EA Unflinching in its Support of Medal of Honor

August 25, 2010 -

Electronic Arts is not backing down from criticism over letting gamers don the role of the Taliban in Medal of Honor multiplayer. In a recent interview with Develop, EA Games President Frank Gibeau, used "The Red Badge of Courage" and "The Hurt Locker" as examples of art imitating life - something the company contends it is doing with its new Medal of Honor game.

"At EA we passionately believe games are an artform, and I don't know why films and books set in Afghanistan don't get flack, yet [games] do," EA Games President Frank Gibeau told Develop Online. "Whether it's 'Red Badge of Courage' or 'The Hurt Locker,' the media of its time can be a platform for the people who wish to tell their stories. Games are becoming that platform."

Critics have taken issue with EA letting gamers play as the Taliban, the real enemy that NATO forces are dealing with on a daily basis in Afghanistan. Gibeau acknowledged that allowing gamers to play as a Taliban solider is a bit of a "creative risk," but he said that EA won't give in to the media outcry that wants to "compromise our creative vision and what we want to do."

Gibeau also points out that setting the game in Afghanistan is a normal and natural move for the company because the Medal of Honor games are always set in real "war zones."

"That's always been a Medal of Honor concept--we put you in the boots of a solider, whether it's in the Pacific, Europe, Afghanistan; it's always been the story of the solider," he told Develop Online.

Ultimately EA wants to stand up for the game because it is an important and popular franchise, and because it doesn't want its game to end up like Atomic Games' and Konami's Six Days in Fallujah, which ended up being cancelled due to public pressure.

Medal of Honor is scheduled to launch on October 12 for the PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, and PC.

Source: C|Net

Posted in

Comments

Re: EA Unflinching in its Support of Medal of Honor

Their original defense of "it's just a game" makes this new "we believe in games as an art form" defense seem a little ridiculous to be honest. Not that I disagree, but I really believe EA is handling this very poorly.

Re: EA Unflinching in its Support of Medal of Honor

I would have to agree to a point. Games purely exist for entertainment whilst films and books don't have to be entertaining, for instance I wouldn't exactly call Schindler's List entertaining.

Whilst I don't have a problem with MOH, I wouldn't call it "art".

Re: EA Unflinching in its Support of Medal of Honor

So, you ever played Go? Steel Panthers? ArmA?

Saying that a game is "purely to entertain" it is to offend lots of people that believe in the "homo ludens" theory and use game as teaching tool, including all the armies around the world, the army of brazil for example bought some tank simulators and modded them heavily, and I must say: Yes, I had fun playing them, but yes, I had to learn how to behave in a real tank and learn real team work (to pilot a tank you need 4 people).

Or some places that are accepting training in Microsoft Flight Simulator as "real" (even if valued less hours) flight.

And go tell the authors of "flower" that their game cannot be art.

criadordejogos.wordpress.com

--- MaurĂ­cio Gomes twitter.com/agfgames

Re: EA Unflinching in its Support of Medal of Honor

Doesn't the fact that you're referring to them as "simulators" tell you something? Just because something shows a virtual reality doesn't make it a game. People can have fun at school or work and learn but it doesn't mean it's a game. Enjoyment does not equate to a game.

I haven't heard EA refer to MOH as a war simulator.

Also so what if I offend people? Tough, people don't have a right not to be offended (even if there wasn't anything offensive in the first place, you've just decided to take offence).

Re: EA Unflinching in its Support of Medal of Honor

The people complaining about this are probably the same that complain about kids having toy guns.  I never heard anyone complain when one team was Nazis in all of those WWII games.  

Pwnage of Empires

Re: EA Unflinching in its Support of Medal of Honor

Good for EA and, frankly, kudos to those who aren't comfortable with the Taliban being a playable option.  As far as I've seen, none of them are attempting to infringe on my rights to play this game as the developers intended.

EDIT: After some thought, I'm going to amend my above comment.  Suggesting retailers don't stock a game would limit my access to it if they followed such a suggestion.  That I can't abide.  Fox would have done better to recommend that like-thinking folks show EA what for by refusing to buy the game.  That puts the decision exactly where it belongs: in the hands of the consumers.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: EA Unflinching in its Support of Medal of Honor

As I pointed out when I wrote an article relating to this, no one complained about the ability to play as various terrorist forces in Counter-Strike, nor the ability to play as the OpFor (Opposing Force) in CoD4... which happened to be middle-eastern appearing terrorist.

Though it was rather blunt in their previous statement, "someone's gotta be the cop, and someone's gotta be the robber".



----
Papa Midnight
http://www.thesupersoldiers.com

----
Papa Midnight

Re: EA Unflinching in its Support of Medal of Honor

Don't recall anyone griping about COD4 but I do remember complaints over the ability to play as terrorists in Counter-Strike.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: EA Unflinching in its Support of Medal of Honor

I believe the difference is that they are relating to the Taliban as "The Taliban" rather than "insurgency" or "terrorists". Plus remember that this is based off of a real conflict rather than fictional conflicts that have been depicted before.

Re: EA Unflinching in its Support of Medal of Honor

"I believe the difference is that they are relating to the Taliban as "The Taliban" rather than "insurgency" or "terrorists"."

Yes, that would be a difference.  What's your point?  I was merely pointing out that there have been complaints (several, in fact) over the fact that you can play as terrorists, albeit, generic ones, in Counter-Strike.

"Plus remember that this is based off of a real conflict rather than fictional conflicts that have been depicted before."

Was there something in my post that made you think I didn't realize that?  And again, I'm not catching your point.  There have been other games that have come under fire for their depictions of actual events, locations, and peoples and games that escape controversy even when doing the same thing.

One similarity I'm noticing is that the games that cover current events tend to reap the most heated controversy.  Seems like the more time that passes, the more acceptable it is to portray real life happenings.  Perhaps its one of those "too soon" things.

 

Andrew Eisen

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Poll

Which Feminist Frequency video are you looking forward to most?:

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Goth_SkunkI propose that the new TMNT movie was not about making nostalgic adult nerds smile, but introducing the franchise to a new generation of younger fans. And some of those fans may even be kids of the nerds that grew up with the original TMNT.01/28/2015 - 3:55pm
Goth_Skunk...disservice to the franchise. But when I look at it, I see a franchise fanbase that, the last time anything major happened in the franchise, all its fans were kids. Those kids have now all grown up and are adults.01/28/2015 - 3:54pm
Goth_SkunkRemember how Escapists new EIC was talking about nerd culture being "curmudgeonly?" This ties right into that as well. These people I talked with complained about how the new TMNT wasn't being true to its roots and because of that it was doing a great...01/28/2015 - 3:53pm
Goth_SkunkTake TMNT for example: I recently watched the new movie, and I thought it was decent. But a lot of people I've talked with who grew up in the 80's and 90's on the TV show, the video games, and thecollectible toys all unanimously seem to think it's trash.01/28/2015 - 3:52pm
Goth_SkunkRe: Ghostbusters, I don't care if it's a reboot or a sequel, I'm just happy to see another Ghostbusters movie. But it's fascinating to hear people in our age demographic talk nostalgicly about the things we grew up watching or reading.01/28/2015 - 3:51pm
WonderkarpI have a GBA. I dont need to buy virtual console gba games.01/28/2015 - 3:11pm
MonteI wouldn't care about running emulators on the 3DS if nintendo would just release more virtual console games. There are so many titles they could have up but don't. Seriously, its ridiclous that after 3 years they STILL haven't released GBA titles.01/28/2015 - 3:06pm
Wonderkarphttp://www.gamerevolution.com/news/game-boy-color-games-3ds-browser-exploit-30905 Play Gameboy Color Games on the 3ds using a browser exploit01/28/2015 - 2:39pm
prh99http://io9.com/one-of-our-most-popular-special-effects-originally-came-1682151657 Looks like the 1988 anime, Akira and anime in general has effecting popular culture, at least when it comes to special effects.01/28/2015 - 12:26pm
Wonderkarpyeah. some people are salty over it. but that wiki article was filled with vitriol01/28/2015 - 12:06pm
prh99Yeah, I saw people complaining about that, claiming Wales was a hypocrite cause he supposedly removed some feminist editors.01/28/2015 - 11:57am
WonderkarpCivility, Wikipedia, and the Conversation on Gamergate https://blog.wikimedia.org/2015/01/27/civility-wikipedia-gamergate/01/28/2015 - 11:45am
Wonderkarpone thing that surprised me...theres a lot of expanded universe books for star wars, star trek, alien, even videogames like resident evil....why not ghostbusters? There's a comic series and cartoon but thats it01/28/2015 - 11:37am
prh99Well it is Hollywood, remakes are the one thing they can be relied on for.01/28/2015 - 11:34am
E. Zachary KnightSo you want a sequel and not a reboot. Fair enough. I think either could work as you have said yourself.01/28/2015 - 11:32am
Wonderkarpotherwise, let it lie. Next thing you know they'll remake/reboot Alien or Godfather01/28/2015 - 11:28am
Wonderkarpand Ghostbusters is my favorite movie and its aged well. it doesnt need a remake. Just like Psycho didnt need one. If they threw in Dan Aykroyd, kept the original tech, and acknowledged the old films without crappy easter eggs, I'd be on board.01/28/2015 - 11:27am
WonderkarpI dont like Reboots/Remakes. For every Batman begins or Invasion of the Body Snatchers, there's a million Robocops, King Kongs, Star Treks, Amazing Spidermans, Taxis, Clash of teh titans, planet of the apes, footloose.01/28/2015 - 11:26am
prh99Wonderkarp, what more do you need? It's been ~26 years, and Harold Ramis died last year. If they can make something decent, who cares?01/28/2015 - 11:19am
prh99I wonder if they will fall into the trap of making those items more scarce in game in order to get people to pay.01/28/2015 - 11:14am
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician