NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

July 31, 2008

Forget about LaDainian Tomlinson. Longtime NFL watchers still maintain that Jim Brown is the best running back to ever play the game.

And now Brown is suing EA and Sony over what he says is the inclusion of his likeness in EA's best-selling Madden series. According to a report on Bloomberg

Brown, who left the National Football League to become an actor and starred in the movies "The Dirty Dozen'' and "Any Given Sunday..." [alleges that] the character, part of the "Real Old School Teams and Players'' series, is a muscular, African-American running back wearing the number 32 jersey who is featured in the game's "All [Cleveland] Browns Team,'' Brown said in a complaint filed yesterday in state court in New York.

 

Brown, who was number 32 for the Cleveland Browns, said in the complaint that he "never signed away any rights that would allow his likeness to be used...''  Brown said in the complaint that, when he played football, "the NFL had league wide policy that players shall have no lawyers or agents when negotiating compensation. Video games were not invented yet and no union to obtain rights from existed.''

Active NFL players are covered - and receive compensation - under licensing agreements with the NFL Players Association. Some retired players have received funds as well, but the numbers are typically smaller than for active players.

Via: GameDaily

Comments

Re: NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

it  would seem to me that you would need more than the fact that the guy ws muscular african american wearing the number 32 to prove it was your likeness...

Re: NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

Then who is it supposed to be? These games don't really do the whole fictional character thing.

Re: NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

Yeah it pretty much is obvious it's him, same team. But really, sueing SONY? did they make the game? What about microsoft?

Re: NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

Note the "Liceinced by Sony/Microsoft/Nintendo" at the boot up of every single game on one of their consoles.

Re: NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

You might think that but not according to previous like Ali VS Playgirl.  In that case a cartoon which depicted a muscular black boxer seated in his corner with the captions "mystery fighter" and "The Greatest" was found to be enough to rule in favor of Mohammed Ali.  There are other cases like this in which celebrities catch phrases or jersey numbers have been enough for the courts to rule in favor of the plaintiff.

Re: NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

true, but unless they explicitly say its him, I don't think he has legal grounds, as far as I know.

Re: NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

Covering your tracks on a player you haven't got the rights to is nothing new: Ken Griffey Jr.'s MLB on the SNES had a pitcher with incredible stats on the Boston Red Sox named "Heat" who was a dead ringer for Clemens, and there was a basketball game a while back that included Michael Jordan as "Roster Player."

But maybe if EA gets shafted on using retired players in Madden games, they'll bring out a CFL game where I can play as Mike Pringle.

---
The Mammon Industry

Re: NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

Right, or baseball games, such as EA's MVP (RIP) series having a playing on the San Francisco Giants named Jim Dowd who had stats strangly similar to Barry Bonds or dozens of other sports games that have done the same over the decades. If they don't use his name or his face then he has no case. His jersey nor the number on it doesn't belong to him and his stats whatever they may be in he game don't either, just being a well built black guy isn't enough to claim his likeness was used without his permission.. Leaving MS and Nintendo out is either from ignorance or just because having two large companies who have lawyers that will rip this suit to shreds was enough.

Re: NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

Jim's complaint makes a point in that old school everybodies (ballers, rappers, actors, ect.) did tend to get played by the various industries they worked in when it came to compensation in comparison to what some of the new school cats make (some of whom are straight-up bums in comparison and don't deserve half of what they make) because, in part, the old school cats taught the new school cats by example how NOT to get played. All the more reason for the the old school cats not to keep on getting played for their paper. Besides, you don't wanna get on Jim Brown's bad side. He's quick to slap the taste out ya mouth, if you do.  

Re: NFL Great Jim Brown Sues Sony, EA over Madden

And it don't take much to have a good "unauthorized use of likeness" case. As I recall, the legal test in most jurisdictions is "likely to cause confusion" (i.e., if the average, reasonable person on the street would be unsure that the product isn't depicting Person X, then Person X has satistfied the "looks like me" requirement of the lawsuit. You'll notice that the test doesn't call for Joe Blow to conclude that it is Person X, just that he can't say for sure that it isn't.

GamePolitics ShoutBox

Posted 11/20/08 at 12:08pm
KN: back to miscarriages
Posted 11/20/08 at 12:08pm
KN: they're both horrible and contribute nothing to society sooo
Posted 11/20/08 at 12:06pm
KN: PETA likes using the phrase "ANIMAL HOLOCAUST" and the JDL is a group of batfuck insane jews who would sperg out over this
Posted 11/20/08 at 12:05pm
KN: I really wish I didn't have to buckleybox jokes but here we go
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:59am
Baruch_S: They should make a kosher Cooking Mama for the Jewish gamers.
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:55am
KN: cage match
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:55am
KN: Jewish Defense League VS PETA
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:54am
PHX Corp: see update at the bottom for what's going to happen to those Teens over killing the cat
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:53am
Baruch_S: @NovaBlack: Nice find. I hate to tell PETA this, but I'm still have turkey for Thanksgiving.
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:49am
NovaBlack: got a link to that thread? i cant find it :S
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:48am
NovaBlack: lol PETA responds to majesco... http://kotaku.com/5094386/peta-beats-a-dead-horse-asks-for-veggie-cooking-mama
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:47am
KN: coo'
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:45am
JDKJ: @KN: The Thread in the ECA Forum.
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:40am
KN: what thread
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:39am
nightwng2000: For interested parties, head over to The Thread for, very possibly, the FINAL update. 2 Minutes to post time. :)
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:38am
KN: ok frontpage tell me about frontpage kid. Gimme some gold
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:35am
Shadow D. Darkman: *sigh* FAIL.
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:34am
KN: it's frontpage kid!
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:33am
Shadow D. Darkman: *facepalm*
Posted 11/20/08 at 11:31am
KN: sup frontpage
Login or register to post shouts