Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on Arizona Killer

January 12, 2011 -

An article in Scientific American featuring comments from psychologist Craig Anderson (director of the Center for the Study of Violence at Iowa State University) and psychologist Christopher Ferguson (Texas A&M International University) comes to the conclusion that many in the media are drawing conclusions with little evidence when it comes to Arizona killer Jared Loughner.

While the media tries to say that Loughner was influenced by heavy metal music, angry political speech, and video games, both Anderson and Ferguson agree that more details on the individual are required to come to any kind of conclusion.

Here's what Anderson says about it:

"The problem in any specific case is that you can't really know for sure whether an incident would have happened had not there been, say, a lot of media violence exposure," says psychologist Craig Anderson, director of the Center for the Study of Violence at Iowa State University. "In this particular case, we can't really know whether such shootings would have taken place had there not been this recent history of fairly nasty political exchanges in the press."

Ferguson zeros in on video games:

"There is still some debate about whether it is a risk factor, and I would argue that it's not," Ferguson says of video games, noting that violent crimes among juveniles have been on the decline even as games have increased in both prevalence and graphicness.

Similarly, studies by Ferguson and by other researchers, such as economist Todd Kendall, have found a decrease in rates of rape that coincides with increased availability of pornography. "Once again you see this sort of inverse relationship across not just in the U.S. but in other countries as well between pornography consumption and the actual rates of sexual violence," Ferguson says. That does not mean that video games prevent violence, or that pornography curbs sexual crime, but it does highlight the difficulty in establishing a casual relationship between any one medium and a group's behavior, let alone the actions of an individual.

Ferguson goes on to say that many are being irresponsible:

"It's irresponsible in my opinion to start blaming anything until we know more about this individual," Ferguson says. "I think we're really rushing to judgment, and that's not to say that I like this kind of political speech. I find it atrocious, like everybody else."

Anderson agrees:

"I think it would be fair to say that when political discourse gets more and more strident, and when there are images portrayed on the Web where you have a scope sight as part of your attack on your political opponent, that isn't helpful. I think that's safe to say. But whether or not it plays any major causal role in any given case, it's just impossible to say."

Image source


Comments

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

I stumbled this week when I realized I was being a hypocrite.  I've been in opposition to the notion that violent media makes people violent, that playing a video game makes someone more likely to pick up a gun and shoot someone.  But when this tragedy broke, I was more than happy to jump on the bandwagon with blaming incendiary political discourse (like some Tea Party favorite saying we may need a "second amentment solution" to the health care reform debate, suggesting that maybe they should just arm themselves and shoot up people they disagree with) as a key factor in his decision to kill.  I hate the political climate today, there's no room for compromise.  And a lot of media personalities are feeding on the insecurities and fears of the people to push an "Us versus Them" mentality.  But I have to accept that this wasn't what caused him to kill.

Video games don't turn normal kids into sociopathic monsters, it just happens that sociopathic monsters are drawn to violent media.  They're already like that.  So too, this guy was off his rocker.  Maybe all the nasty rhetoric and conspiracy theorists fed into his delusions, but it didn't cause it.  Millions of normal people who listen to the Becks and Palins of the world, are appauled by what this man did.  Their opinions may be swayed, but they're not being brainwashed into doing violent criminal acts.

It's like another guy last year.  Avid Beck fan, became convinced that the gov't was coming to get him and his guns.  So when some police entered his appartment building one day, he killed 3 of them.  Beck may be an asshole, but he didn't make this guy kill those cops.

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

It's true...it's always easy to point a facile finger of blame at something you don't value.  That's much of what fuels the video game moral panic.  My hats off to you for recognizing it (we all do it of course).  Now if only the rest of America could do the same...

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

Well, there's a subtle difference. Video games don't urge people to kill people. People on the far political right have been doing just that, with phrases like "We need a second amendment solution". The words "Who will rid me of this turbulent priest" come to mind. Murderous words, unlike violent video games, can lead to people getting killed.

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

Which is why Incitment to Violence is not consitutionally protected, but violent storytelling is.

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

And maybe, some day, people will understand that being drawn towards certain types of media because of your underlying issues is not the same thing as said media causing those underlying issues.

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

Wow ! Craig Anderson and Christopher Ferguson actually agree on something... Doesn't happen very often.

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

This guy, from what I've been reading, has a big language hard-on.  Unfortunately this is coupled with the fact that he is not as deep as he believes himself to be.  The reason that he shot Giffords in the first place is due to the fact that he had previously posed the question: "If words have no meaning then what is government?", and he didn't like her answer to his pseudo intellectual bullshit.  And apparently after that fact that he dropped Giffords name a LOT in conversation.  Because she couldn't answer his, uknown to him, meaningless bullshit he stewed on it endlessly.

-Ultimately what will do in mankind is a person's fear of their own freedom-

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

In an article about the dangers of speculating on the motives of the shooter, you speculate on the motives of the shooter. Thanks for the contribution to the betterment of society.

E. Zachary Knight
Oklahoma City Chapter of the ECA
http://www.theeca.com/chapters_oklahoma

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

Oh, well I guess we should ignore the fact that the people closest to him have said that he was completely obsessed with the congrress woman and the, in his words, inadequate answer to his question.

Instead lets just go, I DUNNO.  It is so much easier that way.  Thanks for hindering society.

Is it really so wrong to say that a crazy person was crazy?  Really?  You know sometimes things are cut and dry.  If a guy killed someone who slept with his wife, are we going to do some deep introspective and try to see if his mother hugged him enough when he was a child or some other crap and ignore the obvious?

-Ultimately what will do in mankind is a person's fear of their own freedom-

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

I agree, that's not speculation, that's something he really was obsessed with.  And incident with his stupid question didn't "make him do it," rather it just focused his crazy vibes on Gifford.  Nobody's saying that he killed her because she couldn't answer his bullshit question, we're just noting that it created a (loose) history between the shooter and Gifford.  I think Erik's first post is valid.

Quite simply, he had mental issues and killed someone he didn't like.

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

"Nobody's saying that he killed her because she couldn't answer his bullshit question..."

Is she dead? Last I heard she was doing okay.

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

Exactly.

-Ultimately what will do in mankind is a person's fear of their own freedom-

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

I think once you throw in schizophrenia, everything else becomes pretty much meaningless.

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

It's not too soon to judge the influences on him. The guy was a grade 1 nutter. Being a complete wack-job influenced him to kill. Anyone who has read his YouTube rants can see that this guy was at least as batshit-crazy as Dr. Strangelove's Brigadier General Jack D. Ripper. Jared Loughner's loony warnings about 'mind control'' sound a lot like Jack D. Ripper's fear of his 'precious bodily fluids' being sapped.

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

How many friends does this guy actually have (or had)?  Did people go out of their way to include him in their circle or did they eschew him and mock him?  Any girlfriends or romantic relationships?  Close friends provide stability in a person's life even with unstable individuals.

- Left4Dead

Why are zombies always eating brains? I want to see zombies that eat toes for a living. Undead-related pun intended.

- Left4Dead Why are zombies always eating brains? I want to see zombies that eat toes for a living. Undead-related pun intended.

Re: Researchers Agree: Too Soon to Judge Influences on ...

 What I find fascinating about this particular case is that this guy turns out to be quite complex- with conspiracy theories, book/movie influences, and quirks that span all over the political spectrum.  This guy has aspects that identify with both the right and left as well as traits that each political dogma pruportes (spelling WTF) to hate.  

This guy is mentally unstable but also turns out to be a real person who can't be easily pigeon-holed into a particular designer strawman...regardless of what MSNBC, FoxNews, or the 700 Club would have us believe.

Sadly, considering that people were already pointing fingers at their favorite strawmen before the crime scene was even cleared, it proves that we are living in classy times indeed.

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Andrew EisenMeanwhile, 6 of Wii U's top 12 are exclusive: Mario 3D World, Nintendo Land, Pikmin 3, Mario Kart 8, Wonderful 101, and ZombiU. (Wind Waker HD is on the list too but I didn't count it.)09/01/2014 - 4:36pm
Andrew EisenLikewise, only two of Xbox One's top 12 are exclusive: Dead Rising 3 and Ryse: Son of Rome (if you ignore a PC release later this year).09/01/2014 - 4:34pm
Andrew EisenNot to disrespect the current gen of consoles but I find it telling that of the "12 Best Games For The PS4" (per Kotaku), only two are exclusive to the system: Infamous: Second Son and Resogun.09/01/2014 - 4:30pm
MaskedPixelantehttp://www.joystiq.com/2014/09/01/beyond-two-souls-ps4-trophies-emerge-directors-cut-reported/ MMM MMM, nothing quire like reheated last gen games to make you appreciate the 400 bucks you spent on a new console.09/01/2014 - 4:24pm
Andrew EisenThat's actually a super depressing thought, that a bunch of retweeters are taking that pic as an illustration of the actual issue instead of an example of a complete misunderstanding of it.09/01/2014 - 4:20pm
Andrew EisenObviously, the picture was created by someone who doesn't understand what the issue actually is (or, possibly, someone trying to satire said misunderstanding).09/01/2014 - 4:10pm
Papa MidnightPeople fear and attack what they do not understand.09/01/2014 - 4:04pm
Papa MidnightWell, let's not forget. Someone held their hand in a peace sign a few weeks ago and people started claiming it was a gang sign. Or a police chief displayed the hand signal of their fraternity and was accused of the same.09/01/2014 - 4:04pm
SleakerEither people don't understand that what the picture is saying is true, or the picture was created out of a misunderstanding of what sexism is.09/01/2014 - 3:52pm
Sleaker@AE ok yah that's where the kind of confusion I'm getting. Your tweet can be taken to mean two different things.09/01/2014 - 3:51pm
Andrew EisenSleaker - No. No, not even remotely. The pic attached to my tweet was not made by me; it's not a statement I'm making. It's an illustration of the complete misunderstanding of the issue my tweet is referring to.09/01/2014 - 3:13pm
Papa MidnightIn other news, Netflix states why it paid Comcast: http://money.cnn.com/2014/08/29/technology/netflix-comcast/index.html?hpt=hp_t209/01/2014 - 3:10pm
Papa MidnightAndrew Eisen: Sites like Tumblr make things seem much bigger than they are. A vocal extreme minority start complaining and things go as they do.09/01/2014 - 3:09pm
SleakerAre you trying saying that specific costumes are sexist simply by being included in the game?09/01/2014 - 3:03pm
Andrew EisenSleaker - Seems completely cut and dry to me (of course, I wrote it so that's not surprising). What about it do you find confusing?09/01/2014 - 2:25pm
MaskedPixelantehttp://www.joystiq.com/2014/09/01/icewind-dale-enhanced-edition-now-available-for-pre-order/ Third time's the charm, right guys? Right? Surely Icewind Dale EE can't suck as much as Baldur's Gate 1 and 2 EEs can, right?09/01/2014 - 1:37pm
Sleaker@AE I don't even know what you're trying to say in that tweet.09/01/2014 - 1:28pm
Andrew EisenBy far the most retweeted tweet I've ever tweeted. https://twitter.com/AndrewEisen/status/50617593365333196809/01/2014 - 11:15am
Thomas RiordanNo, certainly not. Anything to prevent that kinda crap.09/01/2014 - 8:18am
SleakerAlthough.. I don't think it hurts anyone if kids think the report is true :P09/01/2014 - 3:26am
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician