RPS Editorial on Panorama Game Addiction Show

December 7, 2010 -

Rock, Paper, Shotgun's John Walker responds to the Panorama TV episode on game addiction (it aired on BBC 1 in the UK last night) with an editorial of his own. While acknowledging that he does not "possess the evidence that gaming does not cause addiction," Walker lays into the Panorama episode and its host for producing a slapdash expose on gaming addiction, leading viewers to conclusions without providing any real evidence.

For example, the show promised to provide details on the secret mechanics that keep gamers "coming back for more," but that secret gaming sauce was never revealed during the program. Likewise, while the host talked a lot about studies that claimed to make a connection between gaming and addiction, no proof was ever provided.

Here is a sample from Walker's editorial:

"For the first seven minutes of the programme, reporter Raphael Rowe brings us many references to people being “addicts”, people who suffer from “addiction”. It’s stated as fact, unambiguous. Seven minutes in it’s admitted that there’s no evidence that gaming can cause addiction, but long after they’ve made their position completely clear. In fact, it clearly reminded me of that classic Brass Eye moment where DJ Neil Fox explains to camera that there’s no evidence that paedophiles share most of their DNA with crabs, but it’s still scientific fact. Never mind the facts, the data, the proof; we have an agenda here, and we’re going to demonstrate it through unresearched, unevidenced, anecdotal stories."

And here is another about "experts" the show used to make their point:

"Further proof of addiction in games comes from a scientist who has been studying the subject for many yea… oh wait, no, sorry. An artist who takes pictures of kids playing games, and finds that their faces are different when they watch television. No one ventures the notion that there may be physical differences in how one responds to the passive activity of watching TV and the active participation in gaming. But one kid didn’t blink, so there’s danger.

Read the rest here. Maybe someone will take a serious look at the subject.


Comments

Re: RPS Editorial on Panorama Game Addiction Show

For example, the show promised to provide details on the secret mechanics that keep gamers "coming back for more," but that secret gaming sauce was never revealed during the program

Sorry but they did. They discussed operant conditioning, but the use of it in games is no secret, they sensationalised this area of the programme in the previews. Essentially they said that in order to get gamers to keep coming back for more you have a system where you get rewarded for the more you play on it (crudely discussed as "earning more lives"), basically an XP system and levelling up (with rewards for levelling up), hardly a secret mechanic, but possibly a revelation for the journalist whose own experience of gaming consisted of Pong.

Re: RPS Editorial on Panorama Game Addiction Show

Not that I agree with the documentary, but here is one of the mechanisms that SOME game designers use to "keep them coming back for more."

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/extra-credits/2487-The-Skinner-Box

I still have yet to watch the documentary or read the editorial.  I'll comment more after I do so.

-------

Morality has always been in decline. As you get older, you notice it. When you were younger, you enjoyed it.

------- Morality has always been in decline. As you get older, you notice it. When you were younger, you enjoyed it.

Re: RPS Editorial on Panorama Game Addiction Show

PWNED...

Pretty much what I think about this documental. They don´t have any evidence, but still they will prove the dangers of videogames.

You can´t be fair when you show to your public a dead baby, an idiot mother and a kid without the ability to blink, plus scary music and footage of a shocking long-ass line to get the new Starcraft.

I recognize they didn´t use too much shocking value to prove their points, but still, it was fear-mongering.

Also, the birth of a new meme: randomly giving us extra lives...

 

 

------------------------------------------------------------ My DeviantArt Page (aka DeviantCensorship): http://www.darkknightstrikes.deviantart.com

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Andrew EisenThat hopelessly stupid title doesn't inspire confidence though.11/24/2014 - 9:11pm
Andrew EisenI think Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (ugh, that title!) will be very telling as to the rest of the DC film slate. Who knows? Maybe WB knows what it's doing and will knock it out of the park.11/24/2014 - 9:11pm
WonderkarpProblem with DC's films, MaskedPixelante, is DC isnt making them. WB is. Which is why they fail alot. if WB was smart, they'd have DC Comics make them.11/24/2014 - 9:10pm
Wonderkarpfavorite thing I'm hashing out for the website is I'll feature anybodys game, AAA or Indie, on the front page regardless of who makes it. so long as they gimmie screenshots or a trailer, and info.11/24/2014 - 9:09pm
MaskedPixelantehttp://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/michelle-maclaren-signs-develop-direct-752055 Michelle MacLaren is directing Wonder Woman. Still have no hope for the project.11/24/2014 - 9:08pm
Andrew EisenI'm sure someone could come up with something regarding barrel jumping but there's certainly a lot of fun stuff to mine out of the scenario and back story.11/24/2014 - 9:03pm
Wonderkarpand the defining trait of a Game is that it should be fun.(Thank you Nintendo)11/24/2014 - 9:00pm
Wonderkarpwe can talk about games, but there's no existential questions regarding Mario jumping over Barrels to beat a Monkey.11/24/2014 - 8:59pm
WonderkarpGaming won 1st Ammendment Rights. Its Already Legit. Nobody can legislate against it. So just enjoy.11/24/2014 - 8:57pm
Wonderkarplike, in early nintendo power, they would write these little blurbs. Not really crapping on the game if its bad. Kinda hinting at it. I want people to play the games for themselves. One Persons Duck Tales is another Persons Festers Quest.11/24/2014 - 8:55pm
black mantaRight. "Leave us alone to let us play our video games devoid of of deeper analysis and influence. They're just playthings." You do realize how damaging that is; potentially undoing everything we in the ECA have fought for to legitimize gaming?11/24/2014 - 8:50pm
Andrew EisenI have no idea what that means but hey, good luck with that and post a link when it's ready for prime time.11/24/2014 - 8:49pm
Wonderkarpno editorials unless absolutly necessary, no scored reviews. Reviews are going to be ambiguous ala classic Nintendo Power11/24/2014 - 8:47pm
WonderkarpI decided I'm going to pull the trigger on my website I've been working on. Getting some people together. I want to make a Gaming News Site that only cares about the Games.11/24/2014 - 8:46pm
Matthew Wilsonin the end, I dont think its a big deal.11/24/2014 - 8:44pm
WonderkarpRight, I'm not going to argue with Black Manta. I've already argued once today on the Internet. Thats one time too many. Anybody hear about the Star Wars Spinoff news?11/24/2014 - 8:43pm
black mantaIf it's imprtant at all.11/24/2014 - 8:43pm
black mantaI'm with Andrew. I fail to see how this really improves anything. The importance of this is overstated.11/24/2014 - 8:42pm
Matthew Wilsonit should be obvious what those links are, but more transparency is never a bad thing in my eyes.11/24/2014 - 8:42pm
Wonderkarpyeah.11/24/2014 - 8:41pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician