European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

December 17, 2010 -

Families who have lost loved ones to the Mafia are fighting against Mafia II, One of those people, Sonia Alfano, lost her father to the mob on January 18, 1993. She has come out against the video game Mafia II, saying that it trivializes the violence and murder committed by organized crime. Alfano's words carry a lot of weight because she is a member of the European Parliament. She is fighting to get the game banned in Europe. She is also the president of Italy’s association for the families of Mafia victims.

"It really, really hurts," Alfano, recently said in an interview. "We can’t allow this to happen, our wounds are still too fresh."

Last week she asked the European Commission to consider banning the game.

"These games transform the Mafia, a reality of death and destruction, into a thrilling and hands-on virtual pastime," she said. "Even if momentarily, players identify with brutal killers and for us who have experienced violence firsthand, it’s appalling."

Take Two defends the game and compares it to other entertainment based on organized time:

"Mafia II tells a compelling story about organized crime in America -- a subject that for decades has been featured in award-winning movies, television shows and novels such as ‘The Godfather’ and ‘The Sopranos,’" said Alan Lewis, Take-Two’s vice president for corporate communications and public affairs. "We fully and completely stand behind our creative teams and products, including Mafia II."

In Europe, Mafia II is rated 18+ for graphic violence and adult language. According to the Guinness Book of World Records, Mafia II uses the "f-word" 397 times.

Source: Bloomberg


Comments

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

Yes, entertainment media trivializes violence. But that's not a reason to ban it. People died in the Napoleonic Wars, but that doesn't make the novel War and Peace a trashy book by an insensitive author.

Some people need to grow up! Life is not a kindergarten in which everyone will be protected from the psychological harm that derives from their own personal traumas. Other people don't need to have their lives impacted by Sonia Alfano's trauma. Life is traumatic enough - we shouldn't need to bear the burden of everyone's loss.

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

Has anyone actually considered the logistics in this ban? If it is proposed to the EU then the ban would be Europe-wide, so no country within the EU would be allowed it.

This was one of the concerns over PEGI replacing the BBFC's limit role (and to make PEGI legally binding) is that each country within Europe has a different culture and what is offensive in one country isn't in another. If one country decides that the game isn't for them then they can potentially force that decision onto all other countries.

It's one thing to call for a ban in your own country, but it's quite another to call for a ban in other countries too. Typical European interference.

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

 I know the man was her father, but 17 years is not fresh. 

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

I can understand when people want to ban video games because they think they make children violent (which I know has not been proven) and then those people think the kids will go on a shooting rampage because of it, but banning a game because it reminds a person of something that happened is something I can not stand. If you don't like it don't play it, but others do want to play it. If no one wanted to play the game we wouldn't need a ban. So really what she is doing is telling those who want to play a harmless game cannot because she doesn't like it.

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

"...our wounds are still too fresh."

Obviously, this is the new catch phrase for tin-pot-dictator-wannabes who want a tool to justify violation of Human Rights, ie. Freedom of Speech/Expression.

Do I have sympathy for her?  No.  Why?  Because she is exploiting the violent and horrid acts committed against her family for nothing more than a tool to violate the Human Rights of other individuals.  She is, in fact, exploiting her family.  So, no, I have no sympathy for what I preceive to be her FALSE "wounds".  I have sympathy for the family members that were harmed, but that is a totally seperate issue from this because what happened to those individuals occurred in the real world.  The product we are talking about is based in fiction.  And fiction and reality are two seperate things.

Nightwng2000

NW2K Software

http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000

Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Nightwng2000 NW2K Software http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000 Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

Actually, it's more of civil rights that human rights.

I don't recall freedom of speech (especially your definition of it) being a human right.

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

From the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 19:

  • Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.
 

This document was adopted and proclaimed by the United Nations in 1948.  Though, at last check, the US had only signed, but not ratified, the UDHR, and the UK's stance on it I am not aware of, the US has a tendancy to take umbrage with any country that does not abide by the Human Rights which the US has been know to recognize. 

The UDHR is a representation of the Human Rights that ALL individuals should be recognized as having, and not limited to what any individual country recognizes.

And, yes, it should be noted that Article 19 has been under attack for more than a decade in an effort to place limitations, such as religious limitations prohibiting "blasphemy", as well as other departments and organizations within the UN who actively contradicted Article 19 by their very actions, such as the demand to have a computer game, created and commercially sold only in Japan, banned from existance (you recall the Rapelay case?).

Nevertheless, regardless of various contradictions, conflicts, self serving agendists' demands, Article 19 clearly shows Freedom of Speech/Expression to be among a number of Human Rights.  And no national boundary should place a limitation as to the recognition of those Human Rights.  Whether that nation be the US, a member of the UK, or any other nation or other government boundary.

Nightwng2000

NW2K Software

http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000

Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Nightwng2000 NW2K Software http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000 Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

 Then you'd better raise a stink with the EU.  Free Speech protections fall under human rights protections. 

Also, explain how people living under regimes that restrict freedom of speech are not having their human rights violated?  

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

Just curious: does the Guinness Book of World Records count the f-bomb 397 times during a play-through or how many times it appears as a unique recording? If it's the former, I'm sure there's a character spouting obscenities during a fight or something who could loop forever and break that record, if one so chose.

As for Sonia Alfano: I'm sorry, but her calls to ban the game are most likely an offer we can refuse.

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

"It really, really hurts," Alfano, recently said in an interview. "We can’t allow this to happen, our wounds are still too fresh."

I mean no disrespect or malice when I say this: Not "our" wounds, but YOUR wounds.

I am sorry that Sonia lost a family member to the mob. However this game doesn't make you a member of the mob. It is entertainment like the Soprano's, Godfather, Goodfellas, etc. If Sonia feels offended, that is too bad and I can understand. However she should not push her beliefs unto others...

---------

James Fletcher, member of ECA Canada

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

And ban racing games because they might hurt people who have lost loved ones to car wrecks.

Re: European Parliament Member Wants Mafia II Banned

Good idea brinng up other mafia based tv shows and movies. If they want Mafia 2 banned they should try to go after all mafia related products NOT just games.

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Poll

Best decade for video games?:

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Matthew WilsonI know most of my friends first saw robotech when it was on Toonami in the mid 90s, but it is possible that a fan who watched it in the 80s are in a position to do it.03/27/2015 - 1:04pm
Andrew EisenRobotech was mid 80s. Fans of the show (who were kids when it aired) are my age and older.03/27/2015 - 1:01pm
Matthew Wilsontiming. anime only really became widely known in the US in the mid 90s. if we assume it was mostly kids watching it, they still wouldnt be high enough in managment to be given full creative control yet. it would still be another 5 to 10 years for that.03/27/2015 - 12:59pm
Andrew EisenI agree. Now what makes you think that there is no one in power who cares about (or has the ability to) make a good adaptation?03/27/2015 - 12:47pm
Matthew Wilsonits not about pratice, it is about people who understand it getting in to positions of power.03/27/2015 - 12:34pm
Matthew Wilsonallot of the comic book characters that have been turned in to good movies started in the 70s or earlier.03/27/2015 - 12:32pm
Andrew EisenWell, if it really does take two generations of practice to get it right, we'll never get good live action adaptations of anime if no one starts making them.03/27/2015 - 12:31pm
Andrew EisenWhat have you seen that would make you say that?03/27/2015 - 12:30pm
Matthew WilsonIt took 2 genarations of comic book reader before we got good comic book movies. I imagine that will be the case for anime as well.03/27/2015 - 12:28pm
Matthew Wilson@AE yes if they have people that understand the content give it a shot, but as far as I can tell that does not look like it is happening in this case.03/27/2015 - 12:26pm
Andrew EisenI understand the skepticism but I don't think "this will never work" and "no one should even bother" are very healthy attitudes.03/27/2015 - 12:11pm
Andrew EisenWhy would you doubt that? A lot of writers are my age and older, the perfect age to be fans of the content. All I'm saying is it's not impossible to get a good Robotech movie. In fact, it's more likely today than any other time.03/27/2015 - 12:11pm
Matthew Wilson@AE the difference is in the case of marvel the writers and directors clearly understand the source content. I doubt many of any of them are that way with robotech, or any anime for that matter.03/27/2015 - 11:10am
MaskedPixelantehttp://www.playstationtrophies.org/news/news-15838-Sony-Cuts-the-Price-of-PlayStation-TV-Today.html Sony cuts the price of the Vita TV in the UK, still wont force developers to make their stuff compatible with it.03/27/2015 - 10:49am
Andrew EisenMechaCrash - It's true, there are a lot of examples of crap adaptations. But there are increasing numbers of great adaptations such as the Marvel movies. That said, it's certainly going to be an uphill battle at Sony, especially with Tom Rothman around.03/27/2015 - 10:45am
ZippyDSMleeOh live action crap...I dunno with hollywood being stuck in the 90s grimdarkblack mode I can not see how anything would work well other than SNK or Akira.. then again Akira is a bit of head trip...03/27/2015 - 10:11am
MechaCrashI meant Hollywood in general. If they did a Robotech movie, it'd just be a slightly tweaked Macross, because usually when people talk about Robotech, they just mean the first third. Nobody cares about the Masters/Southern Cross or Invid/MOSPAEDA stuff.03/27/2015 - 9:36am
ZippyDSMleeYes Macross is good..... robotech....not so much..... Now Pizza Cats that's the definitive TV dub, if not best dub ever I'd put it up there with COwboy Bebop just becuse the Pizza Cats dub is fun as heck and crazy,Medabots and Fighting Foodons are decent.03/27/2015 - 9:20am
InfophileAged well plot-wise, I mean. The animation is showing its age, but if you don't mind that, the plot holds up quite well03/27/2015 - 6:52am
InfophileRobotech may be 30 years old, but it's actually aged pretty well. Plus, one of the three Japanese franchises that went into making it, Macross, is coming out with a new series soon. So it's far from forgotten or out-of-date03/27/2015 - 6:50am
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician