D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

October 25, 2008 -

A man who rides Washington, D.C.'s Metro underground rail system has written to the Washington Post to complain about poster ads for Fallout 3 which appear in the Metro Center station.

Joseph Anzalone criticizes the ads as well as Metro management for accepting them:

In one ad, the Washington Monument and the American flags surrounding it stand ravaged, as if hit by missiles. In another, the Capitol dome is partially caved in, while the rest of the building and the city behind it lie in ruins.

The people of our city do not need a daily reminder that Washington is a prime target for an attack. We do not need a daily reminder of what our worst fears look like. Since any First Amendment objection would be irrelevant (the ads do not present a true viewpoint or political message and would therefore not be protected), there is no reason for these ads to be part of our daily panorama.

The ads should be removed, and the appropriate office at Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority should be directed to exercise better judgment regarding what can be displayed in our transportation system.

GP: Whether the ads are in poor taste is a matter of opinion, but Anzalone gets his constitutional argument wrong. The First Amendment protects more than "true viewpoints" and "political messages". That's why they call it free speech.


Comments

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

I guess this goes along with him BBB complaint about NukaCola's bottling practices and FCC registration of his VaultBoy watch?

Seriously, video games are usually about conflict. They aren't even using imagry that offends most people, like personal injury or violence, rather it is indescriminate and impersonal violence of a nuclear holocaust. He is upset because it COULD happen, and he doesn't want to be reminded of that. Guess what, that emotion it is evoking? That's art. This same person would be offended by "hippies" protesting the building of nuclear weapons because it exposes him to said fear.

In his next public statement, he says "Get off my lawn you kids!"

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

yeah, i can't believe someone wanted to write in about an ad for a game based on 1.) a past that didn't happen, and 2.) a future that is 200 years in front of us. what a joke. take up a nobler cause, dude.

also, the metro was filled with all kinds of ads for this game, beyond the reported screenshots by the clown who wrote to the washington post. vault boy makes several appearances, as do fake cereal box ads. it is a pretty phenomenal campaign that will end just in time for the guy who complained to think he was responsible.

 

 

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

I am surprised that it took this long for someone to complain.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Okay, as much as I hate it, I have to agree.

Those shouldn't be in D.C. or other places where people feel they are high priority targets for attack.

It's negative PR, and unlike the ATHF stuff (which this instantly reminded me of), it won't boost sales, and might turn public opinion further against video games.

It'd be like putting a huge big mac sign outside of a clinic that specializes in bulemia. As hilarious as it might sound, it'd do harm, and would cause people to want to avoid the product.

Now if it was like a commercial advertisement for one of the vaults, it might be a bit more tolerable. heh.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Who's to say it won't boost sales? Last I heard brand recognition and exposure were considered good things in advertising terms. Hell, probably the negative publicity will boost sales (look at GTA, for crying out loud).

Also, censoring ourselves to a degree that's not required of any other media will reinforce the stereotype that games are not an art form and are not "equals" with film, television, and the performing arts. We don't want that. You can't just take down everything that might make somebody somewhere feel uncomfortable.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

I'm guessing you don't live anywhere near D.C. and it's surrounding counties? Those of us that grew up here don't "feel" we're a high priority target for attack, we know we are. Growing up this is realized about the time we learn about the concept of war and nuclear war. From there it's a short step to the realization we'd stand a fairly good chance of being inside the fireball looking out in the event of one.

It doesn't particluarly bother most of us. It's just one of those facts of life, similar to how the various monuments around here are seen as "It's just the monuments." Just another one of those things we take for granted.

-Gray17

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Vegeta what's his fail level.....

IT'S OVER NINE THOUSAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAND!

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

WHAT?!? Nine Thousand?!?

 

All we need now is a shoop da woop and we've turned into 4chan . . . *facepalm*

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

I live in DC.  If you aren't already aware of the fact we're a prime target, you're an idiot.  If being reminded of that fact bothers you that much, move.

  -P, who has no sympathy for twits like this.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Wow that is just so stupid.......

Vegeta what's his fail level.....

 

Never underestimate the power of idiots in large amounts.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

*Crushing scouter*

"It's over 9000!!!"

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Sir! His fail level is over 7500!! (As opposed to JT's 10,000,000)

Hunting the shadows of the troubled dreams.

Hunting the shadows of the troubled dreams.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

WTF is a "true viewpoint"?

Saying that Jack Thompson is impotent is an insult to impotent men everywhere. They've got a whole assortment of drugs that can cure their condition; Jack, however...

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

I hope they tell the guy to shut the hell up, and quit being a dumbass.

Nido Web Flash Tutorials AS2 and AS3 Tutorials for anyone interested.
How to set Xbox 360 Parental Controls

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

I've lived in DC, and trust me. Those ads are the least of DC riders concerns, considering the reason the Metro hasn't gone under is because the Feds own it. And aprrently he must not watch 24 or a few other shows who's name escape me at the moment. If he paid attention for more than a moment he would realize that "Fallout 3" and Bethesda Softworks" logos are slapped on them. "True viewpoint" "Political message"? What the hell is that even suppose to mean, the game is basiclly "Mad Max."

 

Let me put that on my to-don't list.

Let me put that on my to-don't list.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

Now compare to:

"Since any First Amendment objection would be irrelevant (the ads do not present a true viewpoint or political message and would therefore not be protected), there is no reason for these ads to be part of our daily panorama."

 

Ok...so his arguement is that because the ads to not have any form of political nature or viewpoint to them, that they're not covered under the First Ammendment.  He apparently doesn't read much.  Where in the First Ammendment does it give any sort of requirement that speech has to be political in some way for it to be protected?

The answer is no where.  To be concise, it says that the government shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech.  That's is it.  It means all speach and any speach, you shallow, narrow minded, insecure jackass.  And now you've written something to the paper that's been published, and now everyone can see you're an idiot as well.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

I think we DO need a daily reminder that D.C. is a viable target.  Maybe it'll help shape our foreign policies a bit, make us think a little more before we start WWIII.

"HEY! LISTEN!"

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Yeah and it IS just a game. 

Guess we should be glad it took this long before someone got their panties in a bunch.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

That would be funny as hell IMO.

Yes I have a WIP. Just wait and see.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

@ronnoc

If I find the time, I will try to write something. I use DC metro weekly and have seen the ads, but from an objective standpoint, I can't see why anybody would complain about them. Honestly... ffffffffffff, great, now I'm raged.

Yes I have a WIP. Just wait and see.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

  Well, I hope a GP reader in the Wasignton area will write in to the paper and set him straight.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

I though the whole concept of free speech is that you can talk about anything you want. It doesn't limit to political messages. As far as I know, the only time the the first amendment is excluded is "Clear and present danger" like yelling bomb at a airport.

I bet if 9/11 never happened, people wouldn't mind the ad anyway as much as they do today.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

And who, may I ask, is Joseph Anzalone? He has no credentials, no title, no law degree. So, what makes him qualified to make pronouncements about what the First Amendment protects, or doesn't protect? Right, then.

Also, I was a little put off by this comment:

"The ads should be removed, and the appropriate office at Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority should be directed to exercise better judgment regarding what can be displayed in our transportation system." [my emphasis]

So, he wants to chill free speech by making rules about what can (not "should") be displayed in the subway? Y'know, I don't think that the ads are that great - they're obviously presenting a provocatively frightening image in order to get people to look - but I don't think they should be censored. Pretty soon they'll be complaining that the ads in the subway are pro-immigrant (schools for learning English) or that they're immoral (that woman advertising the new NBC show is revealing too much cleavage) and then we're on a slippery slope to Censorship Land.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Credentials does not stop anybody from being a dumbass. Nor do they stop somebody from being wrong in their subjects. Have you already forgotten Jack Thompson? Didn't you notice that Joe Biden (a constitutional lawyer) was completely ignorant on the powers, position, and location in the constitution of those powers and that position of the Vice President of the United States? 

To clarify: I agree with your ends, but not your means.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Sorry dude,

Fallout's post-nucular war theme precedes the current war.

 - Warren Lewis

Consumer responsibility is just as important as Corporate responsibility. So, be responsible consumers.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

So, apparently it takes almost three weeks to cook up a complaint? 

What's amusing is the sense of false accomplishment this guy will have in a couple weeks.  I'm assuming that the ads were probably supposed to run through the end of the month, which is next week.  If that's the case then another week will go by and then the ads will be replaced by something else and then this guy will think "Look at that, I did that with my keen misunderstanding of the First Amendment."

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Next thing you know, people will start saying "Stop reporting about deaths in the news, we do not need reminders that we will eventually die."


Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

But what would the 24 hour news networks report on for 23 hours of the day if that happens???

There are already people complaining about this and they have a point, the 'news' networks like to report on sensational death stories a bit too much...

 

As for the Metro thing, I am surprised that so few people have complained... I seroulsy expected a huge moralist movement... This little amount of outrage about a game that is 'corrupting our youth and training them to want to nuke washington'(I expected this to be said about it...) has been an expected surprise, I guess people are finally getting it into their brains that games are just games...

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

If the works of Andrew Pollock and Andy Warhol are protected by the First Amendment (and they are) then so is this. The art itself express viewpoints and ideas in our minds.

"No law means no law" - Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black on the First Amendment

"No law means no law" - Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black on the First Amendment

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

I have no idea what meaning there is behind Warhol's drawing of cans of Campbell's Soup.  All I know is that the colors are pretty and they look like cans of Campbell's Soup.

And if that qualifies for First Amendment protection, most things do.  Incitement to riot (must be very specific), creating a dangerous sitaution (yelling "FIRE!" in a crowded theater when no fire exists) and direct threats on the President's life are the only exceptions I can think of.

"That's not ironic. That's justice."

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

P.A.R.A.N.O.I.D. Worst fear? What about The Great Depression II? What about Abolishment of Constitutional Rights...oh wait...whose side is this guy on?

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

 Uninformed moron is uninformed.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Somebody failed high school government. Commercial speech (of which these ads fall into) are protected so long as they do not violate special situations (the Miller Test). 

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

I say, just for spite, place MORE ads! /joke

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Unfortunately, free speech doesn't exist in the minds of political and evangelical loudmouths.

---You are likely to be eaten by a Grue.

---You are likely to be eaten by a Grue.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

No, I have to disagree with that one.  It exists just for them. Or at least that is what they usually have in their heads. 

Jeremy Powers aka Zen
Panama City, Fl.

Zen aka Jeremy Powers
Editor and Host of the Zenspath Podcast (now on iTunes)
www.ZensPath.com
XBL: "PsychoticZen" PSN: "Zenspath"
Nintendo Network: "Psychoticzen", 3DS: "3024-7965-4819

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

No, it doesm just it only exists for them and those who share their views exactly.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

lol its so daft.

 

How many films have been advertised in the metro that feature terrorists, washington, bombs, etc etc

I mean ban adverts for '24' , that show is all about the terrorists. So completely daft.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

"Since any First Amendment objection would be irrelevant (the ads do not present a true viewpoint or political message and would therefore not be protected), there is no reason for these ads to be part of our daily panorama."

FALSE!!!

The ads coudl very well be interpreted to depict a literal wasteland that many believe Washington to be figuratively already.

 

Opps, guess I'm anti-american now, put me o na watch list for speaking my mind.

Re: D.C. Metro Rider Complains About Fallout 3 Ads

Was only a matter of time, to be honest, no-one worried about 'The Day After' etc, and they were quite horrific, but then they weren't those dratted 'Vidja Games'...

You'll always get people who will be oversensitive, purely because they can be.

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
PHX Corphttp://www.polygon.com/2015/7/27/9050375/street-fighter-5-beta-offline-delayed Street Fighter 5 beta taken offline, now postponed indefinitely07/27/2015 - 9:51pm
Goth_Skunk@eZeek: Noooooooooo.... ;)07/27/2015 - 8:44pm
MechaTama31Re: Google+, wow. I never in a million years thought they would backpedal on that. I just resigned myself to not using commenting functions on any of their services.07/27/2015 - 6:21pm
E. Zachary KnightGoth, are you saying all women are fat. ;)07/27/2015 - 5:38pm
benohawkMake it more adorable and more gender neutral! Widescreen Dog and 16:9 their 16 kitten sidekicks07/27/2015 - 5:15pm
Goth_SkunkOr, if you prefer, Widescreen Woman.07/27/2015 - 4:12pm
Goth_SkunkWho will save us from this abominable practice?! Introducing WIDESCREEN MAN and his sidekick 16:9!07/27/2015 - 4:10pm
Andrew EisenInteresting coincidence. I tweeted about the evils of vertically oriented video just last night. https://twitter.com/AndrewEisen/status/62549836960397312007/27/2015 - 4:01pm
PHX Corphttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iJ_I9-CkzDE The Great Atari Ransack (The Jimquisition) Warning Vertical video syndrome in one scene07/27/2015 - 3:40pm
MattsworknameBout time google07/27/2015 - 3:33pm
james_fudgeugh. TG man :)07/27/2015 - 1:15pm
MechaCrashGoogle drops Google+ requirements for YouTube and other services: http://venturebeat.com/2015/07/27/google-is-dropping-its-google-requirement-across-all-products-starting-with-youtube/07/27/2015 - 12:55pm
benohawkThat still isn't Steam pay royalties. At best it is Bethesda not being willing to relicense the music,07/27/2015 - 12:51pm
Infophile(cont'd) different service. This often happened with TV shows, where music was only licensed for broadcast, but not for DVD release. So for many older shows, they either have to relicense it or use different/no music for the DVD release.07/27/2015 - 12:36pm
Infophile@benohawk: It most likely comes down to the original licensing agreement for the music in it. Often those agreements only license it for the medium it first releases in, so it has to be re-licensed if it's rereleased in a different form or through a ...07/27/2015 - 12:35pm
benohawkWhy would steam be paying royalties on anything in quake?07/27/2015 - 12:01pm
black mantaI recommend using the KMQuake II patch which supports .ogg music files, then downloading the music from someplace, then dropping it in to a music folder into the \baseq2 directory.07/27/2015 - 10:32am
black mantaI got Quake 2 during the Steam Quakecon sale. Funny thing is, there's no music for it! Guess Steam didn't want to pay the royalty fees or something.07/27/2015 - 10:30am
black mantaLike EZK, I also have a backlog of games. Right now I'm playing Crysis 3 for the first time, and replaying Quake 2.07/27/2015 - 10:29am
E. Zachary KnightZippy, No. It is because I have a backlog of games a mile long and have not bought to many new games, which includes Mass Effect.07/27/2015 - 9:28am
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician