kid to study. No matter what you threaten the kids will just stare blankly at the book they are "Studying" for the two hours turning the page every few minuets making it look like they are studying.
You've got to be kidding.

Soon they'll be packing people into crates and throwing them in a river. Today the Inonesian children tomorrow the world? Freedom, Homework and Bread?

This can only bring about bad things.
What about if the kids already did their homework during the school day???
That's ridiculous. I feel sorry for those poor kids.
next will be camps to go study for few hours. then they will only let them study what they wrote. and burn the rest
Let's see - large group of kids with 2 hours to spend forced to choose either independent study or "study time" with fellow classmates indoors? Oooh! I know this one! Doesn't it end with them all getting knocked up and/or hooked on D&D?
Waaait...how will they enforce this? Knock on every door and demand proof that they're studying?

And Mythgarr, what's wrong with D&D? :-D
@Mythgarr;

Best comment ever.

Congratulations, you win at internet.
This is not really much of a step further than compulsory state-approved schooling.
Obviously this country no longer has any after school sports or music programs… since the grand majority of all performances / football games occur right at 7:00. This isn’t just an attack against kids, it’s an attack against creativity, sportsmanship, and the arts.
Was this law written by Obama?
Damn thought police >_>.
You know...if Kira is living in this place...its only going to make it easier for him/her to write in the Deathnote (flash back to the "Dramatic Chip-Eatting/Homework scene.) >=D
Seriously tho, this really is a bad bad BAD Idea, how many kids are actually going to study during this time? "Study or you will go to jail." I would probably NOT study outta principle...I forsee riots and protests and many problems ahead...
I think that maybe they don´t have any crimes or something, if they have the resources to be checking what children do in their free time.
Holy crap.. what about teaching kids time management?? Maybe they're better at studying from 9-10? Or 5-7? At best you'll raise a generation that can't think for themselves, but more likely a generation that rebels against doing anything they're told!
"During study time, no TV or video game will be alowed and students will be banned from going to the mall or entertainment centers."

Doesn't say anything about not going to strip joints. :)
wonderful picture
Scary and unfair, but...

study and do their homework or face legal consequences…

Fucking hilarious.
If anything this is gonna force grades down

Cram sessions don't work usually as it can overload the brain, and that's all I see here, government enforced cram sessions
@videogameotaku

Deathnote refernce for the win!
I'm curious how they plan on enforcing this. What happens when a sadistic teacher decides to assign "must watch (insert documentary)" for homework? Are they gonna have cops peeping into people's windows looking for lit TV's?
And is indonesia really so fortunate that they don't have more serious crimes to be on guard for??
Hmm, for a long time - while I was in school at least younger - I never had video games to play..

Yet.. I still didn't do my homework, lol
Fucking Indonesian government...
Well, that doesn't like a police state at all...
How is this going to be enforced? Will they have cops sneaking around and peeking in windows, or will it be up to all adults to keep a watch out? I can see them being able to enforce no malls or entertainment centers, but home entertainment? Will they be going door to door and making sure the child is staring at a book?
Drop that game controller! Do this book report on Orwells "1984" instead...
While this bad. This is not comparable to an Owellian 1984 state. So stop saying it no thought police or nothing. 1984 was about the control of thought. While in this situation they are telling kids what to do they are not forcing them to think in a certain way.
So they're placing a law into effect that cannot be enforced by any practical means...real smart, guys. Think of the children, yeah, that's important, but first THINK OF THE LOGISTICS! So right now the law seems to be little more than a suggestion for parents.

The only thing that the government can directly control is TV programming, like the Telecom act passed by the US. That can influence a kid's watching habits. But kids will be kids and they can figure out other ways to kill time.
@Werrick
Seconded
@Stu

Two Words... Slippery Slope
@ BrandonL337

Every slope still has its valley at the end. It's just an issue of knowing where that slope will end.
Yeah...next they'll start to control what times students come home, where they can go, then extend it to adults, take away private gun ownership (if it's still there even)...and straight into an Orwellian state...sounds like a good plan!
Right on!

7 PM to 9 PM every night... Anatomy and sex ed! Woot!

/Sarcasm

Epic failure in law. It's worthless unless you can enforce it.

Nice way to make the gov't the parent. Let's make a generation of losers that must be told what to do at every point in their life. Brilliant.
@JustChris

It may eventually stop but that doesn't mean anything unless you can climb back out
This coming from a country with history of oppression in Aech, West Papua and what was East Timor. Don't forget that this is a country that pays only lip-service to freedom.
There is a time to study and a time to play games. If the youngsters in that area don't understand the concept, that's ok....there's always a french fry cook position open at the local McDonalds and Burger King.
are they banning tv, radio and playing other games as well, or just picking on the evil video game industry, At least with a video game the kid is interacting some how, not like those kids sitting on their ass watching scoobie doo and eating the junk food their parents are giving them to keep the quiet.

If polititions could campaign in video games I bet all this "STOP THE EVIL VIDEO GAMES" shit would go away.

As far as kids playing violent video games, I would love it if they just made it illegal for kids to play them rather than banning the games, at least then I could play a game I enjoy and if online would not have to listen to a bunch of brats. How about xbox give us an option to report an underage kid online playing a game ment for us adults, then they get their xbox locked up and problem solved, I realy dont care how they do it as long as they dont try to tell me I cant play a game because it cant be sold do to too much sex or violence, yet I can go to war to kill people for real, go rent a hard core porn movie or go to a strip club and that is all ok.
Parents just need to pay attention a little and the government needs to get out or our private lives.
How is this plausable, seirously? Unless they actually enforce Oceania style screens in people's houses, or unless they actually develop the Guadalcanal-22 0_o...
Wow I have friends in highschool who can do their homework in an hour, some in a half hour, sometimes there is no homework.

In addition when I was in elementary school until like fifth grade I was in bed by eight o clock.
To be fair, this is an Indonesian municipal government ruling meaning.

1) It's never going to be enforced like a hundred other by laws that Indonesia has.

2)If it is, it's because some cop needs a bit of pocket money.
That's unfair, and what the hell are they going to do if the child refuse? Don't forget that this is children we are talking about not machines, it's at moments like this i pray that Soviet rises from it's ashes and everyone unleashes nuclear hell. Someone press the restart button!
"He loved Big Brother."
-George Orwell, 1984.
Re: Report: Indonesian Authorities Enforce Video Game Ban

I lol'd at the Death Note comment.

I take a video game... and BAN IT!

 

okay I'm done now. Seriously though, this is scary... but they'll figure out it's impossible to enforce. Right? god, politicians are stupid in *every* country. :/

Post new comment

By posting comments on this Web site you agree to abide by the Comments Policy.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This image is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. The letters in the picture are all UPPER-CASE.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.

GamePolitics ShoutBox

Posted 08/29/08 at 10:52am
ZippyDSMlee: feeman:DS is saying goverment would exspand more if the duims get in, he's probly right.
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:51am
thefremen: LOL, yes, the government has not expanded at all in the last 8 years, especially not for the benefit of corporate entities.
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:51am
thefremen: LOL, yes, the government has not expanded at all in the last 8 years, especially not for the benefit of corporate entities.
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:43am
ZippyDSMlee: DS- http://forums.theeca.com/showthread.php?p=84679#post84679 In OT BTW
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:32am
ZippyDSMlee: Dark Sovereign: Sure ^^
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:29am
Dark Sovereign: @zip: Make the thread. I'm just not active there.
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:28am
SimonBob: Heh, I was just playing with the semantics for my own amusement, not trying to shoehorn my way into the argument.
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:28am
ZippyDSMlee: Dark Sovereign: Iwish you would join the forums so we can have a full conversation these shouts are stifling!
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:27am
ZippyDSMlee: Dark Sovereign:force them into the wilderness to die off...this is the reality of not taking into account what to do with the lower classes.
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:26am
Dark Sovereign: @zip: What are you talking about? Less government means less taxes. Less taxes means more money in average Joe's pockets.
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:26am
ZippyDSMlee: Dark Sovereign: you DO realize there were roving shanty towns and poor hosues before social secuty was started? they were hives for poverty and disease,hell with todays "cleanliness" in housing code you can not have them anymore and states will just forc
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:22am
ZippyDSMlee: Dark Sovereign: noobies and their silly definition ^_~, but I ahve to ask how do you keep millions off the streets, taking twice as much money from states without social security and health care?
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:22am
Dark Sovereign: You ASSUME that not giving tons of handouts to people will make them poor. America itself shows you are wrong.
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:17am
Dark Sovereign: Fascism involves ever-expanding government. I just argued the exact opposite.
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:17am
Dark Sovereign: Do either of you have any idea what "fascism" or totalitarianism IS? You aren't showing it.
Posted 08/29/08 at 10:08am
SimonBob: "Fascism" is such a dirty word. Call it "totalitarianism" and at least it sounds vaguely reasonable, in a Heinlein-esque way.
Posted 08/29/08 at 09:50am
thefremen: @Dark Soveriegn: You're advocating the values of fascism, you know that right? If we call it conservatism does it smell as sweet
Posted 08/29/08 at 08:36am
gamepolitics: When I'm on the West Coast I miss my three-hour head start... wah...
Posted 08/28/08 at 10:03pm
ZippyDSMlee: Dark Sovereign: right? ack sorry for the long windedness ><
Posted 08/28/08 at 10:02pm
ZippyDSMlee: Dark Sovereign:infrastructure, let the states deal with the millions on disability or SSI let states run shanty towns for the great unwashed masses and all the death and disease that will ensue, as long as the middle and rich pay less taxes who cares righ
Login or register to post shouts