Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

September 28, 2009 -

The United States Supreme Court is scheduled to address an appeal of a Californian videogame law tomorrow, September 29.

Entertainment Merchants Association v. Schwarzenegger (formerly known as The Video Software Dealers Association (VSDA) v. Schwarzenegger), revolves around a Californian law that banned the sale of certain videogames to anyone under 18 years of age. First signed into law by Schwarzenegger in 2005, the law was rejected again in February of 2009 by the 9th Circuit Court of California, which upheld an earlier 2007 ruling that deemed the law unconstitutional.

Schwarzenegger and California Attorney General Jerry Brown appealed to the Supreme Court in May of this year, marking the first time a case involving the restriction of violent game sales to minors has ever been considered by the top court of the United States.

As part of the proceedings, The Supreme Court will also decide whether to accept the amicus brief filed by California State Senator Leland Yee (D) in July of 2009. In the brief, Lee, who authored the original statute at the center of the whole case, argues why the Supreme Court should approve the state of California’s petition for a full hearing. He was supported in the brief by the California Psychiatric and California Psychological Associations.

The Supreme Court’s decision could take a few days or more. A final decision should be made public by next Monday, October 5.

Update: Just to clarify, The Supreme Court did consider a similar topic when ruling on American Amusement Machine Association et al. v Kendrick et al. in 2001, when it denied the City of Indianapolis' petition for certiorari. That case centered on an attempt by the city to limit the display and operation of currency-based machines deemed harmful to minors.


Comments

Re:Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week;Update 1

http://www.scotusblog.com/wp/todays-orders-40/#more-11301

10 cases granted cert so far, and California's appeal is not among those.

Geaux Saints, Geaux Tigers, Geaux Hornets, Jack Thompson can geaux chase a chupacabra.

Geaux Saints, Geaux Tigers, Geaux Pelicans. Solidarity for the Saints = No retreat, no surrender. 2013 = Saints' revenge on the NFL. Even through the darkest days, this fire burns always.

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

Actually, it's out of Yee's hands. This one's on Arnold and Brown.

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

I have a feeling this won't get heard by the Supreme Court. And rightly so. It's already been struck down twice, but I guess Yee really feels the need for a hat trick until he shuts up. 

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

IIRC this bill was to ban ANYONE under 18 from violent video games even though the ESRB says the recommended age is 17 and up. They made all M games AO rated.

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

I meant stupid ban and censor the video game bills. :P 

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

But this Bill isn't about an outright ban or censorship, is it? It's about backing up the ESRB ratings with the force of law.

I can't get my head round why it';s such a big issue for you... well, unless you're under 17, I suppose.

-- teh moominz --

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

Well some of us over 18 do believe minors esspecially older minors like teenagers deserve full Free Speech rights. The nanny-state should have no more right to decide what they can or can't watch, play, read or listen to then adults. They should have the ability to form their own viewpoints based on unrestricted and uncensored access to media that have the capability of presenting ideas, information, messages and opinions.

 "No law means no law" - Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black on the First Amendment

"No law means no law" - Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black on the First Amendment

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

A private, voluntary, rating, getting enforced by law? Sounds real bad. Besides, these ratings are ADVISORY, not mandatory. Big difference.

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

My guess is that Stickboy is probably European like myself, most if not all rating bodies in this part of the world have the force of law behind them and for the most part it works out fine, though here in the UK Carmageddon and Manhunt 2 were banned for a while. Of course the Germans are a bit stricter and the Aussies are pretty much boned as far as getting any of the top FPS games out there uncut.

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

So does that mean that people will keep making stupid bills now?

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

People will always make stupid bills whenever they feel like they don't like something so it should be irradicated.

I want a bill to stop having restraunts naturally put tomatoes on hamburgers, personally. They are slimey, fall off the burger, and negatively affect the taste. They should be a custom order addition instead of being part of the main sandwhich build.

"

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

That's how I feel about pickles.

Although, they're fine on the side.

------- Morality has always been in decline. As you get older, you notice it. When you were younger, you enjoyed it.

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

I kinda hope the Supreme Court does decide to hear the case, though it'd suck for Cali. Also if whenever this does get struck down I hope you use a MK Fatality screenshot to accompany the story. :D

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

I looked at the petitions to watch part 5 on SCOTUSBlog No word of EMA v. Schwarzenegger in all 5 parts of petitions to watch so it has no chance of being granted

Watching JT on GP is just like watching an episode of Jerry springer only as funny as the fights

America has just became its own version of the Jerry Springer Show after a bizarre moment in Florida involving a carnival worker.

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

While it looks like it gonna be rejected the Supreme court should atlease say that this bill is unconstitutional so we would have to deal with another bill like it.

http://www.magicinkgaming.com/

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

You know, I was wondering what this story had to do with an old Genesis Basketball game... Then I got it... You are a sneaky one, Pete...

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

Still pisses me off that he made the appeal when the state was several billion dollars in the fucking hole. Right around the time when he went to Obama and asked "can i has moar monies"?

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

Actually this is the second time the issue has gone to the Supreme Court. In 2001 an Indianapolis city arcade anti-gaming bylaw that was stuck down by 7th circuit court with a wonderfully worded opinion by Judge Posner was appealed to the Supreme Court and SCOTUS denied it. The case was AAMA v. Kendrick and it was the first anti-gaming law that was struck down by the courts.

 "No law means no law" - Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black on the First Amendment

"No law means no law" - Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black on the First Amendment

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

Right, because what California's economy needs right now is more legal fees. 

Gubernatorial recall election, anyone?

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

Gubernatorial recall election, anyone?

I wouldn't recommend it. That last one was a five ring circus that landed you with Schwarzenegger. Another would pretty much be tempting fate.

-Gray17

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

I love how Mr. Yee had said years ago that he would not pursue any further anti-speech legislation after it was defeated.  Like a typical politician, he lied about that.

I think we need a non-profit fundraiser to raise money to buy a copy of the Bill of Rights and have them delivered personally to every politician in Congress...

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

It's looking more and more likely that SCOTUS will not hear the appeal.

Geaux Saints, Geaux Tigers, Geaux Hornets, Jack Thompson can geaux chase a chupacabra.

Geaux Saints, Geaux Tigers, Geaux Pelicans. Solidarity for the Saints = No retreat, no surrender. 2013 = Saints' revenge on the NFL. Even through the darkest days, this fire burns always.

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

 FINISH THEM Supreme Court. ;)

Re: Supreme EMA v. Schwarzenegger Decision Within a Week

You forgot to mention the Eagle Forum also filed an amicus brief.

--------------------------------------------------

I LIKE the fence. I get 2 groups to laugh at then.

-------------------------------------------------- I LIKE the fence. I get 2 groups to laugh at then.
 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Montetrolls are just at their absolute worst when it comes to women and feminist. You could bet good money that if the developer were male the trolls would be silent and the conversation would actually focus on the journalism.10/18/2014 - 9:18pm
MontePapa: Not the first time we've had a journalism scandals before, but the harassment never got close to this level; the difference with this scandal is that feminists are involved. Without the feminist angle, their would be A LOT less harrassment10/18/2014 - 9:15pm
Papa MidnightMonte: That's honestly rather short-sighted. As has been proven with other persons who have been targeted, if it wasn't Quinn, it would be someone else.10/18/2014 - 6:26pm
AvalongodI think that's part of what gives an esoteric news story like this real life...it taps into a larger narrative about misogyny in society outside of games.10/18/2014 - 3:29pm
Avalongod@Monte, well the trolls made death threats that came to police (and media attention). I think this is tapping into a larger issue outside of games about how women are treated in society (like all the "real rape" stuff during the last election)10/18/2014 - 3:28pm
WonderkarpZippy : Havent tried the PS4 controller. might later.10/18/2014 - 2:37pm
MonteSeirously, If Quinn was not involved and GG was instead about something like the Mordor Marketing contracts, the trolling would have never grown so vile and disgusting. There have been plenty of movements in the past that never sufferred from behavior..10/18/2014 - 1:57pm
MonteWe have seen scandel's before but the trolling has never been as vile as what we see with GG. Trolls usually have such a tiny voice you can barely notice them, but its like moths to a flame whenever femistist are involved.10/18/2014 - 1:53pm
ZippyDSMleeWonderkarp: You might be able to if you had a PS4 controller.10/18/2014 - 1:00pm
MaskedPixelantehttp://store.steampowered.com/app/327940/ Night Dive starts charging for freeware.10/18/2014 - 12:21pm
Matthew Wilsonthe sad thing is there are trolls on both sides of this. people need to stop acting like their side is so pure.10/18/2014 - 12:19pm
MechaTama31So, only speak out on a scandal that hasn't attracted trolls? I wouldn't hold my breath...10/18/2014 - 10:49am
MonteI feel like GG just needs to die. The movement is FAR to tainted by hatred and BS for it to be useful for any conversation. Let GG die, and then rally behind the NEXT gaming journalism scandal, and start the conversation fresh.10/18/2014 - 10:33am
quiknkoldand we dont have a Dovakin to call a cease fire10/17/2014 - 7:37pm
quiknkoldThe whole thing is Futile. Both sides are so buried deep in their trenchs that there isnt a conversation. Its just Finger Pointing, Name Calling, Doxxing, Threats. there needs to be a serious conversation, and GG isnt it.10/17/2014 - 7:37pm
quiknkoldI thought it was a good article. Jeff is right. I feel like GamerGate did destroy its message. I am for Ethics in game journalism, but man. so much hate. and its on both sides. I've seen some awful stuff spewed on twitter. Its a big reason why I exited..10/17/2014 - 7:34pm
Matthew Wilsonwhile he focused on gg, he did call out both sides crap.10/17/2014 - 7:18pm
Papa MidnightThat was a damn good read offered by Jeff Gertsmann.10/17/2014 - 7:17pm
Matthew Wilsonhttp://www.giantbomb.com/articles/letter-from-the-editor-10-17-2014/1100-5049/ deferentially a nice write up.10/17/2014 - 6:44pm
james_fudgeI think Evan killed it. He's a great guy and super smart.10/17/2014 - 6:38pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician