If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send Back the Money

August 6, 2008 -

The Entertainment Software Association made a bit of a splash yesterday with news that the state of California had forked over $282,794 to the game publishers' lobbying group.

The money represents legal fees incurred by the video game industry while fighting California's 2005 video game law in U.S. District court. Judge Ronald Whyte ruled the statute unconstitutional in August of 2007.

However, as GamePolitics has reported, California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger (left) appealed Judge Whyte's decision to the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court earlier this year. While it is unlikely that the state will prevail in its effort to keep the video game law on the books, if it does pull an upset, the ESA is required to return the money.

The details of this arrangement are spelled out in a November, 2007 agreement between the ESA and the state, which says, in part:

If, after all appeals have been exhausted or the time for all remaining appeals has expired, plaintiffs [the video game industry] are no longer the prevailing party in this case, the plaintiffs shall pay back the amount stipulated in paragraph 1 within thirty (30) days of the disposition of the final appeal or the expiration of time for all remaining appeals.

It's also interesting to note that the amount paid to the ESA by California was subject to some negotiation. As GamePolitics reported last September, the ESA initially sought $324,840.

Grab a copy of the settlement agreement here.


Comments

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

I'll be paying all attorneys' fees from my income derived from appearances on Fox News.

Jack Thompson

 

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

One more reason why not to watch that sad channel.

I would think it would be smarter using whatever money you get to help support your family but what do I know.

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

I believe you have finally admitted defeat.

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

Acceptance is the first step.

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

I see a lot of people spouting off about unconstitutional this and unconstitutional that.  What about that Anti smoking thing they put through a while ago.  You know, the one that says if you OWN a BAR or restaurant you CANNOT let people smoke inside of it!  Thats more a violation of the constitution if I ever seen one.  The solution to that one was simple.  If you dont like that Bar that lets people smoke in it, don't go.  Let tme businessmen/women decide.  But no... California thought it would be in the best interest of the "Children" *In bars?!*.  And made it illegal.  I don't know about you but if I owned a Bar or Restaurant, and I wanted people in my business to smoke at their will.  I would be pretty upset at the state for playing big brother.

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

the difference is simple between the 2, with the smoking they have found a direct causal link between smoking and lung cancer, as such, allowing smoking in the bar runs afoul of health code, which any owner or a public establishment must meet if they wish to stay in bussiness, and the idea is not to protect children, but more the employee's of said bar, that don't neccessarily have the option to not go to it

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

They game industry will fight and win against the appeal, then they'll make California pay more. Its not confusing, so why the hell are they so dumb?

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

I guess they are so over-"protective" of children they lost all sense of legal, constitutional, and judicial concepts.

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

Huh, I was thinking about that sales tax increase Arnold recently wants...

I wonder why?

Maybe if they stop doing this kind of shit to waste taxpayer money and do massive payment cuts for the Gov., Sentors, and those in office's salaries, I sure all us Californians would love to get behind that. Not that would ever happen, but one can dream Sacramento gets it's final comeupance some day.

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

Wow the people of California must really like footing bills for unconsitutional laws.  I mean does Arnold really think his law is suddenly going to be consitutional and does he really think the ESA isn't going to seek reimbursement for the legal fees they are going to spend in the appeals court ....

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

Don't you love election years, where these guys try to make examples of any and everything to get attention and try to get more votes, or more votes for the people they support...

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

The worst part is that most of the time, it works.... >_<

Easy explanation

Assume 20% of the population is generally stupid/ignorant who live in the USA, and I've met some high school kids this year (3 in fact from my part time teaching gig) who cannot find the USA on a globe.  PATHETIC.  I directly asked them (in private), to let them get out of a class early-they did not get to go home early of course.  We are talking 16, 17 and 18 year old kids.  Wait until THEY grow up...

 

Re: Easy explanation

That's horrifying...  I can still name/locate every state on the map of the US, and almost all of the capitals... Damn, I wish I could say all...  I forgot Alaska, the Dakotas and Montana's capitals...  Not too bad still...

AHHHH a rock the vote pop-up...  I hate both of the idiots, I want new selections damnit.  I will take Romney and Edwards paired up.  It is pretty bad when Paris Hilton looked more educated, WAS more well spoken, and yeah...  Our country has problems...  It isnt only the educational system...  Our entire government structure was suppose to change as the country changed to make it so that it could stay of the people, for the people and by the people...  Our founding fathers set it up to change with the times, but when you make it so that ONLY old people are in office, with little to no youth to keep things mixed up...  Things turn bad...  The young and old balance eachother out...  There have been little to no new ideas on how to improve our country or the world as a whole...

Things like this make me realize why people from other countries hate Americans... 

Anyways, if I had to vote right now, I would vote in Paris Hilton with Lewis Black as VP, haha.

Re: Easy explanation

even thou im canadian i would love to see Lewis Black as president and maybe Penn and Teller as VP and assistint VP

Re: Easy explanation

I feel bad for Americans right now.  The country's idiotic leadership has definately helped create some of the current problems right now.  Don't know how Indian politicians will handle it if we become a superpower.  Our Parliement house behaves like 3 year olds.  They keep walking out of debates and shouting out like infants.

What's up with the education here?  It's around three grade levels behind India's education.

I can imagine another generation of closed minded people who will try to censor the next new form of media.

 

Re: Easy explanation

yeah the schools here are pathetic.  A's are handed out if u do a competant job.  In my old school in the Indian himalayas I got 70s for projects that get A's here.  Classes are too easy.  i study in a school that's in the top 3% of US public schools.  I can't imagine what the situation is in worse schools.  Teachers give out free extra credit just so the class doesn't fail.   

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

You know what ESA?  I think it is safe to bank that cheque...

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

It's actually smarter to.  Put it in the bank, let it gather interest, and even if the case is overturned (which won't happen) they still come out a winner.

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

You know what's really ironic?- The Governator wants an unnecessary (and unconstitutional) media law to "PROTECT T3H CHILDRENZZZ", yet how many movies has he starred in that are far from appropriate for kids?

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

The California government is just attempting to save face with the populace.  Forking over nearly 300k of tax dollars can be pretty humiliating.

Michael Carusi

Capitol Gaming

augamers.blogspot.com

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

Save face? That's the funniest thing I've ever heard about Californian politics.

Knowing them, I don't think they would really fight that much to get the money back. They'll just make exuses again and cut money from education, health, and places Californina needs to have running or working for the state. It's not like those a-holes are going to make cuts to their own salaries. Do they really need that much money to work for office? Why does everyone else in the state has to work for minimum wage and they don't?

I don't think my own natives are going to let this go down, be sure to see opinion pieces or letters in newspapers from pissed off Californians who either want that money back or hate Arnold and Lee for that stupid piece of Law in the first place. I know I hate Lee and Arnold.

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

I hope California loses the appeal. Gov Schwarzenegger and Senator whoever are wanting a law that is unnecessary, unconstitutional, will cost too much taxpayer Dollars and in the end, will accomplish NOTHING. To make matters worse, it would result in 17 year olds, who are old enough to buy M rated games (and the M rating means *17* and up) not being allowed to buy them! Such a law is totally stupid an unnecessary. Enforcing laws against under-age game sales is NOT the answer, Teaching about the ESRB IS the answer.

Don't forget the knucklehead's name...

The state senator who is ready to defend his fucked up, unconstitutional law is named Leland Yee.  He's of the uber-liberal mentality that, "it takes a village to raise a child", which is just unrealistic, yet he can't see it any other way.  Yee initates a LOT of laws in California.  Law-this, law-that, if there is a problem make a law!  Yee can't effectively defend his blocked anti-video game law against constitutional scrutiny, so he just parrots "save the children", "defend the children", "protect our children" over and over, and over again.

Meanwhile, he fights for other 1st amendment issues for college newspaper protections and such, revealing his blatant double-standard.  According to Yee, video games don't get those same protections.  The state of California *will* eventually lose.  Just because Schwarzenegger is at the helm doesn't mean the constitution will change.  Kids who really want GTA4 will get it anyway and in the end Yee's efforts do nothing but waste taxpayer dollars, which he has no problem doing for the sake of his ego.

Re: Don't forget the knucklehead's name...

Senator Yee also contradicts himself on the ESRB. Last holiday season, he said that parents have to trust the ratings even though he said "they (ESRB) can't be trusted".

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

Given the fiscal state of California now, it's no longer about "the children."

It's about getting the money back.

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

Wish in one hand, Sh** in the other. See which one fills up first.

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

If they have an unconstitutional law pass.....hmmmm I don't think it will. :)

Re: If California Wins Video Game Law Appeal, ESA Must Send

Never Underestimate Arnold. He's seriously had a nack for getting what he wants, one way or another. If he was on our side, he'd be a great ally. But he's an idiot when it comes to politics.

With all the success of bringing games to mainstream, why are we losing so bad in legislation?

Appeals can lead to court

Appeals can lead to court decisions being overturned in many cases. New evidence comes to light that was not available at the beginning of a case, new technology is available to more accurately analyse existing evidence, etc. However, I don't think that the Constitution of the United States is going to change to omit one of it's principle facets...

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
ZippyDSMleeWell it could be worse, like skyrim out of the box, a shame DAI dose not have that level of editing...05/25/2015 - 5:58pm
Zenpretty well without getting "nasty". Many people are disappointed in the decision and the about face on the status of the games development.05/25/2015 - 4:22pm
ZenEvery market has horrible people...but being like this towards all of them in a group is not a way to garner support and can make people more hostile towards you. Ironically his response was to someone that wanted to state a disagreement, but worded it05/25/2015 - 4:22pm
Goth_SkunkAs demonstrated by Ian's remarks, that 'market of possible fans' is apparently negligible.05/25/2015 - 4:18pm
Zeninformation while other versions had everything talked about openly.05/25/2015 - 4:15pm
ZenYeah, I've read through it and wanted to make sure I had it quoted correctly. I get there are issues, but this is horribly unprofessional and just burning a market of possible fans..many of which supported them and were waiting while getting little to no05/25/2015 - 4:15pm
Goth_SkunkOh wow. That's not even misquoted, he actually said that. Though for additional context in previous pages, he truly does not think highly of Nintendo console owners, and claims that in the industry, he's not alone.05/25/2015 - 4:12pm
ZenI also took a screenshot of the statement in case it is taken down (via my Twitter): https://twitter.com/zenspath/status/60293960536562483205/25/2015 - 4:05pm
ZenLink for my previous post - http://forum.projectcarsgame.com/showthread.php?27584-Project-Cars-Sales-figures&p=942776&viewfull=1#post94277605/25/2015 - 4:03pm
ZenProject Cars basically canceled for Wii U, Slightlymad Studios Head, Ian Bell, states "Yup, and if you need to pass this on, we really dislike Nintendo users" on Forum to Wii U players waiting for the game and disappointed in the news.05/25/2015 - 4:03pm
Goth_SkunkAnd now, a humorous gif. Oblivious Otter is Oblivious. http://i.imgur.com/zdUZOWo.gif05/25/2015 - 3:49pm
Goth_Skunka bonified game dev.05/25/2015 - 3:45pm
Goth_SkunkGranted, most of that feedback is going to be vicious, but if a novice dev knows full well not to expect their hastily strewn together game as the next Grand Theft Auto, such curmudgeonly feedback shouldn't deter them from their ultimate goal of becoming05/25/2015 - 3:45pm
Goth_SkunkAdditionally, Steam is a platform whereby these novice devs can showcase what they were able to put together and see what kind of feedback they can get from the community.05/25/2015 - 3:44pm
Goth_SkunkI don't think it's wrong for a novice dev to want to recover any losses from people willing to pay money for what they have produced, either. After all, every game dev had to start somewhere.05/25/2015 - 3:41pm
Goth_SkunkI disagree. I think that for novice developers, this tactic still at a fundamental level teaching someone the ins and outs of video game development.05/25/2015 - 3:41pm
PHX Corp@MW There are things that developers are doing that drive me up the Wall as a consumer, reused Unity assets is no Exception to said rule05/25/2015 - 2:17pm
Matthew Wilsonhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5svAoQ7D38k this is stupid, and the fact its allowed is stupid.05/25/2015 - 1:52pm
james_fudgeHappy Memorial Day to everyone05/25/2015 - 7:13am
Mattsworknamealso, in MGR, on higher levels, button mashing will get you reckt, you have to master parry to even have a prayer05/24/2015 - 8:52pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician