Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

June 30, 2008 -

The Entertainment Software Association (ESA), which represents the interests of video game publishers in the United States, has issued a press release announcing that the state of Minnesota will reimburse the industry to the tune of $65,000.

The figure represents legal fees incurred by the video game industry in its court challenge to Minnesota's unusual 2006 "fine-the-buyer" law.

As passed by the Minnesota legislature and signed into law by Governor (and potential Republican VP candidate) Tim Pawlenty (left) in 2006, the law would have turned traditional video game legislation on its head by fining underage buyers of M-rated games $25. Virtually all other video game content bills have sought penalties against retailers.

There were some other noteworthy aspects to the Minnesota situation:

U.S. District Court Judge James Rosenbaum, who ruled the law unconstitutional, borrowed his law clerk's Xbox to check out some violent games while considering his ruling.

Former Minnesota Attorney General Mike Hatch (D), who defended against the industry's constitutional challenge in its early days, described violent video games in a court filing as "worthless, disgusting speech" and "speech of very low societal value."

Minnesota appealed Judge Rosenbaum's decision's to the 8th Circuit Court, but lost. A request for a review by the entire 8th Circuit was also turned down.

The state's only remaining recourse was the U.S. Supreme Court. Judging from the settlement with the game biz, Minnesota A.G. Lori Swanson has apparently decided not to pursue a Supreme Court decision, but we've got a call into Swanson's office to confirm that.

The ESA originally sought $73,332 in fees in a motion filed in August, 2006. The $65,000 figure indicates that a little bit of negotiating went on.

ESA CEO Michael Gallagher weighed in on the $65,000 payment:

Minnesota’s citizens should be outraged at paying the bill for this flawed plan. Minnesota’s public officials ignored legal precedent and instead pursued a political agenda that ultimately cost taxpayers money. Courts across the United States have ruled consistently that video games are entitled to the same First Amendment protections as other forms of art, such as music and literature...

 

Politicians need to realize that the key to protecting our children from inappropriate media content is not haphazard legislation, but rather parental education. Video games have a first class ratings system supported by retailers, opinion leaders and parents.  It would be a far better use of public funds to help support this system, rather than continue to pursue unconstitutional legislation that works against it.    

GP: In a way, it would have been fascinating to see the Supreme Court make a ruling on this issue.


Comments

Jeez

My "Net connection has been out,I must've missed alot.Who are we pissed at right no?

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

 The politicians who pass unconstitutional laws need to have their pay docked or some other public humiliation inflicted on them.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

I'm a big fan of bringing back tar-and-feathering.

~~All Knowledge is Worth Having~~

~~All Knowledge is Worth Having~~

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

Meh, too bad it wasn't a lot more just to make those idiots who can't be bothered to worry about the constitutionality of what they're trying to enact and leave it to lawyers look even worse. Politicians who try to pass "feel good" laws deserve to lose their position.

My wallet hurts!!!!

-And as always, the taxpayers are the ones who suffer.

 

If shit and bricks were candy and tits, we'd all be livin' large. For information on games and psychology, look up: Jonathan Freedman(2002)Block & Crain(2007)Grand Theft Childhood, by Harvard Medical School researchers Larry Kutner and Cheryl Olson

Reality/////////////////////////////////////Fantasy. Seems like a pretty thick line to me...

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

Fuck.

 

Thank god I forwarded my rebate towards next years taxes.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

GP: In a way, it would have been fascinating to see the Supreme Court make a ruling on this issue.

Be careful what you say GP. I rather things stay the way they are with a united front by the circuit of appeals. Though it supports our chances with winning in the SC, I've read plenty of cases where the SC went the otherway regardless of a united front. I say lets keep things the way we are with us on the winning side and not take unnecessary chances.

Risk v. Benefit

Yeah, the risk of them deciding against us is frightening indeed. But if they decide for our side, we are done with all the legislation, the tax burns, etc. Forever. But yes, if we were to lose, it would SUCK! You know Jack would be claiming victory all over the site.

 

 

-If shit and bricks were candy and tits, we'd all be livin' large. For information on games and psychology, look up: Jonathan Freedman(2002)Block & Crain(2007)Grand Theft Childhood, by Harvard Medical School researchers Larry Kutner and Cheryl Olson

Reality/////////////////////////////////////Fantasy. Seems like a pretty thick line to me...

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

Two things to note here.

1) As long as politicians can milk these "feel good" laws to make voting constituants happy, they'll keep making and trying to pass them.  All kinds of bills like this are passed yearly, and most of them get shot down soon after.  Videogames are the big thing right now, so expect to see more of these, no matter how many have been deemed unconstitutional before them.  And it's not just morally bankrupt politicians, it's misguided politicians who have a very loud, crass, big mouthed someone whispering in their ear (high Jack!), it's morally zealous politicians who think that they're morals are "right", and everyone else is "wrong", it's completely oblivious politicians who want in on the bandwagon, and pretty much every other politician sooner or later.

 

2) To the people of Minnesota, and every other state that's had to shell out big $$ because of some moronic dolt of a politician who couldn't give up the ghost, write to your local newspapers, bloggers, TV news station, and pretty much every media outlet in your state, and let them know how your politicians wasted money on trivial, useless, and baseless legislation that has been deemed unconstitutional time and time and time again in other states.  Let them know how much their "moral zeal" has cost your state, when it could have put that money towards alternatives to legislation that would have helped with educate parents about violent videogames and their ratings, and how to buy the right games for the right age levels.  Let them know how the money could have been put towards doing other things for the kids of your community and state, like after school programs, parks, youth centers, and such.  I can garauntee you that more than a few people will be not be happy, and let the legislature know during the next election.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

As far as I know Thompson was not involved in the legislative process on this one.  The big proponent was Sen Sandy Pappas & then AG Mike Hatch as part of his lead up to running for governor, if I remember correctly. 

It is interesting that the office of the MN AG responded to my email as a constituent stating that "Under Minnesota law, this Office is obligated to defend the constitutionality of State legislation."  In many ways it seems that the AG office under Swanson was following through on obligations created by then AG Mike Hatch. 

 

 

 

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

Charging gamers? I think that's actually better than the retailers or the industry itself for being charged. Maybe not as good as the employee, not the company, being fined, but at least this bill attempted to put the blame in the person who was knowingly buying a game to mature for themselves.

Still, it's a good thing that they shot it down. These video game bills are simply getting annoying at this point.

-"A fanatic is one who can't change his mind and won't change the subject." -Sir Winston Churchill

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

"GP: In a way, it would have been fascinating to see the Supreme Court make a ruling on this issue"

Seeing as how they've been ruling against our other rights (Habeus Corpus, etc.) I really don't want to see video games go all the way to the Supreme Court, not with these justices at least.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

Uh...what? They just reenforced habeus corpus to the Bush regime for the third time. They also protected the second amendment.

 

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

"Uh...what? They just reenforced habeus corpus to the Bush regime for the third time. They also protected the second amendment."

 

The "Bush Regime" you are talking about put some of those judges in play that protected the second amendment. The Job of the Judicary branch (aka supreme court) is to decide if the rule of law is constitinal it is called checks and balances.  

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

So is New York next? I wish there a law that the law makers who created this bill would pay 20% out of their own pockets while those who voted on it pay 10%. M]be that might keep them from making unconstutional laws. but then again they would just give themselves a pay raise.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

This just in:  Prosecutor considers bringing criminal charges against Take-Two for copycat criminal acts.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

This Just in: There is NO law that can stick that can cause Censorship in the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA you can't tell people they can't make art/media/video games....That being said RETAILERS have every right not to carry said art/media/Video Games if they choose too....SO JACK PLEASE DO ALL THE WORLD A FAVOR GAG YOURSELF!!!!!!!

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

This just in: Never-has-been attorney tries to derail a topic AGAIN, with crap that probably isn't even true. AGAIN.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

That's not really news though is it.

Now, if the prosecutor did bring criminal charges, it might be worth a mention. Still a little dog bites man though.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

This just in:  You're not Jack Thompson

Where the hell is your family?

Don't you have a sickly wife who needs your care?

 -If shit and bricks were candy and tits, we'd all be livin' large. For information on games and psychology, look up: Jonathan Freedman(2002)Block & Crain(2007)Grand Theft Childhood, by Harvard Medical School researchers Larry Kutner and Cheryl Olson

Reality/////////////////////////////////////Fantasy. Seems like a pretty thick line to me...

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

This just in: Prosecutor considers bringing criminal charges against PBS for two kids getting injured copycatting Benjamin Franklin. (no, this isn't real. A cookie goes to whomever knows what I'm referring to)

岩「…Ace beats Jack」

岩「…I can see why Hasselbeck's worried about fake guns killing fake people. afterall, she's a fake journalist on a fake news channel」

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

LOL  I know what you're talking about, Beavis and Butt-Head, which is what Jack is usually sounding like, a butthead.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

yep, although Jack sounds more like Beavis to me, since Butt-Head is ironically the smarter of the two.

岩「…Ace beats Jack」

岩「…I can see why Hasselbeck's worried about fake guns killing fake people. afterall, she's a fake journalist on a fake news channel」

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

This just in: loudmouth, rabble rousing, massacre chaser, attention whore lawyer Johnny Bruce Thompson faces disbarrment of 10 years after launching numerous fraudlent lawsuits with a 100% failure rate.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

You cound´t even convict a child molester... you couldn´t even convict a traffic infractor or a bike thief in a schoolyard...

---------------------------------------------------------------------------- The cynical side of videogames (spanish only): http://thelostlevel.blogspot.com/

This just in: Said

This just in: Said prosecutor is under a court order preventing him from interfering with Take-Two.

Breaking news: Said prosecutor will have to do this through another attorney as his own career is practically over.

From our Florida correspondent: Said prosecutor has tried the same thing many times in the past.

Update: Said prosecutor has failed each and every time.

Here's Tom with the weather, Tom?

Tom: Well, it's looking like someone's career is in the middle of a storm at the moment, with gale force disciplinary action coming in from the south, and severe failstone showers every time he tries anything. Conversely, everything looks pretty sunny for the video games industry!

This just in

This just in.... A Class action lawsuit it being created against Jack Thompson for slander, libel, harassment, intentional infliction of emotional distress, defamation of character, vilification, Abuse of the process, Malicious prosecution, tortious interference, public nuisance, malpractice, and terroristic threatening. I hope you have a good lawyer.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

This just in:  All of your video game cases have failed.

 

 

 

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

This just in:  Take-Two will never be charged for the actions of individuals dumb enough to copycat their game. Not now, not ever.

Also, please try to keep your posts relevant to the topic of the article.

-"A fanatic is one who can't change his mind and won't change the subject." -Sir Winston Churchill

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

This is how my state spends my tax dollars? At least we didn’t lose too much money.

 

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

PWNED... But I think 65,000 USD is very little. And I wonder in what is gonna the money be expended...

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------- The cynical side of videogames (spanish only): http://thelostlevel.blogspot.com/

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

GP: In a way, it would have been fascinating to see the Supreme Court make a ruling on this issue.

You may get that chance with California.

Glad to see another unconstitutional bill bite the dust and the politicians who signed and voted for it getting what they deserve.

E. Zachary Knight
www.editorialgames.com
Oklahoma City Chapter of the ECA
MySpace Page: http://www.myspace.com/okceca
Facebook Page: http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1325674091

Too optimistic

While I would love to see the SCOTUS shut down Leland Yee with a loud and clear message, I don't see it happening.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

Yeah, and then we'd never have to hear about it again, just like creationism.

As long as the public keeps voting for morally bankrupt politicans, we will never see the end of it.

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

Is there really such thing as a "Moral" politician anymore I figured that was a oxymoron.......

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

Was this one of the pieces of legislation that Jack Thompson was behind?

Re: Minnesota Will Pay $65K to Game Biz Over Failed Law

It sounds a bit like a broken record, you'd really think they'd have learned by now.

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
SleakerGamestop articles popping up everywhere about their ludicrous new Credit card offerings at a whopping pre-approval for 26.9% APR07/29/2014 - 10:19pm
Matthew Wilsonhttp://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/07/podcasting-patent-troll-we-tried-to-drop-lawsuit-against-adam-carolla/ the podcasting patent troll scum is trying to turn tail and run.07/29/2014 - 9:50pm
MaskedPixelanteOf course it's improved. At launch, Origin was scanning your entire hard drive, but now it's just scanning your browsing history. If that's not an improvement, I dunno what is!07/29/2014 - 8:59pm
Papa Midnighthttp://www.escapistmagazine.com/articles/view/video-games/columns/experienced-points/12029-Has-EAs-Origin-Service-Improved-Any-Over-the-Last-Two-Years07/29/2014 - 8:25pm
Sora-ChanSo it's just a matter of having better emulation software. If it can be done with a 3DS game, with all the memory and what not it takes up, it can be done with a GBA title through emulation.07/29/2014 - 7:30pm
Sora-ChanOther VC titles for the NES and Gameboy had the same setup where you couldn't access the homescreen without quitting out of the game til a later update when those games were released for the public outside of the founder program.07/29/2014 - 7:28pm
Sora-Chanthe 3DS can, and does, run GBA games, as seen by the founder gifts, which included a number of GBA titles. As for running GBA games and still having access to the home screen, I beleive it's more of the game emulation software needs to be updated.07/29/2014 - 7:27pm
Matthew Wilsonthe 3ds already swaps os's with the original ds. plus I dont think people expect miverse interaction when playing a gba game.07/29/2014 - 6:06pm
MaskedPixelanteBut that's not the issue, the 3DS is perfectly capable of emulating GBA games. The problem is that it doesn't have enough available system resources to run it alongside the 3DS OS, and thus it doesn't have access to stuff like Miiverse and save states.07/29/2014 - 5:45pm
Matthew WilsonI am well aware that it requires more power, but if a GBA emulator could run well on a original psp, than it should work on a 3ds.07/29/2014 - 5:36pm
ZenThe reason the SNES could run Gameboy, or the Gamecube could run GBA was because their adapters included all of the necessary hardware to do it in the respective add-ons. The systems were just conduits for control inputs and video/sound/power.07/29/2014 - 4:51pm
ZenMatthew: Emulation takes more power than people realize to run a game properly. You can make something run on less, but Nintendo...as slow as they are at releasing them..makes them run as close to 100% as possible. Each game has its own emulator for it.07/29/2014 - 4:47pm
Matthew Wilsonkind of hard to believe since the 3ds is atleast as powerful as the gamecube hardware wise.07/29/2014 - 4:27pm
MaskedPixelanteYes, the 3DS has enough power to run 16-bit emulators, but not at the same time it's running the 3DS systems themselves. You could run the games, but you wouldn't get save states or Miiverse.07/29/2014 - 4:04pm
InfophileRunning GBA on 3DS shouldn't be hard. The DS had flashcarts sold for it that added just enough power to emulate GBA and SNES games, so the 3DS should have more than enough natively.07/29/2014 - 3:37pm
MaskedPixelanteIt's a bunch of people whining about boycotting/pirating Trails in the Sky FC because XSEED didn't license the Japanese dub track, which consists of about 10 lines per character.07/29/2014 - 11:27am
Sleaker@MP - devolver Digital issued a twitter statement saying they would replace the NISA pledge.07/29/2014 - 10:57am
E. Zachary KnightIs that a discussion about RIAA member music labels?07/29/2014 - 10:48am
MaskedPixelantehttp://steamcommunity.com/app/251150/discussions/0/43099722329318860/ In this thread: Idiots who don't understand how licensing works.07/29/2014 - 9:20am
MaskedPixelantehttp://www.joystiq.com/2014/07/28/gaymerx-in-dire-straits-after-nis-america-allegedly-backs-out-of/ NISA backs out of GaymerX support, but it seems like the only people crying foul are GaymerX.07/29/2014 - 6:30am
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician