A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower Ratings

November 18, 2009 -

Speaking at the recent Montreal International Game Summit, the CEO of a game development company complained that publishers are deliberately deceiving the Entertainment Software Ratings Board (ESRB) in a bid to receive lower age ratings.

Rémi Racine of Artificial Mind & Movement (A2M), creator of Wet and the upcoming PSP version of Dante’s Inferno, said that publishers who attempt to trick the ESRB are looking for a wider audience—and subsequent profits— for their game.

Edge Online offered the following quote from Racine:

As a developer who has worked with a lot of different publishers, we’re aware of many that have tried to cheat the rating. They say to the ERSB that it’s a Teen rating [13+] rather than an Mature [17+] to try and sell more; you can do this just by sending them a video that doesn’t show the most violent stuff and then you’ll get the rating that you want rather than the rating you should get.

The ESRB’s Eliot Mizrachi addressed Racine’s claims, saying:

We regularly check games post-release to verify that submissions were complete, and it’s very likely that if a game contains undisclosed content that would have affected the rating assigned, we’ll find out about it. In such cases ESRB can actually impose fines up to $1 million as well as require corrective actions like re-labeling or even recalling product, both of which can obviously be very costly.

Racine’s comments came from a panel which discussed the social responsibility owed to consumers by those who make up the game industry. Racine was also blunt in his assessment of the game industry’s effectiveness at educating consumers:

Right now I don’t think the industry is doing enough to educate the audience. The ERSB is supposed to do it, but it feels like we just kind of expect these kind of industry or government bodies to do the job for us. As much as I don’t think it’s the place of EA or Activision to go off and try and inform parents on their own, a more active role needs to be taken by all participants to ensure our artists are free to express themselves and that content can be enjoyed responsibly.


Comments

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

Should I need to say it again?

The ESRB, same with the BBFC, PEGI and yes even the OFLC are all nothing but umpires/referees in a football match.

Even though we don't like the decisions they make, all we can do a game developers is just get on with the game and play ball.

If you argue against the umpire/referee even though you think you might be right, the umpire/referee is never going to change their decision and we all have to just get out heads back into the game before we turn out to be the real looser.

And even though we sometimes don't like their decision, we should respect them because they have made decisions that were to our advantage like allowing us all the violent videogames that we can play because they said that they were well within their laws even though the politicians only bitched and moaned and argued against the people who they put in charge of rating videogames.

The people at the ESRB and so on, are there doing the best job they can. If you don't like it, would you rather politicians calling all the shots instead?

I hope you all get that clear,  do you?

 

TBoneTony

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

I agree w/some of you on this post that Racine doesn't obviously know what he is talking about when he thinks the ESRB or the EA or Activision shouldn't educate the audience. ESRB does show their ratings on their site & tells them what each rating means for a game. But that is for the public, so they are educating people. I think it's wrong that companies send in a video of the most non-violent parts of a game. That is being dishonest, but if that means making more money they are cutting off more their noses to spite their faces & that is not good. Besides even if they did send in the violent parts of a game, wouldn't more adults or over 17+ be inclined to buy the game?

 

 

"It's better to be hated for who you are, then be loved for who you are not." - Montgomery Gentry

"It's better to be hated for who you are, then be loved for who you are not." - Montgomery Gentry

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

On occasion things slip through any rating system, the famous exposed genitals in Teenwolf, the 'suicide ad' on Top Gear etc, no system is perfect, but trying to extract some kind of Thompson-esque conspiracy theory about it all leaves me dubious to say the very least.

I must admit that I can't help detecting sour-grapes involved in the comments, for a start, I was under the impression that the ESRB did not rate from Video only, and secondly, if this is happening so often, how come the last game that was reclassified on the basis of content is Oblivion.

Is the ESRB somehow part of a big conspiracy to fool itself? That doesn't make any sense, I find that I'm wondering about the fact this gentleman has worked with 'several' developers and wonder what the reasons were for leaving each one.

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

I think Racine's lying.

Geaux Saints, Geaux Tigers, Geaux Hornets, Jack Thompson can geaux chase a chupacabra.

Geaux Saints, Geaux Tigers, Geaux Pelicans. Solidarity for the Saints = No retreat, no surrender. 2013 = Saints' revenge on the NFL. Even through the darkest days, this fire burns always.

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

While blowing a whistle at the same time. Kinda makes me envious. I'm still trying to master walking while chewing gum.

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

While it wasn't part of my quoted statement, it's worth mentioning that ESRB works aggressively to educate the public about the ratings, as does the industry at large.  There are some examples of our efforts on our website at http://www.esrb.org/about/education.jsp as well as examples of our PSA campaigns in our Media Library at http://www.esrb.org/about/media_library.jsp. 

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

This is true, but no matter how well the ESRB dose things without a T 15 level to balance things, more and more issues will pile up around the T and M levels. Like E10 you guys need to get on the ball and put in a T15 level where minor gore and foul language(think Halo and Castlvina,war sims with no decapitation/mutliation) wont be wrote off as something strictly "mature".


Until lobbying is a hanging offense I choose anarchy! Stop supporting big media and furthering the criminalization of consumers!! http://zippydsmlee.wordpress.com/


Copyright infringement is nothing more than civil disobedience to a bad set of laws. Let's renegotiate them.

---

Patreon

Deviantart

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

Why is it the best kept secrets are the most logical and common sensical...  Of course publishers will try and get the ranting down to a T for obvious reasons, however I think publishers would be better off if they focused on the ESRB and got them to accept a T15 level so M can be a bit harder content wise.



Until lobbying is a hanging offense I choose anarchy! Stop supporting big media and furthering the criminalization of consumers!! http://zippydsmlee.wordpress.com/


Copyright infringement is nothing more than civil disobedience to a bad set of laws. Let's renegotiate them.

---

Patreon

Deviantart

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

I agree but it's unlikely to happen until the MPAA places a rating in between PG-13 and R or splits the R rating into two catagories like a soft R15/16 and a harder R17/18.

 "No law means no law" - Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black on the First Amendment

"No law means no law" - Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black on the First Amendment

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

The MPAA follows thier rules so poorly it dose not really matter what they do IMO...


Until lobbying is a hanging offense I choose anarchy! Stop supporting big media and furthering the criminalization of consumers!! http://zippydsmlee.wordpress.com/


Copyright infringement is nothing more than civil disobedience to a bad set of laws. Let's renegotiate them.

---

Patreon

Deviantart

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

Well I have played some T-rated games that seem to be on the border line between Teen and Mature, but after the Hot Coffie fiasco I don't think any company would risk deceving the ESBR.

http://www.magicinkgaming.com/

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

Boo friggin' Hoo. The same kind of crap happens between movies and the MPAA.

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

How could that happen? The MPAA requires that the entire movie as intended for release be submitted for review. How would it be possible to withold particular content in order to get a particular rating when the entire movie has to be submitted? I guess you could release a version dissimilar to the one submitted for the MPAA's review and rating but if you get caught doing that, I'd imagine you'd be in deep doo-doo with the MPAA. 

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

Ya put the MPAA has a get out of lable free card with not rated and they soemtiems ignore things to let thier friends get in a film at a lower ranting...not to mention make smokeing an R worthy offence.... the MPAA is corrupted and lax....


Until lobbying is a hanging offense I choose anarchy! Stop supporting big media and furthering the criminalization of consumers!! http://zippydsmlee.wordpress.com/


Copyright infringement is nothing more than civil disobedience to a bad set of laws. Let's renegotiate them.

---

Patreon

Deviantart

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

Unless it's underage smoking, depictions of smoking do not automatically qualify a film for an "R" rating. It is only a factor (among many other factors) which the MPAA, under certain circumstances (e.g., are the depictions of smoking pervasive and do they tend to glamorize smoking, etc.), will consider when rating a film.

And "not rated" isn't a rating which the MPAA gives any film. A film "not rated" usually means that the producers didn't submit the film to the MPAA for a rating or didn't want the rating they received. And if a film isn't rated by the MPAA, it won't get screened in any of the major theatre chains.

Quit making stuff up, Zippy. There's no "media mafia."

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

Ummm no they tried to make smokeing a defult R, and they have a harder time rating some films than the ESRB dose, also they don;t stick frimly to thier rules. "Not rated" is soemthign that at this time can not be done in retial gaming, DVDs use it all the time to not get hit with the NC17 rating.

 

I was merely pointing out all the holes in the MPAA. And BTW I make up less "stuff" than you and DS do :P


Until lobbying is a hanging offense I choose anarchy! Stop supporting big media and furthering the criminalization of consumers!! http://zippydsmlee.wordpress.com/


Copyright infringement is nothing more than civil disobedience to a bad set of laws. Let's renegotiate them.

---

Patreon

Deviantart

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

The MPAA didn't try to make smoking a default "R." The anti-smoking lobby tried to force the MPAA to make smoking a default "R" but the MPAA refused and said they would, instead, consider it as a factor among many other factors. And if DVDs are being retailed without an MPAA rating, that's not the fault of the MPAA. Blame the publishers for selling their DVDs without an MPAA rating. The MPAA, like the ESRB, is voluntary. They can't force a publisher to have an MPAA rating on their product.

And you weren't merely pointing out holes in the MPAA. As usual, you were merely stoking the fires of your "media mafia" conspiracy theory with bullshit facts you either: (a) made up outta thin air or (b) didn't double-check for accuracy. 

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

uhg they would not have tried to make smokeing an R if they were not so buddy buddy with the brain dead anti lobbys, and its well know the MPAA dose not stick to all its rules.


Until lobbying is a hanging offense I choose anarchy! Stop supporting big media and furthering the criminalization of consumers!! http://zippydsmlee.wordpress.com/


Copyright infringement is nothing more than civil disobedience to a bad set of laws. Let's renegotiate them.

---

Patreon

Deviantart

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

Wait, so he doesn't want to depend on groups like the ESRB to educate the audiences, but he doesn't think individual companies should do it either.

...

Who the hell is left?!

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

Rémi "The Rat" Racine. Stop the snitching. You never know. Tomorrow you may need someone to keep your secrets.

Re: A2M CEO: Publishers Mislead ESRB in Hunt for Lower ...

Something gives me the impression that he's bitter he couldn't convince the ESRB to rate his schlocky crap that was Wet "Teen" (well, it got an 18 here in the UK at least).

--------------------------------------------------

I LIKE the fence. I get 2 groups to laugh at then.

-------------------------------------------------- I LIKE the fence. I get 2 groups to laugh at then.
 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Andrew EisenAlso, let's keep Age of Ultron spoilers out of the Shout box for a while yet.05/06/2015 - 9:10am
Andrew EisenMatt - What feminist/anti-feminist insanity are you talking about? Certainly not the contents of the article EZK linked. Maybe the comments of said article?05/06/2015 - 9:10am
Infophile@Wonderkarp: The P.T. re-download issue is apparently limited to the US PSN only. Apparently Europe doesn't have this problem. So perhaps this means it'll be fixed.05/06/2015 - 8:20am
IvresseYou're talking about decisions in general. I prefer to judge decisions on a case-by-case basis.05/06/2015 - 8:10am
MattsworknameIvresse, if you weren't doing that already, you haven't been paying attention the last 5 years.05/06/2015 - 5:09am
IvresseRegarding EA, they can give all the estimates they want. However if they then pull a Square Enix and classify it as a failure when they sell 4-5 million copies, then frankly that's when I start questioning EA's decisions...05/06/2015 - 3:18am
MattsworknameAlso, on a less angry note, who here is playing blood borne. I get the impresion the next 5 to 6 months of my life are gonna go to this game.05/06/2015 - 1:39am
Mattsworknameacting like this.05/06/2015 - 1:25am
MattsworknameIm sorry, but at this point, Im so sick of the whole Feminist/anti feminsit insanity that i'll just say this. The radical parts of both groups have gone BATSHIT. Radicl feminists have no place in polite socity, radicl MRAs same deal. Screw the both them05/06/2015 - 1:25am
E. Zachary KnightSpoilers contained inside, but this is a great look at Black Widow's characterisation in Avengers. http://io9.com/black-widow-this-is-why-we-can-t-have-nice-things-170233303705/05/2015 - 9:57pm
WonderkarpWithout losing P.T.. Which is an awesome game.05/05/2015 - 9:04pm
WonderkarpDamnit. Not only is the P.T. Demo leaving the PSN, you also cant Redownload it! Meaning if you Delete it, its gone. http://nichegamer.com/2015/05/you-better-keep-that-silent-hills-demo-installed-you-cant-re-download-it/ Now I cant upgrade my HD05/05/2015 - 9:04pm
MattsworknameIm actaully glad to see anita doing posistive videos, I had lots of issues with her older FF stuff, but her more recent stuff is alot better and more of what I want to see, positive female charecters getting praised.05/05/2015 - 6:01pm
WonderkarpThat is one hell of a prediction from EA. I dont know if it'll hit that, but still...Battlefront...though a crippled battlefront. few games I can imagine could hit that salesnumber. Battlefront is one of them.05/05/2015 - 5:52pm
MechaCrashI wonder how much of the game they'll hold back as DLC.05/05/2015 - 5:51pm
Andrew EisenI wonder if development went so over budget that EA HAS to announce such a lofty estimate.05/05/2015 - 5:49pm
Andrew EisenYeah, best of luck and all but that strikes me as a gross overestimate.05/05/2015 - 5:47pm
Matthew Wilsonhttp://www.vg247.com/2015/05/05/star-wars-battlefront-sales-figures-predictions/ EA its nuts. there is no way it sells 10 million copies. I will buy that game, but come on.05/05/2015 - 5:43pm
ZippyDSMleeWonderkarp Sega would have to make somethign worthwhile tho....05/05/2015 - 5:41pm
Matthew Wilson@wond dont forget creative assembly. sega still has a big pc part.05/05/2015 - 5:11pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician