Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court... Madden Document Played Critical Role

November 11, 2008 -

A U.S. District Court jury in San Francisco has awarded $28 million to a group of 2,062 retired pro football players in a class-action lawsuit against the National Football League Players Association. The NFLPA is the union which represents active NFL players.

The jury returned a $7 million verdict against the NFLPA and then piled on $21 million worth of punitive damages.

While Madden publisher Electronic Arts was not a party in the case, the NFLPA's negotiations with EA over licensing the images of retired players was a central piece of evidence in the trial, which lasted for three weeks.

As GamePolitics reported before the trial began, lawyers for the retired players uncovered several "smoking gun" e-mails which indicated that the NFLPA not only sold rights to the retired players at below market value, but deliberately undercut potential competition from rival sports publisher Take-Two Interactive.

Those critical e-mails include a message from former NFLPA exec LaShun Lawson to Madden producer Jeremy Strauser:

For all retired players that are not listed... their identity must be altered so that it cannot be recognized [by Madden players]... Hence, any and all players not listed... cannot be represented in Madden 2002 with the number that player actually wore, and must be scrambled.

In an apparent reference to Take-Two's failed All-Pro Football 2K8, an e-mail from NFLPA exec Clay Walker touches on how Take-Two lost out in the union's deal with EA:

Take Two... went after retired players to create an “NFL” style video game after we gave the exclusive to EA. I was able to forge this deal with [the Pro Football Hall of Fame] that provides them with $400K per year (which is significantly below market rate) in exchange for the HOF player rights. EA owes me a huge favor because that threat was enough to persuade Take Two to back off its plans, leaving EA as the only professional football videogame manufacturer out there.

At issue was the depiction of old school players on classic NFL teams included with Madden. The Los Angeles Times reports that each retired player involved in the lawsuit will receive $13,000. Lead plaintiff Herb Adderley, who wept when the verdict was read, told the L.A. Times:

If you look at the 1967 Green Bay Packers in that game, you'll know that the only left cornerback that year had to be Herb Adderley, but they scrambled my face and took the number off of my jersey. Yet, they had my correct height, weight and years of experience.

The San Francisco Chronicle reports that defense lawyer Jeffrey Kessler expects the jury's verdict to be overturned, calling it "unjust as a matter of law." An appeal to the 9th Circuit Court by the NFLPA seems virtually assured.


Comments

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in ...

That is really great news but I wonder if they ever thought of pre settlement lawsuit funding

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in ...

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

En Mexico quien sera el indicado de emitir el voto por todos nostoros los mexicanos? si cae como todo lo demas en el senado el voto sera el mismo siempre ya que ni trabajan y de ser el CONACyT espero realmente se pongan las pilas para evitar el mas que evidente monopolio por parte de la ventanita

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in ...

EA was at no point a defendant or party in the court proceedings. It has not been charged of any wrongdoing ( Online University ) and its purchase of the retired NFL player licenses in question were done within the eyes of the law. The defendants of the case were the NFLPA ( School of Nursing ). The matters surrounding the deal involving NFL 2002 was one of several accusations against the NFLPA. The defendant’s lawyer Jeffrey Kessler says he expects the jury's verdict to be overturned. ( Human Resource Degree )

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

The NFLPA on the other hand did have that obligation to do the best they could for their members, both active players, and retired ones. film izle

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

And they should have acted due to that obligation.

foam mattress | memory foam beds

Garry Wertu

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

Also, as far as Jibboo's comment about no one caring about old players, how many people are buying the game to play the 2008 Browns? Or the Raiders? I bet if you look at the raw numbers of what teams get played the most, the Dolphins aren't in the top 10. And how many gamers make trades until all the household names are on one team?

Is anyone playing Madden for anyone other than the marquee players? Yet the no-name jobbers get paid in full for their likenesses. Name one guy on the Ravens that isn't Ray Lewis. Or the second-string QB on the Colts. That guy has a SB ring and no one knows who he is.

That's the point of this lawsuit. Fair money, or at least fair business practices. But you can't take away both.

-Legend in my spare time

-Legend in my spare time

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

Here's a thought: Madden sucks. When was the last good Madden game, Sega Genesis?

Any monopoly is bad, especially in a creative field like video games. And what is the only way to break apart this monopoly? Stop buying the crappy schlock they throw out each year. Force them to make a better game. Go out and buy another football game to satisfy your temporary desire to play virtual football.

One week after the game's release, every year, there are at least 20 copies that have been traded in at GameStop, EB Games, etc. It reminds me of the guy sin NYC who protested the French a few years back by buying French wine and then dumping it down the sewer. That is moot beacuse the French already have your money, so what do they care if you dump it in a sewer?

Same with Madden. As long as people buy the game, EA and Madden won't care if the game gets returned, broken, lost, given away, thrown out, or traded in. The only protest is to ignore them (like that episode of the Simpsons when the advertisements come to life).

Also, the guy that wrote that "EA owes me" email is so burned. HAHAHAH! And if I were T2, I would sue EA and that guy for unfair business practices.

-Legend in my spare time

-Legend in my spare time

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

 

Amen - football games haven't been the same since EA got a monopoly. Hopefully we see the end of the exclusive EA/NFL relationship someday.

-------

My Site: Toy Reviews

------- My Site: Toy Reviews

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

Sadly Jibboo is probably correct, the use of old players as a selling point is at best very limited but if the player's likenesses are used, they do have every right to be compensated and I'm damned glad the NFLPA didn't get away with treating them like crap

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

Seriously ... is there anybody out there buying Madden so they can be the 67 Packers? or the 76 packers for that matter or how about the 86 packers ... man nobody cares about guys who played in the NFL 20 years ago ... unless they are Jim Brown or Walter Payton.  These old guys should be thankful that anyone even remembers who they were.  I highly doubt there are many 50-somethings playing madden.

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

Wow, non sequiteur much?

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

From the story, I think that EA's not going to be fined anything, but it's the National Football League Players Association that's footing the bill. So I'm pretty sure that EA is off the hook, as they can simply feign ignorance and say they had no idea the Association was undercutting T-2

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

I think that EA's off the hook regardless, from the standpoint that they have no obligation to provide the best possible for retired football players. The NFLPA on the other hand did have that obligation to do the best they could for their members, both active players, and retired ones.

-Gray17

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

HA! Eat it EA! That's what you get for your dirty law practices!

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...


Yeah EA, give T2 some money, haha. 

barra - I think that every day...

Funny thing is, EA is at 22.9, which is less than their bid to buy T2, who is at 12.1...  T2 used to be 30% the price of EA, now it is around half the price.  That is just stock value though.  T2 is still only worth 12% of what EA is, even though I wish it was an exact relation to the stock price.

---
Nido Web Flash Tutorials AS2 and AS3 Tutorials for anyone interested.
Financial Calculator

Nido Web Flash Tutorials AS2 and AS3 Tutorials for anyone interested.
How to set Xbox 360 Parental Controls

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

EA being evil? I could have never guessed...

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

One week after the game's release, every year, there are at least 20 copies that have been traded in at GameStop, EB Games, etc. It reminds me of the guy sin NYC who protested the French a few years back by buying French wine and then dumping it down the sewer. (torin floor jack and low profile car jacks)
Garry Wertu

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

"unjust as a matter of law."
Because we all know the law is supposed to protect crooks that scam people out of the money they deserve. *has flashbacks to Sinfest comic about Bankstas*

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

I don't think those old school NFl players deserve to win, but who am I to say that.

PMI Certification

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

Duh. That is what the law is for.

Re: Old School NFL Players Score $28 Million Win in Court...

Funny thing is, EA is at 22.9, which is less than their bid to buy T2, who is at 12.1... T2 used to be 30% the price of EA, now it is around half the price. That is just stock value though. Commission Ritual Bonuses | Commission Ritual
Garry Wertu
 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
PHX Corphttps://www.kickstarter.com/projects/iga/bloodstained-ritual-of-the-night/description apparently Bloodstained: ritual of the night will have a Wii U version(through Armature Games)05/26/2015 - 9:02pm
WonderkarpSo I found out I'm Invincible Today. I drove through a Tornado and didnt even know it. was windy and torrential downpour but I drove through like a boss. 05/26/2015 - 7:35pm
ZenEnded up giving the code to Andrew so he gets to be the other guinea pig lol.05/26/2015 - 6:53pm
ZenSo...who wants to help with an experiment and get a free game for 3DS and possibly Wii U lol? Gave a friend the Wii u OlliOlli code from the Humble Bundle and it gave him the 3DS one too. Still have a 3DS code which may give a Wii U version too.05/26/2015 - 4:35pm
Zenjust wish they had been as open about development as they were with X1 and PS4. All we got were interviews saying everything was great and then this lol.05/26/2015 - 4:14pm
ZenYeah, he brought it up again as time went on and stated it was not to be taken seriously. And I am in NO way defending people who are acting like...well....the not so nice way to say "butts". And I don't personally think they haven't worked on the game, I05/26/2015 - 4:12pm
Andrew EisenSo I can see why Bell would be ultra defensive and snippety. But, again, still not an advisable thing to say.05/26/2015 - 3:57pm
Andrew Eisennot to mention horrifically insulting.05/26/2015 - 3:56pm
Andrew EisenAgreed, even out of frustration, not an advisable thing to post. As for the rest, sounds like it thought its tweeks and optimizations would work. The idea that it was stringing everyone along and not actually working on it is nearly nonsensical...05/26/2015 - 3:55pm
Zenand looking great...yet refused to even show a single screen shot while touting their open development on X1 and PS4. People are now asking if they even worked on the game or if it was dropped in the beginning & they were keeping up appearances instead.05/26/2015 - 3:53pm
ZenI understand that, but making a blanket statement to cover an entire market like that will do nothing more than push consumers away or alienate a group. Other issues stem from the interviews and public announcements they made stating the game is running05/26/2015 - 3:52pm
Andrew EisenNot an advisable thing to post, I'll grant you.05/26/2015 - 3:47pm
Andrew EisenReading the thread, it looks like he's just getting frustrated with the obnoxious and unreasonable members of the board (most of whom signed up that day).05/26/2015 - 3:47pm
ZenNintendo users in general by stating "Yup, and if you need to pass this on, we really dislike Nintendo users." on their forum. Sincere or not, it's annoyed some fans & put doubt on the company even trying.05/26/2015 - 3:35pm
ZenThey pushed that even just a few months ago it was running great, with effects, but they just needed a few tweeks before release. I posted about this last night, but it has since cycled thru. Ian Bell also had some fairly disparaging things to say about05/26/2015 - 3:34pm
Matthew Wilson@AE @iamc they admired they cant do wiiu, and they have a valid reason for it. the wiiu is too weak.05/26/2015 - 3:24pm
Andrew EisenLied about what?05/26/2015 - 3:11pm
IanCThey outright lied, they kept pushing that it was coming out on Wii U right to they got a publisher, then went quiet. Funny that...05/26/2015 - 3:09pm
Matthew Wilsonhttp://www.vg247.com/2015/05/26/project-cars-struggling-to-hit-720p30fps-on-wii-u/ I love that he is honest. they admited that they are at their wits end with the wiius hardware.05/26/2015 - 1:48pm
E. Zachary KnightHumbleSupport has said the codes don't expire. So That is pretty tempting.05/26/2015 - 1:38pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician