Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or Large in Number'

January 4, 2012

Speaking to political publication Roll Call, SOPA sponsor and House Judiciary Chairman Lamar Smith (R-Texas) took shots earlier this week at critics of the bill that has gained as much bi-partisan opposition as it has support.

"The criticism of this bill is completely hypothetical; none of it is based in reality," Smith said in a statement to Roll Call. "Not one of the critics was able to point to any language in the bill that would in any way harm the Internet. Their accusations are simply not supported by any facts."

When asked about online opposition to the bill from places such as Reddit, Smith was quite dismissive.

"It’s a vocal minority, he said. "Because they’re strident doesn’t mean they’re either legitimate or large in number. One, they need to read the language. Show me the language. There’s nothing they can point to that does what they say it does do. I think their fears are unfounded."

On support from colleagues on his side of the aisle Smith said that the "most important thing [is], they haven’t told me not to go forward. I’m expecting support."

Anyone that watched the markup sessions noted that many members from both sides of the aisle were not happy with the fact that committee did not spend enough time consulting experts before moving to mark up the legislation.

"It’s time to pull the nerds in," Rep. Jason Chaffetz (R-Utah) said.

"There’s an opportunity to negotiate, even big bills like this, before the markup commences. And your chances of being successful are greater in those negotiations than they are in the open debate," Rep. Steve King (R-Iowa) said.

Rep. Dan Lungren (R-Calif.), a staunch critic of the bill in its current form, said the intense criticism of the bill was the result of the short amount of time the committee had to deal with the issue.

"We’ve had controversy over bills before that are dealing with a comprehensive topic, but we’ve always had more time to deal with them, so that the kinds of large differences that you see laid out here have been taken care of in the past," Lungren said.

Rep. Darrell Issa (Calif.), the boldest critic of the bill, has made the markup process difficult, alongside Lungren and others. Recently Issa changed his Facebook profile picture a black box with "censored" in white letters to protest the bill.

Source: Roll Call

 

Buzz It

Comments

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

So, let me get this straight...

 

Google, Facebook, Amazon, and eBay are not legitimate?

 

YouBestBeTrolling.jpg

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

Where are all the (R) of those opposing it? GP is once more one sided! What is that? They're (nearly) all there? Oh well, guess whomever thinks that must be imagining things then...

(No, seriously, you forgot the R for Rep. Darrell Issa (Calif.) ^^ )

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

He should have just come out and said it.

 

"We're being paid by powerful people to pass this and then for us ot look the other way, people who matter more than you"

 

I think part of the problem is that once they serve office so much as once, they're set for life.

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

"The criticism of this bill is completely hypothetical; none of it is based in reality..."

The true problem is that the bill itself isn't based in reality!

 


Ruger is coming out with a new and intimidating pistol in honor of Senators and Congressmen.  It will be named "The Politician."  It doesn't work and you can't fire it!

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

Is it 'The opposing members do don't have the numbers' or 'The opposing members do not have same amount of money to throw around as the people supporting the bill'. Makes me think of the list of people and companies who donated money. The price of buying a politician. 

 - W

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

So he says that those who are opposing this bill either don't exist or aren't as numerous as they say they are.

Right.  What planet is he living on?

The good news is that support for this bill is steadily eroding.  Some of the bigger names as previously reported are withdrawing support (as are several law firms).  What once seemed like an unstoppable juggernaut has been cut down to size, and more and more are standing up to oppose it as word has gotten out.  I remain cautiously optimistic.

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

Maybe if they let some of the critics actually speak in front of Congress about the bill...

Oh, wait, that would then actually force these morons to actually LISTEN to individuals for once, rather than just their corporate overlords.

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

I was hoping that with everyone in Washington going into election mode they would forget about SOPA and we could potentially have this debate at a later time, but I'm beginning to think this might come up sooner than I thought.

-----------------------------------------

Managing Editor at TheBestGameSiteEver.com

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

usually thats how they get these bills passed actually.

they'll wait for something to happen that'll distract the public and then slam these bills through without hardly a glance at it.

its how they got the patriot bill passed, and despite many that voted for it claiming they wouldn't have if they'd actually read it (they actually admitted not reading it) they also never attempted to repeal, so yeah.. politicians in action.

tbh i'm amazed they didn't wait till election month to secretly slip SOPA by.

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

That could work with us, if theyre worried about their jobs because they support sopa well then...

 

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

"Not one of the critics was able to point to any language in the bill that would in any way harm the Internet. Their accusations are simply not supported by any facts."

There's this wonderful thing out there called the Internet.  You should check it out.

"There’s nothing they can point to that does what they say it does do."

That's mostly because the problems with the bill are not what it says, but what it doesn't say.

Dipstick.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

Another bill from an old man who doesn't understand what he's attacking

Re: Smith Says Reddit SOPA Protestors are 'Not Legitimate or ...

EXACTLY!!!!

Old political corporate shills are corporate and old. I'm 43 and I can't even relate to what this gasbag is pushing.

Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Andrew EisenNeedless to say, a chunck of those might not be inclined to plunk down their dough for Nintendo's new console when they just bought a competitor's, compounded with the fact that Nintendo has shown little interest in catering to their needs.02/22/2012 - 5:43pm
Andrew EisenIf Nintendo is serious about courting the core gamer, it can't just ignore them until it releases the Wii U. They'll just get their fix somewhere else.02/22/2012 - 5:40pm
Andrew EisenA game which didn't light the sales charts on fire but didn't bomb either. In fact, from what I've read, NA sales make up a good half of that game's worldwide sales. Not to mention the good will Atlus garners by continuing to cater to gamers.02/22/2012 - 5:34pm
RedMageEspecially when the likes of Atlus seem to have no problem doing a great job localizing something niche like Catherine.02/22/2012 - 2:20pm
Uncharted NESEntertainment Industry Embraces New Business Model: Suing Google For Third-Party Android Apps That 'Promote Piracy'- http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120221/08245617830/entertainment-industry-embraces-new-business-model-suing-google-third-party-android-02/22/2012 - 2:07pm
Andrew EisenHard to imagine the games would sell so poorly that they wouldn't cover the reletively minimal cost of bringing them over (shipping, ESRB rating, new packaging, printing, etc.).02/22/2012 - 2:02pm
Andrew EisenA point I made in that YouTube video I did last summer. The games tend to sell more copies here so if the damn thing is already developed and localized, why not release it here?02/22/2012 - 2:00pm
RedMageThat's what I figured. It's especially ironic since the black and white data shows NA buys more of these games than Europe or even Japan.02/22/2012 - 1:57pm
Andrew EisenAnd honestly, at this point, most probably won't because they saw their were no more games and moved on.02/22/2012 - 1:55pm
Andrew EisenLocalizing for Europe is actually harder. Or at least, more work because typically, you do more languages. I don't think its a matter of difficulty but that Nintendo, for whatever reason, has no faith in NA gamers to actually buy these games.02/22/2012 - 1:54pm
Andrew EisenFatal Frame's localization was also announced! For Europe...02/22/2012 - 1:52pm
RedMageDefinitely the latter. I'd still like to know why Europe is apparently easier to localize RPGs for.02/22/2012 - 1:51pm
Andrew EisenDo you mean the quality of the localization itself or Nintendo's tone deafness when it comes to catering to the NA market.02/22/2012 - 1:45pm
RedMageThat being said, Nintendo still sucks when it comes to localization.02/22/2012 - 1:42pm
RedMageLast Story confirmed for North America in 2012! FINALLY! http://bit.ly/yDVyEY02/22/2012 - 1:42pm
Andrew EisenSounds like an interesting story. Nothing to do with video games I wouldn't think but we're big on free speech rights here. Darn shame Slashdot's link doesn't work.02/22/2012 - 1:32pm
Uncharted NESThe 'New' Righthaven Offers Discount To Techdirt Readers Who Want 'Spineful' Hosting- http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120221/03205417825/new-righthaven-offers-discount-to-techdirt-readers-who-want-spineful-hosting.shtml02/22/2012 - 1:30pm
Uncharted NESMan Ordered To Apologize To Wife On Facebook- http://slashdot.org/palm/17/12/02/22/1448242_1.shtml02/22/2012 - 1:28pm
Uncharted NESSeriously Zippy? Well Happy 36th. :)02/22/2012 - 1:11pm
james_fudgeBREAKING: Happy Birthday!02/22/2012 - 12:37pm

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician