ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax Proposals

February 25, 2009 -

As states try to plug their budget gaps, some are preparing to levy taxes on digital downloads.

Such action will have a direct impact on gamers who use digital distribution to purchase games and DLC. Music and other digital content will also be affected.

On behalf of game consumers, the Entertainment Consumers Association has launched action campaigns against such initiatives in Washington, New York and Mississippi. ECA President Hal Halpin explained the move in the letter below to Washington state members yesterday:

The Washington state legislature is currently proposing a bill which would impose a tax on digitally distributed products, known as House Bill 2075.  The timing could not be worse. This bill would harm Washington consumers - including you - by raising prices at exactly the time that so many are feeling the repercussions of the economic fallout.

Speak up now and tell the Washington state legislature "no" to HB 2075.

One result of this legislation will be to suppress consumption, which will cause layoffs at effected businesses, including the video game industry, which employs many Washington residents.

Tell your representative to vote "no" on HB 2075
.

In the midst of a financial crisis, bills such as this are precisely what consumers don't need. Please take the time to write your state representative, and also help spread the word by telling your friends in Washington State.

FULL DISCLOSURE DEPT: The ECA is the parent company of GamePolitics.


Comments

Re: ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax ...

Where I draw the line with digital downloads is that you are not getting the same value for an item as with a physical copy.

Ask anyone who used yahoo's music service.  If the service goes away then generally you are left holding a bag of dead DRM'ed music files.

If I have to pay taxes on the files that I download then I want government intervention.  I want all digital downloads to be DRM free and I want LIFETIME gurenteed redownload capability.

Alternately the ability to resell my "purchased" items would be nice also.  I can resell the old copy of civ3 I found in my desk but I can't really resell the copy of on the Rain-slick precipice of darkness that I bought from greenhouse.

 

Re: ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax

Just a thought, maybe GPers and ECAers should check out govit.com.  They are currently lacking the pro-gamer voice in reguards to HR 231.

Re: ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax

It is refreshing to once again see the ECA support the idea of keeping government out of games.  I support this effort 100%.

Re: ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax

Could not agree more, kudos to Mr. Haplin for this one. 

Re: ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax

To be fair, it's not unreasonable for it to be taxed because it's still a product and service. So far, digital downloads I think for the most part are GST or PST free. Not that I like it, but it's not unreasonable. And I don't think it really matters if it is a physical thing or not because stuff like Insurance isin't physical either yet is still taxed.

Re: ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax ...

I currently live in a neighboring state to washington that has no sales tax.

Across the river is Vancouver, WA and I know several people who do all their shopping in stores on this side simply to avoid sales tax.

For big purchases like Cars, home electronics, etc this can be a very big difference in the price.

What in the world is going to stop someone from washington from spoofing their location with a PO box or a simple proxy server from a non-DD taxing state?

The problem becomes enforcement.  When it's a different country, or continent you seldom have much choice in the matter as the difference is harder to spoof but I'd bet my last dollar that there are people in the UK, France etc that are playing MMO's on US servers without having to drop the extra cash for the VAT.

You can't make people pay taxes without some kind of oversight, it's simply an unnatural act and as seems to have been proven time and again people will always find a way to not pay them.

Even if WA does pass the bill, they would have to make every single online retailer enforce it and as was proven in the case of the NY online sales tax Amazon basicly told them to go Screw and stopped collecting it.

 

Re: ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax

In the uk we already pay 17.5% VAT tax on all digital downloads...

and yes that even includes 17.5% added to mmo subscription fees.

I TOTALLY dont understand the justification.

Re: ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax

17.5%?! Damn. That seems high. My state's sales tax in store is just under 10%.

Re: ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax

I respect the spirit behind this, but DD is going to be taxed especially as more consumer switch from buying physical media to downloads.  There's just too much potential tax revenue there for the politicians to ignore.  Not to mention that because of these hard economic times the States are looking for any way they can get money for their budgets.

At best I think this will only delay them taxing it.  I'll write to my rep and everything, but I'm not expecting DD to be tax free for very long.

 

Tea and cake or death! Tea and cake or death! Little Red Cook-book! Little Red Cook-book!

Tea and cake or death! Tea and cake or death! Little Red Cook-book! Little Red Cook-book!

Re: ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax

I think the thoughts behind it go something along the lines of:

Everyone is having a tough economic time. The state is as well as it's people. So in the state's answer to ease the state's tough economic times is to make things harder for the people by adding new taxes. We don't think so.

E. Zachary Knight
Oklahoma City Chapter of the ECA
http://www.theeca.com/chapters_oklahoma

Re: ECA Mobilizing Protests Against Digital Download Tax

The usual problem isn't really with the Tax itself, the problem is the company selling the product now becomes a tax-collector for a state they aren't actually in. And as such these laws all require a company from another state to send them their tax money, however since many online businesses don't file their taxes in all 50 states.....you see the problem here.

Unfortunately, since these are all state taxes, it's hard to enforce across state lines without aggravating someone. Especially considering the constitution limits the State's jurisdiction to subjects within it's borders and interstate commerce is supposedly limited to the Feds.

Mainly it's just confusing and contradictive of the current practices.

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Poll

Which group is more ethically challenged?:

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
TechnogeekI'll be honest. I mostly just wanted an excuse to use that line.07/02/2015 - 1:13pm
Andrew EisenIt's long scrolled out of the Shout box so here's the article in question if anyone wants to read it: http://www.wired.com/2015/06/rape-scenes/07/02/2015 - 1:05pm
Andrew EisenOh come now, I don't believe Goth said the Wired author shouldn't be allowed to say what he claims she said.07/02/2015 - 1:04pm
TechnogeekWhich really makes it seem like Goth_Skunk's complaints are nothing more than...(•_•) (-•_•)>⌐■-■ (⌐■_■)...crocodile tears.07/02/2015 - 12:22pm
TechnogeekYou know, despite often as I've seen Gators conflate criticism and censorship, it's still kind of ridiculous to see "YOU SHOULDN'T BE ALLOWED TO SAY THAT" as a response to "you probably shouldn't say that unless you can do it well".07/02/2015 - 12:22pm
Andrew EisenI get the feeling Nintendo suspected the same thing would happen with the Wii U.07/02/2015 - 12:16pm
Andrew EisenMecha - Yeah, pretty much the only way you're getting away with a console that's a full technological generation behind is if it become's a full-blown pop-culture phenomenon like the Wii.07/02/2015 - 12:16pm
Infophile(cont'd) That's basically what the article is saying about rape. If you don't know enough about it to handle it well, it's a bad idea to do it, as you'll probably do it poorly.07/02/2015 - 12:06pm
Infophile@Goth, EZK: For example, I could very well try to write a book about the difficulties of living with Fibromyalgia. No one would stop me. However, since I don't know a thing about living with fibromyalgia, writing a book about it would be a very bad idea.07/02/2015 - 12:05pm
MechaCrashI just hope they realize that part of the problem with the Wii U was its relative lack of power. You can still make good games with what the Wii U has, but third parties won't want to deal with it when they can target the more popular PS4/XB1.07/02/2015 - 10:59am
Andrew EisenReplace "NX" with "QOL" and I'd buy it as potentially true.07/02/2015 - 10:51am
Andrew EisenNintendo to start manufacturing NX in October to target a July 2016 launch with 20 million consoles shipped the first year. Sure... http://www.digitimes.com/news/a20150702PD204.html07/02/2015 - 10:47am
james_fudgeLet's avoid name calling in the shoutbox07/02/2015 - 8:55am
E. Zachary KnightThe Daily WTF has a nice run down of some of the impact to software that the US Supreme Court ruling on gay marriage has. http://thedailywtf.com/articles/i-m-not-married-to-the-idea07/02/2015 - 7:45am
MechaCrashGee, how did people ever get the idea Gaters are morons who argue in bad faith? It's such a mystery.07/02/2015 - 7:03am
E. Zachary KnightGoth, again, no one is saying that we shouldn't be writig uncomfortable subject matter. What people are saying is that chances are you are going to write it poorly so it would be better to not have done it at all.07/02/2015 - 7:00am
Goth_Skunkdiscussed or portrayed in an expressive medium. Such an opinion only serves to stifle discussion. And as I said before, the only thing not worth talking about is what shouldn't be talked about.07/02/2015 - 6:50am
Goth_Skunk@Info: The same reason why I would entertain the notion that the Wired article writer could be right: Curiosity. Except in this case, I'm not curious at all. I'm not interested in hearing anyone's opinion on why uncomfortable subject matter shouldn't be07/02/2015 - 6:49am
IvresseI think the problem with the Batmobile is that they made it a core aspect of the game that you have to do continuously. If it was basically a couple of side games that were needed for secret stuff or a couple of times in the main game, it would be fine.07/02/2015 - 5:38am
Infophile@Goth: If you're not willing to entertain the idea you might be wrong, fine. That's your right. But why should anyone else entertain the idea that you might be right? If they go by the same logic, they already know you're wrong, so why listen to you?07/02/2015 - 3:53am
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician