Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

July 25, 2008

Recently, GamePolitics reported that the Massachusetts legislature was mulling the idea of tax incentives for the film and video game industries.

Game developers who were considering a move to Massachusetts based on that news may want to re-think their position, however.

The Boston Globe reports that, although the State House approved the tax breaks, the head of the State Senate, Sen. Therese Murray (D, at left), has nixed the idea:

Senate President Therese Murray said her chamber had no intention of taking it up before the end of the legislative session next week.

 

"I just don't think it's something that's affordable," Murray said yesterday in an interview. "It's not the top of our agenda."

 

She said lawmakers' time would be better spent on assessing a package controlling healthcare costs, approving bond bills, and reviewing the governor's budgetary vetoes.

 

Comments

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers
Is that a picture from RE5 or the new Dead Rising game? I know it's some kind of zombie.
Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

Translation:

"Although a fellow body of legally elected representatives of the Massachusettes citrizenry has voted in favor of this proposal, I will use my unique position to stonewall further discussion.  Despite the fact that I am the president of a body whose responsibility is to debate, I shall set the agenda of our debate such to prevent discussion of items with which I disagree."

 

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

Less sarcastically:

Listen, I understand that there is a finite amount of time before the legislature breaks in Massachusettes, and thus a finite amount of business which can be conducted.  However, the concept of "legislative sessions" is one self-imposed by the legislature.  They've chosen to restrict their availability for public discourse, and then use this as a means to bury leglisation on both a local and national level.  It is a disservice to democracy - vote against a bill if you disagree with it, don't resort to chicanery to suppress the opposition.

 

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

As someone from MA, I'm more annoyed that they now require health insurance by law. If required car insurance is any indication, this will devolve into nothing more than a "it's against the law for us to not be taking money from you". Seriously, car insurance is at the point now where they won't cancel your insurance without prior notification that you have already bought insurance elsewhere. Yet.... you can not pay, and they cancel it then. That's almost as bad as the telecom companies that claimed the unwarrented taps were just "doing our civic duty to obey the government's request", yet they cut the taps off when the government didn't pay the bills.

I hate politics....

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

I too was annoyed by the mandated health insurance thing.  Fortunately, these days I'm able to afford health insurance, but for many people the cost of health insurance can be beyond a person's resources.  I feel bad for young folks starting out in a job market when many businesses, especially in the service industry, pay minimum wage and don't offer health insurance.  I mean what options do young folks have, other than living with their parents, when the government insists on people having health insurance but will not insist on employers paying a living wage?

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

Wow. That is...one ugly woman.

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

I WAS THINKING THE SAME THING LOL.....

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

Here I was under the false impresion that Massachusetts was a progressive state.

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

Ok, as a person from Massachusetts....Do we have any Developers or Game Industries in the state?

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

To answer your question,

There's actually game companies within Massachusetts... even the beloved Rockstar Games acquired Maddog Games to form Rockstar New England in Massachusetts.

I don't miss the messed up law of requiring health insurance... I'm glad I hopped the border to New Hampshire: supplying vices for Massachusetts residents for over 200 years.  ;)

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

Correct me if I am wrong but... Tax breaks for gaming companies = Economic growth = More money for the state to fix their healthcare issues?  And among other things.  What gives?

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

Tax breaks = less money coming in now = more tax breaks when the companies threaten to move when the current one runs out

 

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

I wouldn't be surprised if this went through anyways. There's been a large push behind this bill from the movie industry. It passed through the house thanks to the might of the SGA and indie studios/production companies.

As a resident of Massachusetts, I've been highly dissatified with the state's polititians lately. As a 21 year old college student, I've even had issues with the health insurance bill. Health insurance companies hate dependents. They'll drop them if they can find a reason. Due to a mix up where the insurance company lost my paperwork from my college, they dropped my health coverage at the same time as Massachusetts ran a complete television and radio smear campaign against anyone that didn't have health insurance. There's nothing worse than hearing "IF YOU DON'T HAVE HEALTH INSURANCE. YOU'RE BREAKING THE LAW." when there's really nothing you can do.

As both a game developer (it's what I go to college for) and as a movie producer (I run a small production studio),  I have a real interest in seeing this pass. Both movie and game industries would bring large ammounts of revenue to the state and striking this bill down is huge mistake. But then again, if the MA government weren't making catestrophic mistakes, it wouldn't be Massachusetts.

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

Massachussetts is currently the third largest state for game development (behind California and Texas). We have award-winning studios like Rockstar (GTA), Harmonix (Rock Band), 2K Games (Bioshock), and Turbine (LotR Online), and one of the largest monthly meetings of the IGDA (International Game Developer's Association) in the country. Considering how much money the game industry brings to Massachusetts, and how big the movie industry is becoming here (The Departed, anyone?) I am appalled to hear this news. Considering that these tax breaks are supported by Governor Deval Patrick, I do not see why a fellow democrat feels the need to stonewall this legislation, besides her probably buying into the age old "violent games make you violent" urban legend. As a near college graduate on the verge of setting up an independent studio here in Massachusetts, where I grew up and still live (when I'm not at school in Georgia, which, by the way, DOES have the tax breaks that are about to be stonewalled in Mass), I seriously hope she does not prevent this legislation from being passed. The voice of the people outnumbers that of one, mandatory health-care imposing liberal.

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

We have to tell her we want this passed!

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

I absolutely agree with most of the other posters. This legislation needs to be passed. I am 20 years old and currently a theater major in Ma. I chose to go to school where I grew up because of cost. One thing that has made it a little better for a theater major here in Ma. lately has been the idea of this tax break because of all the movie work coming in. It provided me the opportunity to work as a paid extra on the sets of some of the movies and gain first hand experience on what it truly means to be an actor. $112 for one day for a college student is pretty good ( = I would really like to see it become a mini hollywood east here.  It will bring in revenue. This needs to be passed!

Re: Not Happening: Massachusetts Tax Breaks For Game Developers

According to my opinion this is really very nice and informative post. This post really provide me lot of useful and good information.

-----------------
lauran

massachusetts drug rehab

GamePolitics ShoutBox

Posted 11/20/08 at 11:40am
KN: what thread
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:39am
nightwng2000: For interested parties, head over to The Thread for, very possibly, the FINAL update. 2 Minutes to post time. :)
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:38am
KN: ok frontpage tell me about frontpage kid. Gimme some gold
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:35am
Shadow D. Darkman: *sigh* FAIL.
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:34am
KN: it's frontpage kid!
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:33am
Shadow D. Darkman: *facepalm*
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:31am
KN: sup frontpage
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:20am
zel: I appreciate it :D
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:09am
Shadow D. Darkman: Sweet
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:03am
E. Zachary Knight: Zel, I got your back.
Posted 11/20/08 at 10:47am
PHX Corp: looks like the kids are getting a more proper punishment in canada for nuking a cat
Posted 11/20/08 at 10:45am
PHX Corp: http://kotaku.com/5094143/judge-bans-teens-from-video-games-for-cat-killing
Posted 11/20/08 at 10:27am
Shadow D. Darkman: @zel: Found it.
Posted 11/20/08 at 10:26am
zel: its at the bottom of the GTA 4 comments.
Posted 11/20/08 at 10:25am
zel: Wow somehow while posting my message got posted like 6 or 7 times, anyone on that can delete the extra ones? O.o sorry bout that
Posted 11/20/08 at 10:13am
ddrfr33k: @Alevan: It's the only way to fight dirty against PETA.
Posted 11/20/08 at 09:52am
Shadow D. Darkman: @Alevan: Hey, Amy!
Posted 11/20/08 at 09:44am
Alevan: Love how Mejasco is taking the parody game lightly and with a sense of humor.
Posted 11/20/08 at 09:42am
DeepThorn: Good morning
Posted 11/20/08 at 09:40am
Alevan: Good morning everybody!
Login or register to post shouts