ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

January 20, 2012

The Entertainment Software Association announced that it no longer supports the Stop Online Piracy Act or the Protect IP Act. In a statement released today the trade group representing the video game industry said that it had always intended to support a bill that was balanced and fair.

Of course a simple read-through of either law would indicate that SOPA and PIPA did not take a balanced approach to the internet’s nature of free expression and sharing. In fact it took a draconian approach to enforcement that used the power of the federal government to take down websites without due process. The ESA's statement:

"From the beginning, ESA has been committed to the passage of balanced legislation to address the illegal theft of intellectual property found on foreign rogue sites," the group said in a statement. "Although the need to address this pervasive threat to our industry's creative investment remains, concerns have been expressed about unintended consequences stemming from the current legislative proposals. Accordingly, we call upon Congress, the Obama Administration, and stakeholders to refocus their energies on producing a solution that effectively balances both creative and technology interests. As an industry of innovators and creators, we understand the importance of both technological innovation and content protection and are committed to working with all parties to encourage a balanced solution."

The ESA was widely criticized by the gaming community for being hypocritical on the issue of free speech – particularly in light of the groundswell of support from gamers in their Supreme Court fight against the state of California (Brown v. EMA). Some publications even called for a boycott of the group’s annual game industry event E3.

We’ll leave the pontifications on motivation and sincerity to our readers. We do want to take this time to applaud the ESA for finally and quite publicly dropping its support for these horrific bills.

Source: Kotaku. Thanks to PHX-Corp for the tip. Image Credit: ESA.

Buzz It

Comments

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

Time for a regime change as far as I'm concerned ESA. You've shown your colors and they are a putrid shade of green.

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

Sorry, ESA.  This is too late to be meaningful, and we are understandably cynical about your motivation for making this statement.  We don't believe that this statement is honest or sincere.  You've shown your true colors and tried to throw us under a bus.  And now you want to pretend that it was just a mistake and you really had our best interests at heart all along?  Please.

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

Too little too late. I will no longer buy any games from companies that refused to declare themselves against SOPA while the ESA represented them. For the next year or so I'll just stick to Minecraft and my backlog, after that there's Neverwinter and Shadowrun Online. This customer ain't coming back.

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

"I will no longer buy any games from companies that refused to declare themselves against SOPA while the ESA represented them."

You could buy them used.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

I'd rather play Call of Cthulhu. :) Which is in my backlog, actually.

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

that's what I'll be doing.

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

I'm probably still going to be on an E3 blackout this year.

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

Translation:

"SOPA has been shelved, so we are announcing that we have withdrawn our support so that maybe some sucker will believe we aren't jerks."

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

It's not going to matter anyway for me, ESA just backstabbed us over trying to censor the internet. That's why I'll only watch E3 to find out when the Wii U will come out and that's it

Watching JT on GP is just like watching an episode of Jerry springer only as funny as the fights

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

"As an industry of innovators and creators, we understand the importance of both technological innovation and content protection and are committed to working with all parties to encourage a balanced solution."

This screams of disenginuity.

----
Papa Midnight

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

"Humm...it is popular to hate SOPA/PIPA right now.  We've been looking for a good time to jump ship and we can also come up with a puff piece, I mean, press release that fixes our previous statements to make us look good again to gamers.  Two birds with one stone.

Next:  Well, that didn't work.  Let's come up with ways to distrac....oh look!  An EAGLE!"

- Left4Dead Why are zombies always eating brains? I want to see zombies that eat toes for a living. Undead-related pun intended.

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

The ESA is a slimy group. They are not pulling their support for these bills because of actual concern. They are pulling support for these bills because:

1) The entire gaming public had turned against them.

2) These bills are effectively on life support.

When these bills to come back from the shadows, I have no doubt that the ESA will be right back in with support for them. They may hesitate to test the waters, but their intentions have been made crystal clear these last few weeks.

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

"From the beginning, ESA has been committed to the passage of balanced legislation"

Quit lying when you spin. If you were committed to balance, you wouldn't have supported these montrosities.

 

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

Motivation is easy to find. Reporters were pulling out of E3 left and right.

---You are likely to be eaten by a Grue.

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

Just how many reporters had pulled out of E3 so far? I know some had thanks to the video that had been put out about it.

 - W

Re: ESA Drops Support for PIPA, SOPA

I hope everyone keeps pulling. Make companies understand when you do too little too late, it doesn't make up for things.

 

Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Andrew EisenNeedless to say, a chunck of those might not be inclined to plunk down their dough for Nintendo's new console when they just bought a competitor's, compounded with the fact that Nintendo has shown little interest in catering to their needs.02/22/2012 - 5:43pm
Andrew EisenIf Nintendo is serious about courting the core gamer, it can't just ignore them until it releases the Wii U. They'll just get their fix somewhere else.02/22/2012 - 5:40pm
Andrew EisenA game which didn't light the sales charts on fire but didn't bomb either. In fact, from what I've read, NA sales make up a good half of that game's worldwide sales. Not to mention the good will Atlus garners by continuing to cater to gamers.02/22/2012 - 5:34pm
RedMageEspecially when the likes of Atlus seem to have no problem doing a great job localizing something niche like Catherine.02/22/2012 - 2:20pm
Uncharted NESEntertainment Industry Embraces New Business Model: Suing Google For Third-Party Android Apps That 'Promote Piracy'- http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120221/08245617830/entertainment-industry-embraces-new-business-model-suing-google-third-party-android-02/22/2012 - 2:07pm
Andrew EisenHard to imagine the games would sell so poorly that they wouldn't cover the reletively minimal cost of bringing them over (shipping, ESRB rating, new packaging, printing, etc.).02/22/2012 - 2:02pm
Andrew EisenA point I made in that YouTube video I did last summer. The games tend to sell more copies here so if the damn thing is already developed and localized, why not release it here?02/22/2012 - 2:00pm
RedMageThat's what I figured. It's especially ironic since the black and white data shows NA buys more of these games than Europe or even Japan.02/22/2012 - 1:57pm
Andrew EisenAnd honestly, at this point, most probably won't because they saw their were no more games and moved on.02/22/2012 - 1:55pm
Andrew EisenLocalizing for Europe is actually harder. Or at least, more work because typically, you do more languages. I don't think its a matter of difficulty but that Nintendo, for whatever reason, has no faith in NA gamers to actually buy these games.02/22/2012 - 1:54pm
Andrew EisenFatal Frame's localization was also announced! For Europe...02/22/2012 - 1:52pm
RedMageDefinitely the latter. I'd still like to know why Europe is apparently easier to localize RPGs for.02/22/2012 - 1:51pm
Andrew EisenDo you mean the quality of the localization itself or Nintendo's tone deafness when it comes to catering to the NA market.02/22/2012 - 1:45pm
RedMageThat being said, Nintendo still sucks when it comes to localization.02/22/2012 - 1:42pm
RedMageLast Story confirmed for North America in 2012! FINALLY! http://bit.ly/yDVyEY02/22/2012 - 1:42pm
Andrew EisenSounds like an interesting story. Nothing to do with video games I wouldn't think but we're big on free speech rights here. Darn shame Slashdot's link doesn't work.02/22/2012 - 1:32pm
Uncharted NESThe 'New' Righthaven Offers Discount To Techdirt Readers Who Want 'Spineful' Hosting- http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120221/03205417825/new-righthaven-offers-discount-to-techdirt-readers-who-want-spineful-hosting.shtml02/22/2012 - 1:30pm
Uncharted NESMan Ordered To Apologize To Wife On Facebook- http://slashdot.org/palm/17/12/02/22/1448242_1.shtml02/22/2012 - 1:28pm
Uncharted NESSeriously Zippy? Well Happy 36th. :)02/22/2012 - 1:11pm
james_fudgeBREAKING: Happy Birthday!02/22/2012 - 12:37pm

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician