Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget Plan

April 23, 2009 -

Chancellor of the Exchequer Alistair Darling (left) has put forth a budget for the U.K. but game developers are not happy about his plans.

Edge Online reports that Richard Wilson, head of developers' group Tiga, blasted Darling's proposal for failing to provide what Wilson views as adequate financial incentives for U.K. game creators:

This Budget conspicuously fails to back one of the principal creative industries of the future – games development. It is disappointing that while [Darling] plans to spend £671 billion over the coming financial year... he could not find the £150 million over five years to invest in the tax break for games production.

The Government has missed a trick. Video games are a growing sector and the UK games development sector is still world beating. The Government should have used today’s Budget to reinforce success and introduced a tax break for games production...


Comments

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget Plan

I am most unimpressed, I have been looking at training and studying to get into the industry. Doesn't seem plausable to spend money on materials and qualifications if there might not be any prospect at the end of it. Companies like www.train2game.com who provide games courses must rue at this budget as it has put doubts in my mind.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

The budget was a load of rubbish all around.  I fail to have any sympathies for one particular sector.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

And watch as Canada and Scots steal their talent, other wise known as the PC term "brain drain".

Scotland is part of the UK. Looks like someone has some real brain drain going on there.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

Yes but... Scotland has a seperate parliament and are looking at introducing tax breaks for games developers, that can still happen independantly of this budget. What it does mean though is that it would be more difficult for Scottish tax breaks to be introduced as they are affected by the spending cuts that have/will come in.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

So Scotland will steal the UK's talent? People from the UK will move to Scotland? Some people really need geography lessions.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

Your missing my point (I'm from England so well aware of what constitues the UK thanks)

Had this budget catered for tax breaks to UK developers, all UK developers would have benefitted (obviously), if Scotland alone introduces tax breaks it will likely cause a shift of UK developers to be based in Scotland instead, afterall it's a hell of a lot easier to move headquarters North a few miles than shift the lot of to Canada.

Either Scotland or the UK as a whole introducing tax breaks is clearly a better option than none but it would be better for the UK economical markets if it wasn't centred on a single region.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

 

I'm about to finish my BSc in Computer Science, and I do tend to find the lack of support for the IT Sector, particuarly Entertainment, to be quite frustrating, but then, in general, the entire Budget was pretty much as depressing as I thought it would be.

As for the recession, according to the Chancellor, it'll be finished by Christmas. Sound familiar?

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

Who wants to wager a bet that Rockstar North along with alot of other game devs will move to another country?

Amazing, the budget for the London olympics has gone up from initially being £2.3 billion to almost £10 billion, and people still wonder why companies are leaving the UK because of lack of Government support.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

I'll take that bet.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget Plan

oh no! no government funding for private interest.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget Plan

You seriously missed the reason why so many countries and states decide to give the game industry tax breaks?

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

Games industry = jobs

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

Every industry = jobs.  Does that mean nobody should pay taxes?

I'm tired of the tax break game.  Why does one industry deserve a tax break but not another?  Why not just lower business taxes across the board and put an end to these political tax games?  This system just punishes businesses that don't have the option of moving to another location by making them the only ones who actually pay their full taxes.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

Um... The games industry will still be paying taxes. They will just qualify for more rebates if they were offered. Their employees will still be paying income taxes and other imcome related taxes. That is where the benifit is really at.

By offering cheaper development costs in the form of tax breaks for the company, they will be less likely to move out of the country. By staying in the country, people will not have to leave the country to work. By staying in the country to work, they will be paying that country's taxes and thus bring in income to the country.

What the games industry is saying is that their costs are rising while other developers in nations with tax breaks have costs that are dropping due to those tax breaks. It gets very tempting for industries to move to areas that offer cheaper costs.

So why not compete with those nations and work to keep industry in your own country? But I forget this is the UK. The country that would rather complain that other nations offer better incentives to industries rather than offer those incentives themselves.

E. Zachary Knight
Oklahoma City Chapter of the ECA
http://www.theeca.com/chapters_oklahoma

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

I understand that.  And everything you just said applies to every industry, except fixed location businesses like food services.  My point is why fuck around with tax breaks, just lower taxes and be done with it.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

Thing is, if they dont offer tax breaks to the uk games industry... then how can they compete with other countries (e.g. canada?).

As a U.K. game developer myself graduating literally in the next 4 weeks, i can honestly say that i see no real reason to stay in the UK. as soon as i get some basic experience, im off to canada.

The wages for devs there are roughly 30% better. I cant justify staying here. The UK is haemorraghing talent, im top of my class, and have got 4 interviews lined up already. So i must be doing something right as a game programmer. But i have no plans to stay here. The opinion i have is not  isolated. Believe me.

And whether people accept it or not, you CANNOT make good games without good programmers, no matter how hard you try. You need the workers to be able to make the stuff. Its that simple. If your losing the best devs to other countries, then that other company has better developers than you. Meaning its harder and harder to compete.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

 Canada welcomes you with open arms. Any idea where in Canada you want to go?

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

"Any idea where in Canada you want to go?"

Yeah. Can you direct me to the house of one "Derovius" by any chance?

[/sarcasm]

Seriously, I'd love to see how he took the BanHammer.

-----------------------------



"The sun ever rises on the morrow. We can only live for today, and trust that other days will follow." -Unknown

-----------------------------



"A Chrono Trigger is anything that unleashes its will or desire to change history!" -Gaspar

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

yeah i LOVE canada.

I have friends who live like an hour in between edmonton and calgary. And in edmonton there is....

 

BIOWARE!!!

 

god i would eat my own head to work for them.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

But you'd have problems seeing the screen afterwards ;)


Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget Plan

And watch as Canada and Scots steal their talent, other wise known as the PC term "brain drain".

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget ...

Unfortunately this also applies to Scotland.

Re: Game Developers Lament Lack of Support in U.K. Budget Plan

Don't for get France.

E. Zachary Knight
Oklahoma City Chapter of the ECA
http://www.theeca.com/chapters_oklahoma

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
MattsworknameMaybe among themselves andrew, but I cant find any indicatoin that the gg or anti gg groups ever tried to honestly debate each other, name one time anita debated someone or milo debaated someone from the other side, I cant find any05/04/2015 - 7:15pm
Andrew EisenNot at all true. It's just the jerk faces that aren't willing to be decent, civil human beings. Everyone else is fine and more than willing to talk about stuff.05/04/2015 - 7:04pm
MattsworknameTrue andrew, but to my best effort research, i can find no indication of either side being willing to do that. As far as i can tell, neither side is willing to discusss or debate the other. They just keep attacking each other.05/04/2015 - 6:59pm
Andrew EisenSo... yep, hate should stop. Yep, no one should be bullied into self censorship. And yep, the portrayal of women in video games should be discussed. Not sure who (other than jerk faces) you're going to get to argue against any of that.05/04/2015 - 6:34pm
Andrew EisenThird, that’s a discussion that’s already being had. Unfortunately, it’s those darn jerk faces trying to shoot down and ultimately silence such discussions.05/04/2015 - 6:31pm
Andrew EisenSecond, no one wants to bully the industry into self censorship (except the aforementioned jerk faces who work towards exactly that) so that’s a short discussion too.05/04/2015 - 6:31pm
Andrew EisenOkay, first, I don't think anyone wanted hate or harassment (except the jerk faces pulling that crap) so not much to discuss there.05/04/2015 - 6:30pm
Craig R.I'd say I'm baffled how you can still have your head shoved so far in the sand, Goth, but I'm not.05/04/2015 - 6:23pm
Mattsworknamein05/04/2015 - 6:22pm
MattsworknameFirst, we can all agree the hate has to stop, second, we should discuss the different between wanting more inclusion and trying to bully the industry into self censorship, also, we should discuss not if women appear in games and how, but the context there05/04/2015 - 6:22pm
Andrew EisenWhat are some of the things you'd like to see discussed?05/04/2015 - 6:14pm
MattsworknameAs i said in my comment on the GG story, im hoping this both gets some of the media groups to take and unbiased look at gg and starts a path to reconciliation. Im tried of GG being a fight and not a discussion05/04/2015 - 6:05pm
Goth_SkunkI'm baffled speechless by that leap of logic.05/04/2015 - 5:48pm
Craig R.GG has done a great job making other people, such as Sarkeesian, relevant. But the nebulous group of hate and misogyny? Not so much.05/04/2015 - 5:45pm
Craig R.So every Twitch streamer who has been swatted is now incredibly relevant? Not buying it.05/04/2015 - 5:39pm
james_fudgeHopefully that will be the last update on that story. #tired05/04/2015 - 5:39pm
james_fudgeFYI We updated our story with comments from Arthur Chu and Christina Sommers.05/04/2015 - 5:38pm
Goth_Skunk@Craig: Your definition of 'safe' is peculiar then, because GG is anything but irrelevant. You don't call bomb threats on irrelevant groups of people, nor do you kick out pro-GG supporting expo exhibitors if they're irrelevant.05/04/2015 - 5:29pm
Matthew Wilsonhttp://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/05/04/prime-minister-of-singapore-shares-his-c-code-for-sudoku-solver/ got to admit this is kinda cool.05/04/2015 - 5:24pm
Andrew EisenThe Mary Sue isn't speculating, it's reporting. Matthew is speculating but that's fine in the Shout box. Hell, it's also fine to add a bit of speculation and opinion within your reporting too!05/04/2015 - 5:18pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician