PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

March 29, 2011 -

In new court documents filed by PS3 jailbreaker George Hotz's attorney, Stewart Kellar, asked that the court ignore recent SCEA filings that make claims about Hotz "running to South America," owning a PlayStation Network account, and deliberately removing data from hard drives submitted to a third-party for inspection by the court. Kellar also asked the court to deny SCEA jurisdiction in California.

The bulk of Kellar's argument are found in this PDF file, but the main thrust of it is that SCEA does not own or create the hardware and firmware that it alleges Hotz tampered with - that destinction belongs to Sony Japan. They also call into question the power of the PlayStation Network terms of service, claiming that Hotz never used the service at all. In fact, Kellar claims, Hotz never accepted the PSN TOS and that Sony has no evidence to prove otherwise.

There are many other arguments that Kellar makes in the PDF, but if you are too lazy to read it Groklaw has a great summary of everything going on in the case with these latest filings.

Below is Kellar's "closing argument" to the court:

"For the foregoing reasons, Plaintiff respectfully requests the Court to sustain these objec-tions and to strike the testimony referred to above. Further, the Court cannot rely on this declaration as it is not made under penalty of per-jury and because it intentionally attempted to hide relevant evidence from the Court by not showing the serial number that SCEA actually found in its database, which does not match the serial number of the Playstation Computer owned by Mr. Hotz."

Source: PSX-Scene

 


Comments

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

You don't have to create an account to accept the TOS.

By simply setting up and using the product you're accepting it. 

Its clear as day.  This shouldn't even be a case.

The guy f'd up, and he should get what he deserves. Personally I'd burn him at the stake. 

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

Burn him at the stake? You disgust me.

-Greevar

-Greevar

"Paste superficially profound, but utterly meaningless quotation here."

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

Yeah, the guys a hacker accused of enabling piracy. Say you want to throw him if the plank if you're okey with murder.

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

so by your logic, if i bought diablo 2 but never set up an account with battle.net (and thus never accepted that specific ToS), im still bound by battle.net's ToS?

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

In a manner of speaking, yes. But since you're not playing on battle.net, there's no way to break the ToS. Not literally speaking, it's all technical bullcrap. but yeah, the ToS are still there.

"Power means nothing without honor and pride."

http://grifsgamereviews.blogspot.com My video game review site.

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

Funny claiming he never accepted the TOS considering you have to accept the TOS to make an account. 

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

claiming he never made an account.

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

It's a fairly decent argument. This is a civil case and Hotz was under no court order or other obligation to stay in the United States, as long as he maintains communication with his attorney and didn't take anything with him he was specifically ordered to turn over to Sony or the court then yelling about him leaving is completely frivolous.

This case is going to be a nightmare of Electronic Discovery. Judges are notoriously horrible with computer based evidence, they don't understand the tranisitional and necessarily temporary nature of much of the data on a computer.

Should be interesting to see how this proceeds. 

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

Sony, how's that ironclad case working for ya?  About as well as that CD protection system a few years ago, I say.

Nightwng2000

NW2K Software

http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000

Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Nightwng2000 NW2K Software http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000 Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

The one they spent millions developing but was foiled by scribbling on the edge with and eighty nine cent marker?

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

Actually, yes, this is the one I was talking about.  I LOVE throwing it in their face.  BWHAHAHAHAHA!

Nightwng2000

NW2K Software

http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000

Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Nightwng2000 NW2K Software http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000 Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

Me too 8) They spend millions developing it, and someone breaks it for far less than they paid for it, making it worthless.

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

I think he is referring to their root kit fiasco. In which SONY BMG cds installed malware on your computer that disabled many cd rom drives and prevented many 3rd party music players from even playing the cds.

E. Zachary Knight
Oklahoma City Chapter of the ECA
http://www.theeca.com/chapters_oklahoma

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

Ah, ok, so basically they ruined your 500 dollar computer to protect their 12 dollar CD

Re: PS3 Jailbreaker Battles for Motion to Dismiss SCEA Case

Yeah, pretty much.

E. Zachary Knight
Oklahoma City Chapter of the ECA
http://www.theeca.com/chapters_oklahoma

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Mattsworknamei I hope there is, I love that series.04/25/2015 - 5:59pm
Matthew Wilson@matt I am sure there will never be a armored core game04/25/2015 - 5:24pm
Mattsworknameof From softwares recent games, bloodborne is the best work they have done yet, though they really need to get to work on armored core 604/25/2015 - 5:10pm
Matthew WilsonLost Kingdoms came out in 2002 this day. I played that game. I did not relize it was made by From Software. Lost Kingdoms was a good unique hard game.04/25/2015 - 4:56pm
MattsworknameOff topic, but, who heres playing Bloodborne, and if so, is it mercillesly murdering you every chance it gets?04/25/2015 - 7:35am
Matthew WilsonI think its a good article, and devs can take some lessons from life is strange.04/24/2015 - 10:24pm
Andrew EisenI tinyURL'd it. The world is safe!04/24/2015 - 10:23pm
Matthew Wilson@AE my bad there is nothing I can do about that.04/24/2015 - 10:21pm
Andrew EisenLooks like the spoiler is right there in the URL.04/24/2015 - 10:20pm
Matthew Wilsonhttp://tinyurl.com/ok9pf6b a interesting opinion piece on the life is strange episode 2, and a dark event that happens in it. full warning major spoilers.04/24/2015 - 10:11pm
Matthew Wilson@mech no just she, nor her co workers have not. she never said it is not real.04/24/2015 - 8:58pm
MechaCrashWas she saying "I haven't experienced it," or "I haven't experienced it therefore it does not exist"?04/24/2015 - 8:31pm
ZippyDSMleeoy the skyrim paid mod thing is going over well. My 2 lints, I would not mind if Skyrim had a full SDK and not a crappy lil editor....04/24/2015 - 6:46pm
Andrew EisenWell, that is indeed crappy and nonsensical.04/24/2015 - 3:45pm
Matthew Wilsonshe got attacked for saying that she personaly has not experienced the harassment some other female devs have, and she got acused of defending GG and ignoring harassment. she ended up getting dog piled because of it.04/24/2015 - 3:43pm
Andrew EisenFine but do you recall ANY details at all?04/24/2015 - 3:38pm
Matthew Wilsonit was several weeks ago now, and I will admit to not saving it.04/24/2015 - 3:36pm
Andrew EisenAttacked HOW and by WHOM for not writing off WHO as evil? Do you have a link or anything?04/24/2015 - 3:31pm
Matthew Wilsonthat is the whole point she was not attacked for saying anything. she was attacked for being willing to debate in the first place, and not just write them off as evil.04/24/2015 - 3:28pm
Andrew EisenI know there's not a lot of room in the Shout box but goodness you're being vague.04/24/2015 - 3:26pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician