Study Indicates Gaming (and TV Viewing) Could Lead to Something

July 6, 2010 -

Playing videogames and watching television are linked with attention problems in kids, at least according to a study authored by Edward Swing, David Walsh, former head of the National Institute on Media and Family, and Iowa State University’s Craig Anderson and Douglas Gentile.

Television and Video Game Exposure and the Development of Attention Problems (PDF) is published in the latest edition of Pediatrics and sampled 1,323 “middle childhood participants” across a 13-month session. A second sample of 210 adolescent and early adult participants was utilized as well.

The study began by offering, “Many video games seem to share many features (eg, high excitement, rapid changes in focus) that have been identified as potentially relevant to the television association with attention problems, making a similar association between video game playing and attention problems plausible.”

The results did find a correlation between playing videogames and “greater attention problems,” and the researchers noted that the attention problems emerging from games were “similar in magnitude to the television association.”

It was also cautioned that “it is possible that certain types of television programs and video games are associated with attention problems whereas others are not.” The researchers went out of their way to note that “there is some evidence that educational television is not associated with increased attention problems,” but did not make a similar case for videogames.

The academics also threw another statement against the wall in the hopes that it would stick, stating, “… there are theoretical reasons to believe that slower paced educational, nonviolent content is less likely to cause attention problems, but more studies on this issue are especially needed.”

Given the inclusion of Gentile and Anderson, a pair whose research constantly seeks to vilify or belittle videogames, one has to wonder: if the results of this study somehow did not implicate games (or television) as a factor in later attention problems, would the study have been published at all? Were the results shaped from the beginning?


Thanks HarmlessBunny, SimonBob and Wai Yen Tang!


Comments

Re: Study Indicates Gaming (and TV Viewing) Could Lead to ...

 Um, there's one major difference though: Games are interactive. You kind of have to keep your attention on them for a game to work, unlike TV.

Re: Study Indicates Gaming (and TV Viewing) Could Lead to ...

Given the inclusion of Gentile and Anderson, a pair whose research constantly seeks to vilify or belittle videogames

I have to strongly disagree here. It's true that Anderson and Gentile specialized in the negative effects of "violent" video games, but it's not fair at all to imply that their "research constantly seeks to vilify or belittle videogames" as a whole. Gentile in particular published a lot of studies on the positive effects of some video games (e.g. games making better surgeons, "prosocial" games leading to prosocial behavior, etc...). Furthermore, he systematically warns people in his speeches and articles and letters that his purpose is NOT to say that video games are bad. It's sometimes the first thing he reminds to his audience.

They actually consider that video games are excellent and powerful teachers, which means they can teach good and bad things. I personnally don't care much about their teaching potential, but we're very far from vilification. It's one thing to question their research, their methods, their results, etc... but it's another thing to consider them as "anti-games" when they're not.

This being said, I know that most game haters cite Anderson's studies (along with Dave Grossman's rants), but while they parrot his and Gentile's statements on "violent" games, they conveniently forget to mention what they have to say about video games as a whole. To me, the biggest problem isn't Anderson's and Gentile's research, at least not directly. Instead, the biggest problem is the way their research is (mis-)interpreted and recycled for ideological reasons.

 

Re: Study Indicates Gaming (and TV Viewing) Could Lead to ...

I'm sorry but I've read Anderson and Gentile's work very carefully.  They are quite clearly supportive of the "media effects" model and villify video games on a regular basis (this study here has nothing to do with violence, nor does Gentile's work on "pathological gaming).  Both authors have made hard-core positition statements, have repeated refuted statements such as those linking media violence effects sizes to those for important medical effects (a statement debunked several times), and regularly fail to cite any studies which are non-supportive of their view.  They published a book chapter with a set of criteria in which they attempt to link "true experts" on media effects essentially only to those who agree with "media effects" theory.  To the extent that they support "positive" video games, to me this appears to be little more than an effort to convince people not to play violent games, nothing like the kind of cultural support for video games you see in the comments of someone like Henry Jenkins.  Anderson used to (although less so now) regularly invoke school shooting incidents in his papers, despite that reviews by the Secret Service and others have refuted any such link with video games.  In a past study of video games and "attention" Anderson's group's press release made references to ADHD despite that their study never measured ADHD!

The idea that Anderson and Gentile are poor victims of a media or politicians that "misrepresent" their work is nonsense (and I mean no disrespect to you).  Gentile, Anderson and Saleem (2007) the authors clearly egg on other scientists to make more blatantly causal statements to the media.  It is they, Anderson and Gentile themselves, who misrepresent much of their own work.

Re: Study Indicates Gaming (and TV Viewing) Could Lead to ...

I've never see Anderson find a form of media he didn't think was bad.  No he doesn't want things banned but he does argue that there is a causal link between media and aggression.

 

 

http://www.popularculturegaming.com

Re: Study Indicates Gaming (and TV Viewing) Could Lead to ...

If you actually read the study the effects are actually very weak.  For children the beta values for television and video games on attention are all less than .10.  That means video games or television use predicts less than 1% of the variance in attention.

For adults the numbers were a little higher, but mostly less than r = .2 (so around 4% of the variance).

Pretty weak findings that, as usual for this groups of researchers, are blown way out of proportion.

Junk science.

Re: Study Indicates Gaming (and TV Viewing) Could Lead to ...

Exactly how are videogames fraught with rapid changes in focus?  Last time I checked, a level or action encounter in games tend to last for a good amount of time- and lets not forget strategy games.  Are they talking about minigame collections?

Re: Study Indicates Gaming (and TV Viewing) Could Lead to ...

I wonder how many of these 'attention problems' are actually older teachers who are used to slow absorbtion and singletasking not knowing what to make of kids used to a much more rapid flow of information.

I wonder what would happen if they simply spead up the teaching?

I can recall when I was back in HS, I would actually sit and read the textbook in class because I found the lecture frustratingly slow.. it always felt like it was taking forever to get to the point while not actually conveighing any additional information on the topic.

Re: Study Indicates Gaming (and TV Viewing) Could Lead to ...

Teacvhing methods change? Surely you jest! /sarcasm

But seriously yes, our system is far, FAR Too steeped in tradition.

Re: Study Indicates Gaming (and TV Viewing) Could Lead to ...

People say I have A.D.D., they just don't under.. ooh look a chicken!

Re: Study Indicates Gaming (and TV Viewing) Could Lead to ...

"there are theoretical reasons to believe that slower paced educational, nonviolent content is less likely to cause attention problems"

What are these reasons?  Because I happen to think the opposite is true... the number one cause of attention problems is boredom.

------- Morality has always been in decline. As you get older, you notice it. When you were younger, you enjoyed it.
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Goth_SkunkWith GP going down for maintenance, I propose that Andrew do a daily Google Hangout where we can all participate until it comes back.08/31/2015 - 7:21pm
RedMageOnly NOW? Not even when they threw Silent Hills and PT under a bus?08/31/2015 - 7:11pm
WymorenceAnd with this, Konami needs to go die in a ditch somewhere08/31/2015 - 7:05pm
PHX Corphttp://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1104842 NeoGAF: MGSV FOBs beyond the first must be bought via microtransactions08/31/2015 - 6:54pm
RedMageKonami: Proudly living in dodoland since 2010 or so.08/31/2015 - 6:51pm
WymorenceSo tell me again, Konami, why you've still got physical retail copies of your game...?08/31/2015 - 6:48pm
Andrew EisenHa! The only thing on Metal Gear Solid 5's PC disc release is a Steam installer! http://www.destructoid.com/the-only-file-on-the-pc-retail-version-of-the-phantom-pain-is-a-steam-installer-308547.phtml08/31/2015 - 6:39pm
Wymorenceglad to hear the 'old' 3DS amiibo NFC reader adapter is only going to be $20 though08/31/2015 - 6:26pm
WymorenceSmaller? Dear god, my 3DS XL is perfect for my hand size...08/31/2015 - 6:26pm
PHX CorpFinally: The Smaller New Nintendo 3DS Model is Coming to North America http://www.nintendolife.com/news/2015/08/the_smaller_new_nintendo_3ds_model_is_coming_to_north_america08/31/2015 - 5:47pm
InfophileRetailer exclusives are the worst preorders, especially when there's more than one. It's just trying to take advantage of the hardcore fans who want all the bonuses.08/31/2015 - 5:00pm
Andrew EisenNeat idea for a comic: single parent trying to raise a kid with superpowers. http://www.dennis-liu.com/08/31/2015 - 4:35pm
Goth_SkunkFound a fascinating youtube series from The Oxford Union: Right To Free Speech And Right To Offend. http://ow.ly/RBGLH08/31/2015 - 4:31pm
Goth_SkunkBig Perm sure likes people's hair. Sadly, I shave my head bald, so I will never be noticed by their fine tastes. D:>08/31/2015 - 4:28pm
Andrew EisenMethinks Super Podcast Action Committee will be talking pre-order shenanigans this weekend!08/31/2015 - 3:59pm
Andrew Eisenhttp://www.capcom-unity.com/gregaman/blog/2015/08/31/sfv-pre-order-costumes-and-collectors-edition-for-north-america08/31/2015 - 3:52pm
Andrew EisenMore pre-order crap but pretty neat alt-costumes for Street Fighter 5. Love it when they take the time to model new outfits and hairstyles as opposed to going the easy route with a palette swap. Pick your favorite because each is retailer exclusive...08/31/2015 - 3:52pm
WymorenceI wish I could say I'm surprised by Squenix's actions here, but I recall one of the last Tomb Raiders doing the same thing...08/31/2015 - 3:49pm
PHX Corphttp://www.polygon.com/2015/8/31/9232741/deux-ex-mankind-divided-preorder-stunt Deux Ex: Mankind Divided is the latest AAA game to hold its biggest fans in contempt08/31/2015 - 2:49pm
Big PermHer hair does look pretty good tho08/31/2015 - 2:34pm

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician